facebook instagram facebook instagram

Sally's Fish Market

CLOSED
$$ •

270 S William St, Newburgh

Sally's Fish Market Reviews

A friend told me about this place, so I figured I try it out, you never know. Fish mongers are rare up here, mostly supermarket fish counters with their IQF offerings from the other side of the planet. It's in an odd location; across from a scrap iron place and not much else. This is what it was like going to an old fashioned fish monger, back in the old neighborhood. The first thing you notice is, and this is an excellent sign - No Fish smell. If you go some place and encounter...read full review

Good place in the middle of the wasteland area of Newburgh. Like a. Old school butcher shop except with seafood. Really cool old walk-in fridge. We picked up salmon and shrimp to grille on the Barbie. The shrimp was excellent. The salmon fresh caught. They are a bit of a drive for us but next time we're in the area will definitely stop in again.

Found this gem! Sea bass and red snapper are our favorite so far. Always fresh seafood and the market is clean. Old world charm and the owner & staff are so friendly and helpful. Not sure what to do with the catch, just ask. They offer great suggestions on how to prepare and enjoy every fish or seafood they sell. Shrimp, scallops, salmon... great quality to choose from but get there early!! Frozen catch like crab, shellfish and such are available as well. Will be here more often.

More Reviews(66)

Ratings

View all photos
Updated on: