The food was outstanding as was the service. We were meeting friends we don't see often. We were able to talk and enjoy a leisurely evening with top shelf service and spectacular food.
Hina Yu Cao
I like the environment, service and food. I like the lobster head-on shrimp pasta, signature egg york ravioli with black truffle, salmon entree with mushrooms and onion sides.Nice desert. Chocolate soufflé is good. A little sweet for me. Best pistachio gelato I have ever had including in Rome and Florence.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
JonT
Scalini Fedeli is an extraordinary restaurant. The food is terrific; the menu is extensive; service is excellent; and the room is beautiful. The prix fix menu included five amuses bouches before our appetizers arrived, and a coconut sorbet before our desserts. All of this for the price of $89, though a couple of choices have supplemental charges. I would like to put in a good word for the manager. When he noticed that I have balance problem, he informed me that there is a steep stairway to the bathroom and offered to make my hand. Although it was not necessary because there is a railing, I thought it was an exceptional gesture.
Greg Roberts
Really enjoyed the meal. Super delicious and I'm not crazy about Italian food. Everything was above and beyond. Thanks.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Michele Angerosi
Great welcoming, delicious food, superb service Fantastic Wine Selection. It feels like Italy, beautiful venetian Plaster arch celing, planty of room for big tables and special place downstairs in the wine room. if you never been there you have to try it.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
jimandlouise
We were there a few days ago and everything was outstanding! A wonderful greeting, a great table and gracious service created a top of the line dining experience! The $89.00 per person price fix menu was wonderful. We enjoyed everything very much!
Spencer Howard
Very underrated - no idea why this place isn’t more popular! Would recommend 10/10
Loved my experience at Scalini Fedeli as always. Had an amazing intimate corner table, beautifully lit my candle. All of the courses were wonderful. The pistachio crusted lamp chops were out of this world, and it was a fantastic way to celebrate and spend a romantic evening. The service is top tier.
Gerard Armas
Scalini Fideli never disappoints. We came here 3 years ago after I proposed to my now wife and our experience then was memorable. The food here is delicious and the food presentation is beautiful. The chef goes above and beyond with his amazing cooking skills and presentation. I highly recommend this place if you love good Italian food and a romantic place to bring your wife, husband or significant other. This time around yet again a romantic memorable two year anniversary that my wife and I enjoyed with great food, ambiance and top notch service. We will definitely continue to come here and always make it a memorable time in this romantic Italian restaurant.
I've been here a number of times Service and atmosphere were incredible. Food was awesome as usual. Started with the ravioli with black truffle which was to die for. Just the right amount of truffles. Then moved on to the Veal Chop. It was perfectly cooked. Ended with a banana desert with ice cream. Definitely will be back.
Michael C.
Incredible experience. The food is incredible and service top notch. So happy I finally went
Patti W.
Amazing food , service and ambiance. Beautiful restaurant. The food is off the charts. Soft egg yoke ravioli a must. Service was exceptional. Tribeca gem.
Foodie303
Celebrated our Mother's birthday. Great food with excellent service. EVERYONE loved their primi (and we all ordered something different for sampling as well). Secondis were very good. I'd consider requesting a second primi instead, though. And desserts were fantastic. Overall a great night.
SeanM
Phenomenal experience from start to finish. Delicious,exciting food with high quality presentation, service and inventiveness! When ever we are in NY we go to Scalini Fedeli. You will not find a better restaurant in the city!
The food was outstanding as was the service. We were meeting friends we don't see often. We were able to talk and enjoy a leisurely evening with top shelf service and spectacular food.
I like the environment, service and food. I like the lobster head-on shrimp pasta, signature egg york ravioli with black truffle, salmon entree with mushrooms and onion sides.Nice desert. Chocolate soufflé is good. A little sweet for me. Best pistachio gelato I have ever had including in Rome and Florence.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Scalini Fedeli is an extraordinary restaurant. The food is terrific; the menu is extensive; service is excellent; and the room is beautiful. The prix fix menu included five amuses bouches before our appetizers arrived, and a coconut sorbet before our desserts. All of this for the price of $89, though a couple of choices have supplemental charges. I would like to put in a good word for the manager. When he noticed that I have balance problem, he informed me that there is a steep stairway to the bathroom and offered to make my hand. Although it was not necessary because there is a railing, I thought it was an exceptional gesture.
Really enjoyed the meal. Super delicious and I'm not crazy about Italian food. Everything was above and beyond. Thanks.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great welcoming, delicious food, superb service Fantastic Wine Selection. It feels like Italy, beautiful venetian Plaster arch celing, planty of room for big tables and special place downstairs in the wine room. if you never been there you have to try it.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We were there a few days ago and everything was outstanding! A wonderful greeting, a great table and gracious service created a top of the line dining experience! The $89.00 per person price fix menu was wonderful. We enjoyed everything very much!
Very underrated - no idea why this place isn’t more popular! Would recommend 10/10
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Lamb Chops, Porcini Mushroom Ravioli - Piemonte
Loved my experience at Scalini Fedeli as always. Had an amazing intimate corner table, beautifully lit my candle. All of the courses were wonderful. The pistachio crusted lamp chops were out of this world, and it was a fantastic way to celebrate and spend a romantic evening. The service is top tier.
Scalini Fideli never disappoints. We came here 3 years ago after I proposed to my now wife and our experience then was memorable. The food here is delicious and the food presentation is beautiful. The chef goes above and beyond with his amazing cooking skills and presentation. I highly recommend this place if you love good Italian food and a romantic place to bring your wife, husband or significant other. This time around yet again a romantic memorable two year anniversary that my wife and I enjoyed with great food, ambiance and top notch service. We will definitely continue to come here and always make it a memorable time in this romantic Italian restaurant.
Incredible experience. Top notch
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Veal Chop
Restaurantji Recommends
I've been here a number of times Service and atmosphere were incredible. Food was awesome as usual. Started with the ravioli with black truffle which was to die for. Just the right amount of truffles. Then moved on to the Veal Chop. It was perfectly cooked. Ended with a banana desert with ice cream. Definitely will be back.
Incredible experience. The food is incredible and service top notch. So happy I finally went
Amazing food , service and ambiance. Beautiful restaurant. The food is off the charts. Soft egg yoke ravioli a must. Service was exceptional. Tribeca gem.
Celebrated our Mother's birthday. Great food with excellent service. EVERYONE loved their primi (and we all ordered something different for sampling as well). Secondis were very good. I'd consider requesting a second primi instead, though. And desserts were fantastic. Overall a great night.
Phenomenal experience from start to finish. Delicious,exciting food with high quality presentation, service and inventiveness! When ever we are in NY we go to Scalini Fedeli. You will not find a better restaurant in the city!