Probably some of the best NY style pizza I've had! We only got a cheese & pepperoni pie but they have a whole host of other "flavors" to choose from and I cannot wait to try some. Garlic knots were also pretty good, basic knots. The only negative was the wings, too soggy! I think next time (and I'd recommend to anyone who reads this) I will get them extra crispy. That said, the flavor (medium) was ok. This will definitely be a place we order from on the regular.
Christopher S McBride
I lived downstate for 15 years and the pizza at this place definitely can go toe to toe with anything down there. Has a downstate style menu with things like stromboli, penne alla vodka and garlic knotts. Definitely recommend if you like thin crust, foldable downstate style pizza. You will be disappointed if you prefer Buffalo style pizza with thicker crust, loads of cheese and cup and char pepperoni. However this place is a must try if you like thin crust NYC pizza.
Koh Max
I ordered on March 11th and the food was horrible there was a mini pool of greese on top of my pizza the wing were to be extra crispy and they were soft with no sauce and the garlic knots didn't even taste of garlic and were stiff, dry and no real flavor and ever since I ate there I feel sick. I will be contacting the health department about this as I am feeling more sick the next day after eating last night warning to all don't eat here my wife went in to return and the were all laughing and smiling when returning it
Gail S.
we ordered the house pizza - we were told it was going to have 8 very large slices. They told me I could have it cut in 16 slices instead of 8. The pizza was NOT cut in 16 slices as requested. We also ordered 30 chicken wings with 20 of them being MILD. They were definitely NOT MILD. When we picked up our order, the 3 guys behind the counter were not the most friendly. They appeared to have ZERO personality and didn't appear to want to even be there working. What happened to good friendly service and getting our order correct? I asked for a new menu and they said they don't have any. OK, should we order from this place again soon????????
Amanda Hess
Just ordered some food from here tonight. Everything was very good and prices are reasonable! Highly recommend!
Paul K.
It had been a while since I've been here... seeing as I'm working on trying newer places and revisiting some older spots figured it was about time. First off, I need to state that NY Style pizza is my favorite, but you really need to go to the city if you want to truly have the best... it's kinda like going anywhere but Brooklyn for bagels. Maybe there really is something in the water making the dough that special... But of all the NY Style pizza places that I've been to in town, Olisi's is definitely a cut above the rest. Their prices seem to have gone up quite a bit from my last visit, but the quality has remained. I ordered the large (which is their smallest whole pie) bruschetta pizza, and I really enjoyed it. Will likely return soon for lunch slices sometime soon.
Lindsay B.
Ordered a BLT and got a bacon and cheese sub. How do you screw up a sub with 3 ingredients??? Very disappointed. I've given this place the benefit of the doubt way too many times because I love their extra large NY style pies but and I'm just done now. Anytime we order anything besides a pizza they screw up up our order
Brandon L.
Was in the area and was looking for a NY style pizza place to grab food on the way home. Honestly it was pretty good, great flavors is what stood out here, good crust too. I did ask for well done, unfortunately they did not oblige lol, so I stuck it in my oven at home for 5 more minutes on 350.. the pic is the final product. Was great, would definitely order from them again.
Travelaroundwithdawn
I love this place and it's my favorite. From the pizza to the garlic knots it reminds me of authentic NYC pie. Grab a slice to go, order a whole pizza to take out or sit in the dining area. I've never had a bad experience in this establishment.
Ellen S.
My favorite "plain cheese" pizza! Staff is always friendly and helpful. Slices ready on the go too. Salads are also delicious!
The best thin crust NY style in the Amherst area. They're more expensive than the rest, so if I'm ordering anything other than a thin NY style with one or two toppings, I go elsewhere. The pricing is higher than the competition and if anywhere else made a decent NY style for less, I'd order there. I still ×ince when ordering.
Michelle Rao-Robidoux
This is the best pizzeria around! All of their food is above excellence
Leah K.
Good spot for NY style thin pizza. Had a large order over the weekend and they grouped everything best they could to make some combo deals. Really nice of them to do. Only thing is the pizza adds up quick if you want a few toppings. They also send coupons out in mailers around the area. So you usually have a coupon on hand. I've ordered subs and wings here before and they are delicious as well. Thin crust isn't always my jam, and it can be a little greasy but if you're in the mood it's a great local spot
Phil V.
Best place for NY style pizza in the Buffalo NY area, Ive had a few pies from here and they are always on point, nice thin crust with a little bit of chew on the crust Go for the meatball pie and the steak pie Dont sleep on the garlic knots
Probably some of the best NY style pizza I've had! We only got a cheese & pepperoni pie but they have a whole host of other "flavors" to choose from and I cannot wait to try some. Garlic knots were also pretty good, basic knots. The only negative was the wings, too soggy! I think next time (and I'd recommend to anyone who reads this) I will get them extra crispy. That said, the flavor (medium) was ok. This will definitely be a place we order from on the regular.
I lived downstate for 15 years and the pizza at this place definitely can go toe to toe with anything down there. Has a downstate style menu with things like stromboli, penne alla vodka and garlic knotts. Definitely recommend if you like thin crust, foldable downstate style pizza. You will be disappointed if you prefer Buffalo style pizza with thicker crust, loads of cheese and cup and char pepperoni. However this place is a must try if you like thin crust NYC pizza.
I ordered on March 11th and the food was horrible there was a mini pool of greese on top of my pizza the wing were to be extra crispy and they were soft with no sauce and the garlic knots didn't even taste of garlic and were stiff, dry and no real flavor and ever since I ate there I feel sick. I will be contacting the health department about this as I am feeling more sick the next day after eating last night warning to all don't eat here my wife went in to return and the were all laughing and smiling when returning it
we ordered the house pizza - we were told it was going to have 8 very large slices. They told me I could have it cut in 16 slices instead of 8. The pizza was NOT cut in 16 slices as requested. We also ordered 30 chicken wings with 20 of them being MILD. They were definitely NOT MILD. When we picked up our order, the 3 guys behind the counter were not the most friendly. They appeared to have ZERO personality and didn't appear to want to even be there working. What happened to good friendly service and getting our order correct? I asked for a new menu and they said they don't have any. OK, should we order from this place again soon????????
Just ordered some food from here tonight. Everything was very good and prices are reasonable! Highly recommend!
It had been a while since I've been here... seeing as I'm working on trying newer places and revisiting some older spots figured it was about time. First off, I need to state that NY Style pizza is my favorite, but you really need to go to the city if you want to truly have the best... it's kinda like going anywhere but Brooklyn for bagels. Maybe there really is something in the water making the dough that special... But of all the NY Style pizza places that I've been to in town, Olisi's is definitely a cut above the rest. Their prices seem to have gone up quite a bit from my last visit, but the quality has remained. I ordered the large (which is their smallest whole pie) bruschetta pizza, and I really enjoyed it. Will likely return soon for lunch slices sometime soon.
Ordered a BLT and got a bacon and cheese sub. How do you screw up a sub with 3 ingredients??? Very disappointed. I've given this place the benefit of the doubt way too many times because I love their extra large NY style pies but and I'm just done now. Anytime we order anything besides a pizza they screw up up our order
Was in the area and was looking for a NY style pizza place to grab food on the way home. Honestly it was pretty good, great flavors is what stood out here, good crust too. I did ask for well done, unfortunately they did not oblige lol, so I stuck it in my oven at home for 5 more minutes on 350.. the pic is the final product. Was great, would definitely order from them again.
I love this place and it's my favorite. From the pizza to the garlic knots it reminds me of authentic NYC pie. Grab a slice to go, order a whole pizza to take out or sit in the dining area. I've never had a bad experience in this establishment.
My favorite "plain cheese" pizza! Staff is always friendly and helpful. Slices ready on the go too. Salads are also delicious!
Restaurantji Recommends
The best thin crust NY style in the Amherst area. They're more expensive than the rest, so if I'm ordering anything other than a thin NY style with one or two toppings, I go elsewhere. The pricing is higher than the competition and if anywhere else made a decent NY style for less, I'd order there. I still ×ince when ordering.
This is the best pizzeria around! All of their food is above excellence
Good spot for NY style thin pizza. Had a large order over the weekend and they grouped everything best they could to make some combo deals. Really nice of them to do. Only thing is the pizza adds up quick if you want a few toppings. They also send coupons out in mailers around the area. So you usually have a coupon on hand. I've ordered subs and wings here before and they are delicious as well. Thin crust isn't always my jam, and it can be a little greasy but if you're in the mood it's a great local spot
Best place for NY style pizza in the Buffalo NY area, Ive had a few pies from here and they are always on point, nice thin crust with a little bit of chew on the crust Go for the meatball pie and the steak pie Dont sleep on the garlic knots
Awesome pizza, great service