6 Best Pizza Restaurants in Chillicothe

Mister Sub Pizza • $$
543 E Main St, Chillicothe

Customers` Favorites

Garbage Sub Ham Turkey Bacon and Colby Cheese and Sausage Stuffed Shrooms
Sausage Stuffed Mushrooms
Super Italian 16 Inch Sub
Chicken-Bacon-Ranch Sub
Buffalo Chicken Sub
Cheesy Garlic Bread
Ham and Cheese Sub
Island Hopper Sub
Super Italian Sub
BBQ Chicken Sub

“If you're looking for a non-chain sub-shop, this is your pick. Other reviews can regale you with their selections, but for me, it's the meatball sub, which reminds me of the grinders I've gotten on the East Coast. The sauce is perfect, and the meatballs are delicious, but the bread steals the show. My wife opts for the Italian Sub and loves it every time. I've also got a good Philly sub here. There is no cheese whiz, but it's close to the recipe. Inside the place is nothing to write home about. One big drawback: You might miss the place because the owner hasn't changed the sign, which says "The Mill pizza" out front. It gives the impression that it's not open, or about the close. It was acceptable for a few months, but after years, it's time to invest the sign, my guy.“

4.4 Superb78 Reviews
Acord's Pizza & Subs Pizza Delivery • $
13110 OH-772, Chillicothe

“Great neighborhood store, plus yummy food. Two locations. Store and slightly smaller take out and delivery menu is at store on 772. Restaurant and bar with numerous activities through the year, at their Blaine Highway location. Both locations are CLEAN, staffed with very honest and nice ppl. Im a transplant to this side of the county and have always been treated with the kindness and attention that makes for exceptional customer assistance and service. Please try their sandwich ham spread that you can only find here! Secret recipe that tastes like my Grandma Rittinger's! Family owned and operated. Only change that would make the business better was open 24/7. Even with that suggested, they do have good operating hours. Small coin candy (historically called penny candy) for the kidos, decent selection in their walk in beer cooler along with last minute grabs in their store area. If you are reading this on a digital search and not from the area, stop in, not tour guides but many times may suggest auto services or directions; depending on need. While you are in the area, don't miss their combination pizza. Handmade and very tasty!!“

4.8 Superb19 Reviews
Giovanni's Pizza Pizza • $$
423 Western Ave, Chillicothe

Customers` Favorites

Pepperoni Pizza with Banana Peppers and Extra Sauce
Large Pizza with Pepperoni and Banana Peppers
Large Pepperoni Perfection
Lasagna and Garlic Bread
Large Cheese Pizza
Pepperoni Pounder
Baked Spaghetti
Spicy Sausage
Garden Salad
Cheese Bread

“We stopped here on our way back from Hocking Hills, and the food was great! They were really busy, but attentive. We got a small pepperoni pizza, a veggie sub with fries and some hot bone-in wings. It was all excellent! Would definitely stop back.Vegetarian options: You could make your own pizza with all veg toppings. Pizza is easy for vegetarians. The veggie sub was great!“

4.4 Superb69 Reviews
Fire And Stone Pizzeria Pizza • $$
98 N Paint St, Chillicothe

Customers` Favorites

Create Your Own Pizza
Classic Cheese Pizza
The DeGarmo Pizza
The Forager Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
Deluxe Pizza

“In the very quaint downtown of Chillicothe sits this unassuming pizza shop. I was delighted at the idea that they would be using a live fire pizza oven! I ordered the meatball appetizer and it was phenomenal. It wasn't dense at all, there were a couple of cheeses I tasted and the sauce was amazing. The pizza comes out and doesn't disappoint. I decided on the works pizza. Crispy dough (next time I will ask for well done) the toppings were fresh. Again, the pizza sauce is very well balanced. The sausage was not your typical pizza sausage. It was excellent and very well seasoned. Best pizza in Chillicothe.“

4.4 Superb46 Reviews
Julio's Pizzeria Pizza • $
1680 N Bridge St, Chillicothe

“I spent my first weekend in NY walking 10 miles in 20 degree weather post-cyclone looking at overpriced walkups, wondering why the hell I moved here from Los Angeles. Starving, I Yelped the closest pizza place and had my answer. New York is the only city where, despite everything, you can walk into any neighborhood and find a slice of pizza that makes you forget everything you loved in your west coast past life. I used to think Joe's was the best, but this definitely took that spot. I thought, maybe I'm wrong. Maybe this just tasted so good because I was hungry that day and it was cold. To test this, I came here multiple nights in a row and still experienced no diminishing marginal returns. Instead, each visit made me crave this place more. The normal/triangular/non-square margarita is my fave. And although a warm slice tastes great while you're walking outside and makes you forget how cold it is, I much prefer to enjoy these in the large seating area in the back to fully engage in the experience.“

4.7 Superb10 Reviews
PIZZA PIONEER- in KINNIKINNICK Pizza Takeaway • $
125 OH-180, Chillicothe

“The food is amazing! But, I work at a factory and our lunch is very short and I called and place my order and hour and a half in advance and when I call 10 mins until lunch just to double check the estimated ETA the lady that answered had no customer service, very lacking. I've worked in and ran kitchens before this job for years and there's just a way to talk to people and a way not to.“

4.5 Superb11 Reviews
Loading...

Enjoy Similar Cuisines In Chillicothe

map Map