25 Best Italian Restaurants in Huntington

Angelo's Italian Restaurant Italian • $$$
9 Union Pl, Huntington

Customers` Favorites

Pei Mussels and Shrimp over Linguine Fradiavolo
Lemon Fettuccine Alfredo with Chicken
Spaghetti Carbonara w Chicken
Steak with Gorgonzola Potato
Creme Brulee Cheesecake
Braised Short Ribs Over
Chicken Parmigiana
Veal Saltimbocca
Grilled Octopus
Seared Ahi Tuna

“Excellent! Food was top notch. The scallops were the best my fiancé and I have ever had. He said his gnocchi was the best he’s ever had. We will be back! Staff were excellent as well.Vegetarian options: We are both mainly vegetarian but will eat fish on special occasions. Enough of the menu for us to choose from!“

4.9 Superb97 Reviews
Piccolo Mondo Ristorante Italian • $$$
1870 E Jericho Turnpike, Huntington

Customers` Favorites

Our House Braised Short Rib Meatballs
Cedar Plank Roasted Ora King Salmon
Australian Lamb Lollipops
Mafaldine Bolognese
Artichoke Appetizer
Tuscan Ceaser Salad
Tiramisu
Tartufo
Gnocchi

“This restaurant is a neighborhood gem! I can't say enough about the delicious, inventive, and flavorful menu! The chef is top notch! Roland is a rare restaurateur that truly appreciates every customer and aims to make the dining experience memorable. The waitstaff are always professional and you can sense their passion. Kate at the bar makes the best skinny margarita! We will continue to return again and again.“

4.7 Superb117 Reviews
Joanina Italian • $$$
35a Gerard St, Huntington

Customers` Favorites

Whole Bronzini Veal Parmasan Tortellini Side
Pistachio Crusted Salmon over Spinach
Pappardelle Bolognese
Cavatelli Bolognese
Corvina Oreganata
Linguine Vongole
Chocolate Cake
Wedding Cake
Beet Salad
Scarpiello

“Absolutely amazing! I've been wanting to stop by here for some time now and regret not coming in sooner. My husband wanted to try Farm Italy but Joanina had been calling my name for a year now. He reluctantly agreed came in on a busy Saturday night no reservation. Initially told an hour wait but they were able to seat us in this look nook area within minutes and I absolutely loved this little intimate cozy spot. I love margaritas initially I wasn't going to get one and was going to stick to wine but my husband ordered one as I stepped out to get something from the car. This is now one of my fav places for a good marg! I ended up having 4 usually it's 2 max! We started with a app special burrata, artichokes and peppers and yum yum so delicious! We decided to split a pasta and meat yikes incredibly good! I mean just outstanding pork with eggplant, prosciutto and mozz over a Marsala sauce oh my just incredible! Pasta another hit too perfect amount of cream just a touch and those mushrooms yum! We ended up going back a week later and I went with their bolognese another amazing hit! I also had their creamy burrata with prosciutto just so good. My goal is to try everything on their menu! Their pizzas look amazing too so looking forward in trying them.“

4.7 Superb112 Reviews
Cefalù Restaurant & Pizzeria Italian • $$
138 E Main St, Huntington

Customers` Favorites

Spicy Rigatoni Alla Vodka
Margherita or Vodka Slice
Spaghetti & Meatballs
Lunch Grilled Shrimp
Three Garlic Knots
Eggplant Lasagna
Grilled Chicken
Pepperoni Pizza
Classic Burger
Baked Meatballs

“Cefalu is our family's go to for takeout & delivery. Just haven’t gotten around yet to dining in. We love everything we’ve ever ordered. Pizza is top notch and we even had pivoted during the pandemic from our go to pizza place (for 15+ yrs) to Cefalu since they offered many more choices other than pizza. It was then that we were hooked! Also a must add - ALWAYS superior customer service. Joseph, the owner, has even personally delivered a DoorDash forgotten item and always addresses any order mix ups (hardly any at all) apologetically and quickly. Accountability is a rare quality these days! 200% recommendation Cefalu! You won’t be disappointed - delicious food and great people!“

4.6 Superb60 Reviews
Jonathan's Ristorante Italian • $$$
15 Wall St, Huntington

Customers` Favorites

Flourless Chocolate Cake with Coffee Gelato & Caramel Sauce
Seared Scallops and Risotta with Pacetta and Peas
Burrata Caprese
Bucatini All
Sea Scallops
Branzino

“We never leave disappointed! We had the mushroom rice balls, tuna tartar, the lamb special and the linguine with crab special. All were FANTASTIC. I even requested to make the linguine a little spicy and the chef delivered. We finished our dinner with the dog cheesecake (also a special) and an espresso martini. Jonathans is a hidden gem with amazing food and service!“

4.5 Superb128 Reviews
Osteria Da Nino Italian • $$
292 Main St, Huntington

Customers` Favorites

Pasta Bolognese
Risotto
Gnocchi

“My favorite place for a cocktail. The bartenders are lovely and they always make you feel at home.Love to eat at the bar some nights!Vegetarian options: Gnocchi, artichoke, pasta, eggplant, salad and delicious desserts!Dietary restrictions: Diet friendly. They will find you an option.Parking: Come early and you’ll find parking.Kid-friendliness: Nice family place. They always accommodate.Wheelchair accessibility: Yes! In front and in back.In back is the parking lot too!“

4.6 Superb51 Reviews
Tony's Tacos Huntington Tacos • $
281 Main St, Huntington

Customers` Favorites

Pulled Pork Tacos Chicken Parm Taco Meatball Parm
Taco Alla Scarpetta Birria
Churro Dulce de Leche
Cauliflower Explosion
Steak Supreme
Smoked Salmon
Octopus Taco
Chicken Club
Cheese Pizza
Surf & Turf

“I was very skeptical of this place at first, but it was amazing. So the concept is Italian-Mexican food. It works. And it works very well.We ordered 3 tacos as well as the surf and turf quesadilla. I was absolutely blown away by the taste and quality of everything. The quesadilla was one of the best I've had in a long time. The steak was juicy, the shrimp wasn't chewy, and the flavors were amazing. For tacos, we got the ital-Americano, chicken parm, and maialino. Every one was tasty in its own way. The Ital-Americano was super juicy, the chicken parm was just delicious chicken parm in a shell, and the mialino was juicy with just the right amount of spice.I need to remember next time to sign up for the rewards program since I know I'll be back there a lot.Parking: Parking all over.“

4.5 Superb112 Reviews
Junior's Pizza Pizza • $
142 New York Ave, Huntington

Customers` Favorites

Meatball Parm Hero
Gluten Free Pizza

“We were working on a job nearby Junior’s Pizza, so my crew and I frequented Junior’s at least once a week. The food is amazing, staff extremely nice and helpful. Highly recommend coming here!Get the chicken bacon/bbq sauce pizza .. it’s super good!!“

4.9 Superb13 Reviews
The Farm Italy Restaurant & Bar Italian • $$$
12 Gerard St, Huntington

Customers` Favorites

Stuffed Flounder with Crab Meat Chicken Parmesan Broccolini Cacio E Pepe
Olive Oil Cake with Lemon Zest and Honey
Lemon Olive Oil Cake
Chicken Parmigiana
Bread and Butter
Pasta with Crab
Farm Antipasti
Arugula Salad
Veal Milanese
Baked Clams

“After seeing this place on Instagram, I decided to give it a try. The atmosphere, service and drinks were great but the food, was a big no which makes me feel I won’t come back here.The steak was over cooked and well done instead of medium, the sauce it came with was bitter. The ravioli was cold like it came out the refrigerator, they remade it and then it was chewy, wasn’t boiled well.“

4.4 Superb539 Reviews
New York Panini American • $
9 Wall St, Huntington

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Parmigiana Sandwich
Steak Mozzarella Bacon
Sweet Potatoe Fries
Parmesan Cheese Dip

“easy quick casual panini place. got the piccante and it was *chef’s kiss. excellent combo. definitely satisfied my sandwich craving :)there are a few seats available but definitely not a sit-down kind of place. just a reliable place to get a solid sandwich“

4.5 Superb39 Reviews
BiVio Ristorante Italian • $$
1801 E Jericho Turnpike, Huntington

Customers` Favorites

Wedding Cake Filled with Chocolate Mousse Canoli Cream and Raspberry Mousse
Braised Short Ribs with Risotto
Lobster Ravioli
French Onion
Baked Clams
Pasta Aioli
Skirt Steak

“This is my second review for Bivio. One of our favorite restaurants! Nice atmosphere and attentive staff! They always chill the wine glasses which makes for enjoyable glass of your favorite wine! My husband rarely orders off the menu since their specials always are so good. The menu offers a wide array of dishes. We always have a great meal while enjoying the live music!“

4.4 Superb63 Reviews
Baldanza Bros. Italian • $$
3 Union Pl, Huntington

“Incredibly authentic, delicious Italian food... I have so many favorites, there isn't enough room to write it all! This place has been a staple in my life for many years, and the family always treats me like family when I'm there. Fresh, delicious, high-quality Italian food that never disappoints!“

4.4 Superb27 Reviews
Rocco's Pizza & Catering Pizza • $
247 Broadway Greenlawn, Huntington

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Alla Vodka-Perfectly Seasoned Ponk Sauce
Drunken Grandma Pizza
Buffalo Chicken Roll
Chicken Parmigiana
Pepperoni Bites
Cheese Pizza
Meatballs

“Rocco’s is our spot for pizza in my family! In my opinion, it’s the best around! Their Drunken Grandma pie is outstanding! I recently tried the hero and it was equally good. One of my other personal favorites is the “upside down” Sicilian pie!We have also used Rocco’s for catering and they have always come through with delicious food. If you haven’t tried this spot, you won’t be disappointed!“

4.3 Superb31 Reviews
Posto Pazzo Italian • $$$
84 New York Ave, Huntington

Customers` Favorites

White Pizza with Chopped Spinach
Fresh Homemade Ravioli Twisters
Baked Artichokes Bottoms
Mamas Homemade Gnocchi
Aged Tomahawk Chop Or
Meat and Cheese Plate
The Ravioli Twisters
Tiramisu
Burrata

“Our son loves this place and decided they wanted the rehearsal dinner here.We walked in and was greeted by the owner Luigi who walked us through the entire process then we decided to sit down for dinner.Jose our waiter was amazing and the food was even better.When you get a chance don't walk but run to this place for the greatest italian food ever and don't forget to see JoseThank you all for the experience and looking forward to the party“

4.3 Superb94 Reviews
La Parma II Italian Restaurant Italian • $$
452 W Jericho Turnpike, Huntington

Customers` Favorites

Stuffed Zucchini Flowers
Veal Chop Valdastano
Calamari Marinara
Stuffed Mushrooms
Chicken Francese
White Clam Sauce
Chicken La Parma
Lobster Ravioli
Shrimp La Parma
Marinara Sauce

“Best Italian restaurant in New York. They hit on the classic dishes with perfect precision. La Parma also has some creative unique dishes that never disappoint. The staff is super welcoming and it feels like dining with family. The overall experience will absolutely leave you full and happy that you decided to visit this Long Island treasure.“

4.3 Superb100 Reviews
Edoardo's Trattoria Italian • $$
300 New York Ave, Huntington

Customers` Favorites

Pappardelle Alla Bolognese
Uovo Al Purgatorio
Torta Della Nonna
Pistachio Cream
Fresh Foccacia
Truffle Cream
Tomato Salad
Carpaccio
Tiramisu
Ravioli

“OMG My family and I went to Edoardo Trattoria for Easter Celebration. We had a wonderful time. Greeted by Amparo and the Chef Edoardo they treated us like family The food and service was as if i was taken back to Italy in Capri Very cozy restaurant We will be going back every chance we get I already made reservations for Mothers Day with my family Best Luck for continued success .Parking: Very lucky we parked right in front of the restaurantKid-friendliness: My grandson is a very picky eater Whatever he wanted the Chef would accommodate“

4.3 Superb126 Reviews
Piccola Bussola Italian • $$$
970 W Jericho Turnpike, Huntington

Customers` Favorites

Shrimp Oreganata with Spinach and Penne
Chicken Scarpariello
Stuffed Mushrooms
White Clam Sauce
Veal Saltimbocca
Grilled Octopus
Fried Calamari
Baked Clams

“We dined as part of a group of 76 for a party. Every bite was perfectly crafted traditional Italian dishes. Unparalleled service. Best of the Best! Thank you for a wonderful experience ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️Dietary restrictions: I did not require dietary restrictions, but others in our party did and were well accommodatedKid-friendliness: N/AWheelchair accessibility: Easy wheelchair access“

4.2 Good101 Reviews
La Nonna's Pizza • $$
75 E Main St, Huntington

Customers` Favorites

Eggplant Crispino Pizza Slice
Extra Sides of Blue Cheese
Grandma a La Vodka Pizza
La Nonnas Stuffed Knots
Grandma Ala Vodka Slice
Judy's Creation Pizza
Italian Wedding Soup
Chicken Noodle Soup
Eggplant Rollatini
Pasta Fagioli Soup

“I had a full tray of baked ziti and full tray of chicken cutlet parm delivered through the slice app. The chicken cutlet were so tender and delicious. the trays were packed full and the sauce was one of the best I've had! Thank you so much!!Peggy“

4.1 Good44 Reviews

19
Eatalia

Eatalia Italian • $$
34 New St, Huntington

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Parmigiana Pasta
Chicken Florentine
Veal Parmigiana
Fried Calamari
Crab

“My family and I were surprised to see some empty tables on Valentine’s Day and even more surprised after we had an amazing dinner. Fresh and delicious food at reasonable prices. Best chicken parm I ever had (tastefully breaded with tender organic chicken), crispy pizzas and fresh/large fish filet portion. Service was friendly and quick. Chef knows what they’re doing back there. Please come and eat here for the sake of yourselves and us because we want this place to last and you will too!“

4 Good32 Reviews
Catch 25 Seafood & Steaks Seafood •
326 W Jericho Turnpike, Huntington

Customers` Favorites

Baked Ziti Pasta Lunch Size
Stuffed Veal Chop
Sauteed Calamari
Fried Calamari
Baked Clams
Rock Shrimp
Dozen Clams

“We hadn't been back to Catch 25 in some time, but quickly realized how great the place is. A very warm greeting by the owner, John. James, our server, introduced himself, took our cocktail orders, followed by a wonderful presentation of the specials for the evening. We shared the lump crabmeat salad, served in a martini glass. Each entree was delicious- stuffed shrimp topped with lobster meat, half roasted duck, house special pork chop with roasted Brussels sprouts, and linguine with shrimp and clams in a scampi sauce. During the course of our meal, we were visited by James and John several times to inquire about our meals. It won't be too long before we are back for another great dinner“

4.2 Good231 Reviews
Portofino Italian • $
395 New York Ave, Huntington

Customers` Favorites

Brooklyn Pie
Italian
Ln

“We recently went to PortoFino with some friends for an early dinner. The new owner, Tony, greeted us and could not have been nicer. We had a terrific dinner, and everything was fantastic. The entire staff were incredible. Great job Tony! We will definitely come back.“

4 Good50 Reviews

22
Piccolo

Piccolo Italian • $$$
215 Wall St, Huntington

Customers` Favorites

Orecchiette with Broccoli Rabe
Penne a La Vodka

“We were invited here with friends and never tried it before. The service was good and quick , he even noticed our drinks weren’t how we asked when he went to serve them, so he was very attentive. All of us ordered different dinners and sides. The fillet of sole roberto was quite flavorful , the duck was very good, and the stuffed veal was delicious as well. My chicken parmigiana was ok , unfortunately I felt it lacked flavor, specifically the sauce, other than that all the food was quite good. Overall we were happy with the experience.“

4.1 Good156 Reviews
Lasagna Ristorante Huntington Italian • $$
400 New York Ave, Huntington

Customers` Favorites

Ground Sirloin Lasagna
Classic Caesar Salad
House Made Tiramisu
Short Rib Lasagna
Garlic Bread
Lasagne

“This was our first time, and we thoroughly enjoyed our dining experience. We k ew we'd great great service because we recognized our server from another high-end dining establishment. Now the drinks/cocktails...wow. o one makes a better skinny Margherita. Humbly, I consider myself an expert on this drink. It was perfection. A full pour, icy cold, and a great mix of sour/sweet/Don Julio. Thought ordered for one the beet salad was enough for 2, and we loved it. My veggie lasagna was good to the very last bite. Piping hot, full of every fresh ingredient it promised. We were 5 people, and everyone was very happy with portion size and our choices. We will definitely be back and highly recommend. Thank you“

3.9 Good113 Reviews
Umberto's Pizzeria Pizza • $
737 W Jericho Turnpike, Huntington

Customers` Favorites

Grilled Chicken Caesar Salad Pizza
Simple Salad Perfection
Rigatoni Alla Vodka
Linguini and Clam
Pepperoni Pizza
Chicken Francese
Marinara Sauce
Sicilian Pizza
Garlic Knots
Baked Ziti

“since they spent the money on trying to get new customers with coupon ads in the hometown shopper, i clipped a coupon, picked up the phone and ordered for the superbowl to give it a try. the food was ready and hot upon my pickup as they promised and my guests just devoured the meatball hero; the pizza and the italian cold cut hero also delicious. The price was quite fair-2 3 footers, 4 pizzas and more garlic knots than we could eat and... i'm certain i'll be back again.“

3.7 Good59 Reviews
The Ivy Kitchen and Bar Bar • $$$
65 Wall St, Huntington

Customers` Favorites

Cakes with a Sparkler
Truffle Oil Pizzette
Sweet Potato Gnocchi
Short Rib Risotto
Chicken Parmesan
Pizza Margherita
Caesar Salad
Carrot Cake
Sweet Fries
Baked Clams

“Celebrating my daughter's 21st birthday at The Ivy in Huntington, NY, was an experience to remember. From the moment we stepped through the door, we were greeted with warmth and hospitality that set the tone for the evening.The Ivy's ambiance is chic and inviting, with stylish decor and comfortable seating. It provided the perfect backdrop for a special celebration. The staff went above and beyond to ensure that every aspect of our dining experience was exceptional. They were attentive, friendly, and accommodating, making us feel like valued guests throughout the evening.As for the food, it was nothing short of spectacular. From the appetizers to the desserts, every bite was a delight. The flavors were perfectly balanced, and the ingredients were fresh and high quality. In addition to the fantastic food and service, The Ivy also had a great atmosphere. The music was lively; by the end of our meal, we danced, and even my 76-year-old mother got up tp dance. It was the ideal setting for a birthday celebration, allowing us to enjoy ourselves without feeling rushed or crowded.Overall, our experience at The Ivy was outstanding. It exceeded our expectations in every way and made my daughter's 21st birthday truly special. I would highly recommend this restaurant to anyone looking for a memorable dining experience in Huntington, NY.“

3.8 Good172 Reviews
Loading...
map Map