Otie's Tavern & Grill

5344 Center St, Hilliard
(614) 876-1548

Recent Reviews

Ric Shoemaker

A great little corner bar. Good selection of beer and good service even though they were short staffed. You never felt like you were forgotten. Wished I lived closer.

J Fyock

New beer ? I tried was very good. Christmas Ale from Great Lakes Brewery. Bartender did a good job. Looked a little slow , but enjoyed time here.

Greg Fralick

Have loved oties for decades, tje food did not dissapoint. Good service, old times still. The odd part otie baloney is on the website at 10.99, rubber at 8.99. It rang up at 12.99 and 13.99. We were there at lunch on a weekday, ordered no extras. Why??? Dropped a star for this. Fix your website please.

Gerald Knott

Forty-two men were hosted in the upstairs party room. Appetizers were plentiful and outstandingly served. Main course was a smorgasbord of their menu and were excellent. Josh, the bartender, did a fantastic job serving all of us. We plan to schedule future gatherings at Otis’s.

Kathy Ogden

We ordered several appetizers and they were all good! Our bartender/waitress was the best! Great service, very friendly and outgoing. Drinks were good quality.

Zada Layman

Worst experience I have ever had in a restaurant. It made me and my fiancé very sick. We were given plastic silverware, tables are so unstable that our drinks spilled all over us, and our food was half cold and rancid. Would give 0 stars if I could. I will NEVER go back. Very disheartening as this was our first time going there. Do not go unless you want to be throwing up all night and want food poisoning. At least the nachos were kind of ok.

Laura Stalter

Lovely rooftop bar, the renovation they did is beautiful. Great Hilliard bar

Katherine Persang

Love this place. Warm and inviting. Staff incredible. The Otis bologna sandwich. Da bomb. Had an awesome time. Will be back soon!!


We've eaten at Oties for more than 30 years--an old favorite of my late father and uncle. Has outside seating along Old Town and inside as well. Great burgers--and fun service. Ash for Emily--great waitress who served our party of 14 without any issues!

Kayla Beidelschies

Jonathan is awesome. He is running this whole place by himself. Have patience and appreciate the people that are willing to stay and do the best they can!

Adriana L Amezcua

Hummus was spicy and not good. Philly sandwich was very greasy and fries almost burned. Nachos were good though. The patio is beautiful, but food just ok. Probably not coming back.It took a while to get service and food, as normal to all places right now.


Like many have said, the atmosphere is the only reason to come. The patio is nice, although the upstairs is rarely open. This place could awesome with the amount of space here but it’s always lacking due to the food and drink (always leaves something to be desired). I’ve been here precovid and post, and the service has always been rough. I don’t blame the employees…I blame the owner for sure. I miss the old Otie’s before it was sold and I wish this place could be so much more than it is.

Samuel R

Attempted to take the family here and sat on the patio to enjoy the weather (self seating). Waited 20 minuted without even seeing a server, so we left.

Sandra Pinkerton

Good bar food. Bologna sandwich had great seasoning and taste.

yvette roquemore

I have been here several times every time it's 5 Star Treatment !!!!!!!!! very friendly atmoshere........Food is Amazing

Load More