Restaurants in Wantagh

“Wow just AMAZINGLY DELICIOUS My son and I tried it today for the first time and we are impressed and we will definitely be thank you. John you are a talented chef !!”

“The restaurant is located in back of Jone Beach Hotel. We were greeted and seated as we made reservations. The drinks were good as well as food. The sharing portion is for more than two people. The waitress was nice and attentive to our table. Will definitely be going again as it was a great experience.”

“It’s a owner operator business, Manuel, is a star! Went in for lunch with my good friend he was Very attentive. We had the shrimp quesadilla and chicken crunch wrap! Three different mild sauces and three different hot sauces . Their homemade hot sauce was excellent! Chorizos was spectacular! Nobody’s gonna run it the way you want it! Thank you Manuel!Parking: I had no problem parking in front of the business.”

“I am not one to write reviews, but this place deserves top marks all around. Drinks while you wait, terrific service, food that hits the spot, and you do not feel rushed to leave. How many places can you say that about? There is always something new to try, but you can always fall back to a favorite as well. The staff alone is worth the trip alone, Steph knows the menu and gives the best recommendations.”

“Excellent fish store. Always busy, always very friendly and patient, always a sufficient number of workers. All types of fish prepared and sliced according to your order. There is a restaurant attached that I have never had the opportunity to experience, but it is always spotlessly clean and delicious I am sure. My go to fish store when I am in the area. Plenty of parking in their free parking lot on the side of the store.Vegetarian options: PlentyDietary restrictions: There are optionsParking: Not an issueKid-friendliness: Very friendly to allWheelchair accessibility: It is accessible”

“Recently enjoyed our breakfast at Sunrise Diner. Had a nicely cooked sunny side ups, bacon, and homefries platter. Other folks had similar breakfast fare.The staff was friendly and attentive. No complaints here. Just complements.”

“It was very crowded and busy and loud but the person who took our orders was INCREDIBLY kind and patient even when my friend was indecisive and taking their time w ordering. The best service I’ve had in a long time!!!!!!!!”

“Missing my train stop turned into me discovering this little slice of food heaven.Upon walking in, I was warmly greeted. The employees graciously explained the menu items. Overall, it was a positive experience. The food was delicious, and the customer service was exceptional.”

“Absolutely delicious food, drinks and dessert! I had no clue this was only a mile away from me, but now that I know, I can’t wait to go back. Our waitress told us the chef changes the menu often, so I’m eager to see what other incredible things he cooks up!Only negative is the lack of parking, but we parked on the side street!”

“Overall a very nice experience . The service was fantastic, the drinks were served quick. We had the meatballs as an appetizer and they were perfect... very tasty. We both had the chicken parm. It was clearly freshly made and overall a nice meal. The only thing we didn't like is how oily the chicken parm was. The oil took over the taste a bit, but it was still pretty good.”

“Quaint little bar with great wing and drink specials on Wednesdays and has been a quintessential part of the Wantagh bar scene for about as long as I can remember and even before that. You can always count on friendly faces and cold drinks but definitely be prepared to bump some elbows when it gets busy because it gets tight! Plenty of parking both in the from and back of the bar.”

“Hubby and I have gone there twice...So far the food has not disappointed and the service is great. Everyone is very accommodating.Only suggestion, hot sauce selection ?”

“A tradional Irish Pub! We had so much fun at Mulcahy's on St.Patrick's Day! If you're looking for an Irish pub in Long Island, go to Mulcahy's in Wantagh on Railroad Ave!”

“We've been here so many times, and every time is wonderful! We love it so much that we went on Christmas day the past 3 years!This one chef automatically knows how we like our steak cooked, and that we like double yummy yummy sauce! 10/10 every time!”

“Great place, great food and great drinks. Anthony, the owner, came by numerous times and was very generous to us after we finished our dinner. Highly recommend! We will be returning!!”