14 Best Pizza Restaurants in Newburgh

Cosimo's Pizza • $$
1217 NY-300, Newburgh

Customers` Favorites

Brick Oven Magrarehtta Pizza with Grilled Mushrooms and Sauteed Onions
Spicy Fennel Sausage Wood Fired Pizza
Polpette Chef’S Meatballs
Spicy Fennel Sausage Pizza
Jones Farm Carrot Cake
Burrata Garlic Bread
Seafood Fra Diavolo
Margherita Pizza
Chicken Francaise
The Chicken Parm

“Nice place which seems to have reliable Italian food. For someone just passing through it was a good place to stop. We had 4 main courses and were all fine. The Nona pasta with smashed meatballs listed on the menu just had sliced meatballs which was quite disappointing.Nice modern interior and very good service.“

4.2 Good130 Reviews
Fusion @ Union Italian • $
1400 NY-300, Newburgh

Customers` Favorites

Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Fried Calamari
Fried Ravioli
Chopped Salad
Lasagna Balls
Truffle Fries
Cheese Pizza
Brick Oven
Pizza Union
Garlic

“Outstanding ambiance and the staff was great. The food was spectacular. An unbelievable positive experience. The cauliflower pizza was to die for and the pasta and garlic bread was superb. They know their food and can prepare to any spice level desired or no spice at all.Vegetarian options: They can customize to your preference.They care about what they cook and customize to your tastes.Wheelchair accessibility: Bathroom was ADA friendly“

4.3 Superb60 Reviews
Pizza Mia Pizza • $
50 NY-17K, Newburgh

Customers` Favorites

Fresh Mozzarella and Tomatoes
Selection of Pizza Slices
Vegan Pepperoni Pizza
Veal Parmigiana Sub
Chicken Bacon Ranch
Meat Haters Pizza
Garlic Knot Pizza
Chicken Pizza Mia
Cheese Pizza
Vegan Cheese

“The staff was amazing. The pizza and galic knots were to die for. We asked for a specialty pizza that we've seen online and they nicely advised its a longer wait but it was worth it. I highly recommend and we live 2 hours away and we will be back! Thank you!“

4.2 Good72 Reviews
Eddie's Gourmet Pizza Pizza • $
169 S Plank Rd, Newburgh

Customers` Favorites

Cheese Pizza Slice
Large Cheese Pizza

“Came by for dinner after a long day, came here like last hour they were open, but they more then happy to take my order. I got a meatball sub and buffalo chicken sliders. My order came to me in less then 10 minutes. So the sub, the meatballs were decent size and not too big to the point I was unable to close the sub, cheese was completely melted and gooey, sauce could been less, since the bread did get soggy, and almost came apart. Now the chicken buffalo sliders , that was a experience. First the breading, looked and almost tasted like a pretzel, then the filling, plenty of chicken bits and a healthy amount of buffalo sauce. Seriously the sliders were the best, I was expecting little burger sandwiches and instead pretzel type bread with filling. Very happy with the sliders and definitely something I will get again“

4.3 Superb23 Reviews
Joe's Pizza & Deli Pizza • $
198 S Plank Rd, Newburgh

Customers` Favorites

Slice of Cheese Pizza Plus Mushrooms
Chopped Italian Sandwich
Lucy's Pizza White Pie
Sicilian Pizza Slice
Chicken Cutlet Hero
Meatball Parmigiana
Veal Cutlet Hero
Buffalo Chicken
Veal Parmigiana
Pepperoni Pizza

“Great food, great service and great prices. You can’t go wrong at Joe’s Pizza and deli. The pizza is amazing. I really love the cheese ravioli and the meatball sub. The people are so friendly and helpful. If there is one way to improve this place it would be make it bigger.“

3.9 Good65 Reviews
Villa Italia Ristorante Pizza • $
1663 NY-300, Newburgh

Customers` Favorites

Pasta with Marinara Sauce
Grandma Pie by the Slice
Chicken Ceasar Wrap
Warm Italian Bread
Salmon with Capers
Rigatoni Ala Vodka
Pepperoni Calzone
Gnocci Bolognese
Pollo Parmigiano
Pizza Primavera

“This is my 4-5th time here in the last few years. Always a solid choice. Food is always good and service is usually on par. Ambiance is quiet and tranquil. Really can't ask for much more. Prices are regular Italian establishment type. Pizza is decent nice crust, good sauce, and toppings are fresh. Bread is crispy and warm. Pasta fagoli is good, Italian wedding is amazing, and the tortellini en brodo is klller! Deserts haven't partaken...can't seem to get there.“

3.9 Good63 Reviews
Brooklyn Pizza Pizza • $
5273 Rte 9W, Newburgh

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Parmigiana
Brooklyn Pizza

“I went into Brooklyn Pizza last night for the very first time. Everyone was friendly and the food was extremely delicious. They have a huge array of different foods (Italian, tacos, fajitas, steaks , appetizers, etc. . I can't complain not one bit. I heated everything up when I got home and omg, to my surprise the first bite I took was so crispy, and fresh. I also recommend the garlic knots sandwich with the mozzarella,red roasted peppers, balsamic and chicken cutlet. I am so excited to have found this place. The prices are not bad either. Highly recommend bklyn pizzeria, . Give it a try if you haven't already. You won't be disappointed.“

4.1 Good27 Reviews
Pizza Shop Pizza • $
27 Water St, Newburgh

Customers` Favorites

Baked Ziti and Bread Sticks
Square Margherita Pizza
Gorgonzola Walnut Salad
Margarita Pizza
Meatball Sliders
Pepperoni Pizza
Veggie Pizza
Cheese Pizza
Garlic Knots
Asian Wings

“Was visiting from out of town and met up with my family, a party of 10. They were very busy but the staff and management were VERY accommodating. They pivoted to alternate seating for us and still made us feel welcome on an obviously very unexpected evening. The food was excellent and the service was spectacular. I will be sure to visit again next time I am in town!“

3.8 Good59 Reviews

9
J & F

J & F Pizza • $
474 Broadway, Newburgh

Customers` Favorites

Pepperoni and Cheese Pizza Slice
Chicken Alfredo Pasta
Meatball or Sausage
Spaghetti or Ziti
Buffalo Chicken
Shrimp Parm
Meat Sauce
Wings

“J&F has delicious food. Their meatballs are homemade and legendary. It is a very laid- back, small, and unassuming place on upper Broadway in Newburgh. Almost all of their business is take out- hot and cold sandwiches ( locally made bread), pizza , soup, and pasta dishes all made on site. Started by 2 brothers (John and Frank) , it has remained in the family for over 50 years. Very friendly people and good food. It's our go-to place when we need a quick meal.“

4 Good22 Reviews
Pizza 300 Pizza • $
1208 NY-300, Newburgh

Customers` Favorites

Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
Garlic Knots
Meatball
Grandma
Italian

“staff was pretty quick and though taking my order, and barely waited for my food to go. Meatball slider was very good, I appreciate they are cut in half meatballs then full ones since those are a lot messier to eat, plus the garlic knot it severed in very soft and not overkilled in minced garlic. Grandma slice was great, crust was perfect and not mussy, but wish there was more grated parm and basil on top. Italian combo was great, and the bread used for it was soft, pretty lightly dressed. overall good food here and i found there prices here pretty fair compared to other pizzerias in the area with the same items.“

4 Good20 Reviews
Pizza Hut Pizza Delivery • $
75 N Plank Rd, Newburgh

Customers` Favorites

Personal Pan Pizza with Bacon
Personal Supreme Pizza
Cinnamon Sticks
Breadsticks

“the service is great, managers go above and beyond to help customers. there’s a lot of good deals, just ask and they’re happy to help. the store is always clean. dining in is open. the store helps the community on a weekly and monthly basis. attentive service“

3.8 Good41 Reviews
OCTY'S: Pizza, Tacos, Sandwiches. Pizza • $
102 S Lander St #1, Newburgh

Customers` Favorites

Taco Sandwich Torta
Pepperoni Pizza
Hawaiian Pizza
Plain Pizza
Empanadas
Burritos
Beef Taco
Hot Dog
Burger

“while picking up a grub hub order, I ordered food for myself. staff was very friendly and welcoming. I ordered, an Italian combo, an empanada, and a Jamaican beef patty. for the sandwich plenty of meat, cheese and lettuce. very filling and glad unlike a few places they put salami, pepperoni and ham in an Italian, glad this place makes it right with all three. also, very good they put plenty of mayo and vinegar with the sandwich and seasoned with salt and pepper. Empanada was crispy, very filling very spicy and well-seasoned. Jamaican beef patty was crispy and flaky, filling was spicy and yummy. honestly the best i had with all three and super cheap for good eats. usually, hard roll sandwich is over $8 most places and cheap with filling, here only $5 bucks and stuffed. both the empanada and patty were cheap as well and very fair overall. A hidden gem for good food at a very reasonable prices with a warm and friendly staff.“

3.9 Good15 Reviews
Stella’s Pizzeria Pizza • $
283 Broadway, Newburgh

Customers` Favorites

Buffalo Chicken Pizza with Ranch
Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza Slice
Pepperoni Pizza
Garlic Knots
Cheese Pizza
Chef Salad

“I go here Every So often and every time I order that amazing Pizza ? I'm in Awe and enjoy every Bite...Vegetarian options: Love this Place and ? is Great and AddictiveParking: Parking On Broadway and Depending upon the time of the day...Wheelchair accessibility: Yess“

3.7 Good31 Reviews
Mr Cris Pizzeria Pizza • $
209 Broadway, Newburgh

Customers` Favorites

Hawaiian Pizza
Mexican Pizza
Carnitas Taco
3.8 Good14 Reviews
Loading...
map Map