10 Best American Restaurants in Lancaster

Cherry Street Pub Pubs • $
202 N Cherry St, Lancaster

Customers` Favorites

Bison Mushroom Swiss Burger and Fries
Pecan Crusted Chicken and Waffles
Peanut Butter and Jelly Wings
Fish and Chips with Coleslaw
Nashville Hot Chicken Mac
Buffalo Chicken Sandwich
The Hangover Burger
French Onion Burger
Chorizo Disco Fries
Macaroni and Cheese

“Wow wow wow. Where do I even begin. I brought a group of seniors today to this restaurant and not only did the staff accommodate us but were so sweet and genuine. Lauren, you rocked it. You are a great server/waitress. You were so kind and your patience level was amazing. Donna Reid thank you thank you thank you for your help I’m getting us in. The food was amazing and reasonably priced. You get a ton of food for the dollar. Again I thank you for a great experience. Thank you. Lisa Rees with the Verena at Hilliard and the seniors.“

4.5 Superb140 Reviews
Ale House 1890 Gastropubs • $$
149 W Main St, Lancaster

Customers` Favorites

Faith's First Prize Chocolate Cake
Cheech & Chong Burger
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Duck Duck Pierogi
French Onion Soup
Barnyard Burger
Fish & Chips
Blue Burger
Absolutely
Calamari

“I wish the seating were more intimate, but it is great for larger parties to sit together. Food was on the spot, and we all enjoyed our meal. I didn't expect chicken varena to be so good. They have great, strong drinks and a large beer selection too.“

4.5 Superb98 Reviews
JB's Downtown Grill Burgers • $
111 N Columbus St, Lancaster

Customers` Favorites

The Italian Sausage Sandwich
French Onion Soup Seasonal
The Buffalo Chicken Wrap
The Chicken & Cow Burger
Brum Burger and Fries
The Cuban Sandwich
JB's Deluxe Nachos
The Brum Burger
Chicken Tenders
Deviled Eggs

“We stopped in on a whim and we were very pleased! We had a variety of sliders, fries, French onion soup (delicious) and a side salad. The food was great, service was attentive and prices were excellent! It was a little awkwardly quiet at points, so maybe some low music would help, but that's minor. Definitely give this place a try and support your local entrepreneurs!“

4.7 Superb45 Reviews
Todds Mountain View Restaurant American • $
540 W Fair Ave, Lancaster

Customers` Favorites

Scrambled Eggs Hash Home Fries Sharing Some Biscuitsw Gravy with Hot Sause on the Side
Bacon Hashbrowns Scrambled Eggs
Hotcakes or Corncakes
Reeses French Toast
Biscuits and Gravy
Eggs and Sausage
Sausage Gravy
Pancake
Waffle

“Toods mountain view has phenomenal food!!! It's a busy little place but that should tell you something about it. I got the mountain top special it had homefries eggs and ham coverd in sausage gravy topped with more homefries and came with toast all mixed together it was so big I could only eat half of it and it was absolutely goooooood!!!! Stop here for breakfast you will not regret it!!! Also the waitress and the service was great!“

4.4 Superb77 Reviews
Old Bill Bailey's Bar & Grill • $
200 Harrison Ave, Lancaster

Customers` Favorites

Slutty Wings Unreal Dine in: Yes Outdoor seating: Yes Takeout: Yes Delivery: No Curbside pickup: No
Wings and a Mushroom and Swiss Burger and Fries
Chicken Bacon Ranch Sandwich
Mushroom Onion Swiss Burger
Cheeseburger Sliders
Fried Pickle Chips
Sweet Thai Chili
Honey BBQ Wings
Jalapeno Poppers
Honey Barbecue

“Drove to Ohio for a night from NH to pick up my puppy BLU with a friend on 7/28/23. The breeder recommended this place as having the best wings. He wasn't kidding! This place had killer wings. We tried I think 4 different flavors, loved the Japenese BBQ that had some spice to it. It had a funky name but was delicious. We also had a fried shrimp basket that was loaded with succulent fried shrimp and the most amazing homemade hand cut fries that were fried to perfection. We played keno and tried our hand at pull tabs too. We weren't big winners but we didn't lose overall which was a plus. The best win was tremendous service. Our bartender was super attentive and she made sure were well taken care of. Portion sizes were generous. Pricing was also very reasonable. This place was so great its almost worth the 13 hour trip out and 14 hour trip back. Can't wait to stop in again next time I'm out that way. Maybe next year when I get another Frenchton puppy.“

4.4 Superb43 Reviews
Roosters Chicken Wings • $
1009 N Memorial Dr, Lancaster

Customers` Favorites

Wings Dine in: Yes Outdoor seating: Yes Takeout: Yes
Boneless Chicken Wings
Grilled Chicken Salad
Medium Boneless Wings
Fried Chicken Salad
Mozzarella Sticks
Dumpster Fries
Mini Corn Dogs
Buffalo Wings
Turkey Burger

“This place was huge!!! Waited 20 minutes buttttt the wait was worth it!! Food was great tasting, enough for 3 meals(leftovers), service was incredible &&& the prices were surprisingly on point to what we ordered. Will return next year.“

4.3 Superb72 Reviews
Munchy Junkies LLC American • $
1941 E Main St, Lancaster

Customers` Favorites

Roasted Red Pepper Chicken Soup
Bread Pudding

“Absolutely delicious! Took the fam to see chef Chris on his birthday and it did not disappoint. Food is definitely awesome and massive especially for the cost. I got the Philly and was fantastic, my 7yr old stole the other half and smashed it. Good selection for everyone. Support local business.“

5 Superb10 Reviews
Texas Roadhouse Steak House • $
2890 Columbus-Lancaster Rd NW, Lancaster

Customers` Favorites

Texas Size Combo Steak and Shrimp with Loaded Steak Fries and House Salad
16 Oz Prime Rib - Medium Rare w Raw Horsedradish
Full Rack of Ribs with Sweet Potato
Prime Rib and Blooming Onion
Rolls with Cinnamon Butter
House Salad Steak Fries
Chicken Critters
Mashed Potatoes
Grilled Shrimp
Cactus Blossom

“We called ahead for the wait list, once there it was a 5 minute wait at best. When we got seated our server was right there talking care of us. The food was delicious! It's a nice warm environment. We drive down from Columbus for that location.“

4.2 Good117 Reviews
Waffle House Breakfast • $
1385 Election House Rd NW, Lancaster

Customers` Favorites

Texas Cheesesteak Melt with Hashbrowns
Waffles Hash Browns and Bacon
Bacon Eggs Cheese Hashbrowns
Chocolate Chip Waffle
Grits with Cheese
Cheese Sandwich
2 Egg Breakfast
Classic Waffles
Hashbrowns All
Scrambled Eggs

“Its waffle house.... say no more.... where you can fill your stomach with out breakin your wallet... the best value on a big breakfast.... and Lancaster is always a fun , chatty place, even if your just in for your morning coffee, OR a full plate. Best grits around, too!...“

4.2 Good91 Reviews
Thimmes Fish Shack Seafood • $
619 W Fair Ave, Lancaster

Customers` Favorites

Fried Clams Fried Oysters and Fried Shrimp
Mozzarella Cheese Stix
Fish Sandwich
Onion Rings
Clam Strips
Waffle Fries
Tater Tots
Bean Soup
Pickle

“Really solid little place. One guy in the kitchen and one guy in the front, got a little busy right at lunch but everyone understood. Working in Lancaster from the coast of Houston Texas, know a bit about seafood. Reminded me of the hometown and how good the seafood was there. The clam strips and shrimp were the favorite. Onion rings were solid! Would pick this place again for sure, definitely a great stop in Lancaster.“

4.3 Superb36 Reviews
Loading...
map Map