Our small group was seated in line with the front door and the kitchen. I'm quite sure the kitchen draft hoods were providing the impetus for a chilly draft when the front doors were opened.The food was considered to be very good by everyone in our group. The BBQ Ribs were perhaps the best I had ever eaten. Truly fall off the bone ribs, like these are rare.Will definitely make a return appearance here.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Ribs
Lesley Darby
We live mins from the middleburg Hts location. But now that we’ve visited this location we will probably never stop there. Everything was spot on Tamara our waitress was friendly, fun and very knowledgeable. She can definitely multitask as there was a “party” going on. Our food was amazing cooked exactly how we asked.
Went there for our 20 year anniversary.Remember it as a kid, still the same... pricey but
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Israel Ciptak
Tara our sever made our experience Exceptional. It was extremely busy and they were short handed during our visit, and Tara didn’t miss a beat. Not only was she Exceptional, but her personality was in unmatched especially given how busy it was. Unfortunately in the times we are living in you rarely experience OUTSTANDING service. Tara is a person of integrity. Thank you Tara, much appreciated!!! PeaceKid-friendliness: Tara and the bartender were extremely friendly.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Steak, French Onion Soup
Tracy Rhoad
We were disappointed ?. We were seated by the hostess promptly but the servers would not make eye contact. We waited patiently at first, after 15 minutes it turned into impatient. Finally the manager walked the floor and we told him we had not had any service, or acknowledgement we were even there. He offered free appetizers, which we did not want. He apologized and sent a server to us. He said the Ice Festival created a problem for them. We ordered our dinners, which were not great. Salad and vegetables were good. Steaks were tough to cut. Expensive meal for an unpleasant dinner
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Name
We went this past Friday and waited over an hour and half for steaks. We told the manager who went to back and we saw through the very visible window, the cooks throw the plates around and throw our ticket on top of one of our steaks. The grill was in a need of a cleaning, badly. Our steaks came out over cooked and somehow my husband’s steak was purple. We watched the cook use the same tongs to remove raw chicken and flip the done steaks. We noticed more than most because my husband grew up in the restaurant business. The waitress said she would get the manager but after leaving never came back with anything other than the bill. They took the alcoholic drinks off the bill but for steak dinners that took forever and overcooked we will not be back. With having kids, we don’t get out for dates much and it’s sad to have an experience like this. We have been to brown derby before and always have the best meals but seems like it’s headed in the wrong direction. Sadly, we will not be back.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 1
Service: 4
Maureen Kaye
Great food and excellent
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Carol Has fun
Nice visit, good food.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Steak
Chad Hendershot
Had a family gathering of 17 our waitress was great handled everything like a pro. The food was great, and all came out together. The pretzel appetizer was a hit with my family and the beer cheese it came with tasted great.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Loaded Idaho Baked Potato, Steak, French Onion Soup
Donna Jones
We went there for my birthday. The food was excellent. We had steak, salmon and the stuff mushrooms for the appetizer. No one in our group complained about anything it was just delicious! Our server was really nice and picked up our bad jokes & joined in as well with a joke or two of her own. Plan on going there again for a night out or special occasion.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Caesar Salad, Grilled Shrimp, Steak
Everything was fantastic!! Love coming here for dinner! The food was amazing, especially the shrimp and Caramel Toffee cake!! Our server Kari was top notch! ! Can’t wait to come back!
Very close to outstanding, they just need to get their service figured out. Friendly staff, good value, great atmosphere, food was made well, but it arrived late and cold (45 minutes after ordering)
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Steak
Tammy Nau
Great food and
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Steak
David Engle
Man, where do I even start? My wife, son, in-laws and myself came in on 1/26/24. There were 10 of us in total. Our waitress you could tell was overwhelmed. I get it, it sucks. But hey, it’s your job. Our rolls that came out at the start, were stale. You could tell they were under the heat lamps for a bit. The appetizers though, were fantastic and that’s where it ended. Not once the entire meal did I even get offered a refill on my coke. Then when my nieces got refills, the coke was flat and almost pure water. You could tell just by looking at it, it wasn’t right. But the waitress brought it out anyway. Then because our order was big, the waitress put our order on 2 tickets. I don’t know if she forgot to reiterate to the cooks that it’s all the same order, or what. But they were making the food as it were 2 different orders for 2 different tables. So while half of us got our food, the other half had to wait. Being family, naturally, we waited until everyone had their food to eat. So half of us had cold food. My wife’s French onion soup was cold, the onions also were still crunchy, not fully cooked. Then her sirloin was rare instead of medium. She sent it back and the second sirloin was the same. My brother in-laws mashed potatoes were stone cold. My mother in-law’s (who’s birthday it was that’s why we went out) lobster was tough and chewy. I got the porterhouse. I consider myself a steak snob. A porterhouse is supposed to be a thick cut. This thing was maybe 1/4in thick. I’m dead serious. There is absolutely NO WAY this was a porterhouse and definitely not 22oz before cooked. My wife’s sirloin was thicker and had more meat on it. What a joke. Then my steak was also medium well when I asked for medium rare, so it was tough. All of the steaks were completely unseasoned and bland as cardboard. My son’s chicken tenders were also the most generic tenders possible. We still tipped the waitress $100 even though we sure didn’t get $100 worth of service. The bill was over $500 for cheap, cold, bland food. Not worth it what-so-ever. You can go almost anywhere, get more food of better quality and pay less. It’s a real shame too. My wife and I went to the Brown Derby by us off Bagley several times, without issue. We went to this one because we saw they had fried green tomatoes, which my wife loves. We raved to my in-laws how good Brown Derby is and now they refuse to give the one on Bagley a try. We’ll be contacting corporate in the morning. This place is atrocious.
Our small group was seated in line with the front door and the kitchen. I'm quite sure the kitchen draft hoods were providing the impetus for a chilly draft when the front doors were opened.The food was considered to be very good by everyone in our group. The BBQ Ribs were perhaps the best I had ever eaten. Truly fall off the bone ribs, like these are rare.Will definitely make a return appearance here.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Ribs
We live mins from the middleburg Hts location. But now that we’ve visited this location we will probably never stop there. Everything was spot on Tamara our waitress was friendly, fun and very knowledgeable. She can definitely multitask as there was a “party” going on. Our food was amazing cooked exactly how we asked.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Grilled Shrimp, Rice Pilaf, Steak, Steamed Broccoli
Went there for our 20 year anniversary.Remember it as a kid, still the same... pricey but
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Tara our sever made our experience Exceptional. It was extremely busy and they were short handed during our visit, and Tara didn’t miss a beat. Not only was she Exceptional, but her personality was in unmatched especially given how busy it was. Unfortunately in the times we are living in you rarely experience OUTSTANDING service. Tara is a person of integrity. Thank you Tara, much appreciated!!! PeaceKid-friendliness: Tara and the bartender were extremely friendly.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Steak, French Onion Soup
We were disappointed ?. We were seated by the hostess promptly but the servers would not make eye contact. We waited patiently at first, after 15 minutes it turned into impatient. Finally the manager walked the floor and we told him we had not had any service, or acknowledgement we were even there. He offered free appetizers, which we did not want. He apologized and sent a server to us. He said the Ice Festival created a problem for them. We ordered our dinners, which were not great. Salad and vegetables were good. Steaks were tough to cut. Expensive meal for an unpleasant dinner
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
We went this past Friday and waited over an hour and half for steaks. We told the manager who went to back and we saw through the very visible window, the cooks throw the plates around and throw our ticket on top of one of our steaks. The grill was in a need of a cleaning, badly. Our steaks came out over cooked and somehow my husband’s steak was purple. We watched the cook use the same tongs to remove raw chicken and flip the done steaks. We noticed more than most because my husband grew up in the restaurant business. The waitress said she would get the manager but after leaving never came back with anything other than the bill. They took the alcoholic drinks off the bill but for steak dinners that took forever and overcooked we will not be back. With having kids, we don’t get out for dates much and it’s sad to have an experience like this. We have been to brown derby before and always have the best meals but seems like it’s headed in the wrong direction. Sadly, we will not be back.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 1
Service: 4
Great food and excellent
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Nice visit, good food.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Steak
Had a family gathering of 17 our waitress was great handled everything like a pro. The food was great, and all came out together. The pretzel appetizer was a hit with my family and the beer cheese it came with tasted great.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Loaded Idaho Baked Potato, Steak, French Onion Soup
We went there for my birthday. The food was excellent. We had steak, salmon and the stuff mushrooms for the appetizer. No one in our group complained about anything it was just delicious! Our server was really nice and picked up our bad jokes & joined in as well with a joke or two of her own. Plan on going there again for a night out or special occasion.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Caesar Salad, Grilled Shrimp, Steak
Restaurantji Recommends
Best steaks in Ohio. Yeah, better than Jeff Ruby's.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Loaded Idaho Baked Potato, Steak
Everything was fantastic!! Love coming here for dinner! The food was amazing, especially the shrimp and Caramel Toffee cake!! Our server Kari was top notch! ! Can’t wait to come back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Grilled Shrimp, Steamed Broccoli, Steak
Very close to outstanding, they just need to get their service figured out. Friendly staff, good value, great atmosphere, food was made well, but it arrived late and cold (45 minutes after ordering)
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Steak
Great food and
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Steak
Man, where do I even start? My wife, son, in-laws and myself came in on 1/26/24. There were 10 of us in total. Our waitress you could tell was overwhelmed. I get it, it sucks. But hey, it’s your job. Our rolls that came out at the start, were stale. You could tell they were under the heat lamps for a bit. The appetizers though, were fantastic and that’s where it ended. Not once the entire meal did I even get offered a refill on my coke. Then when my nieces got refills, the coke was flat and almost pure water. You could tell just by looking at it, it wasn’t right. But the waitress brought it out anyway. Then because our order was big, the waitress put our order on 2 tickets. I don’t know if she forgot to reiterate to the cooks that it’s all the same order, or what. But they were making the food as it were 2 different orders for 2 different tables. So while half of us got our food, the other half had to wait. Being family, naturally, we waited until everyone had their food to eat. So half of us had cold food. My wife’s French onion soup was cold, the onions also were still crunchy, not fully cooked. Then her sirloin was rare instead of medium. She sent it back and the second sirloin was the same. My brother in-laws mashed potatoes were stone cold. My mother in-law’s (who’s birthday it was that’s why we went out) lobster was tough and chewy. I got the porterhouse. I consider myself a steak snob. A porterhouse is supposed to be a thick cut. This thing was maybe 1/4in thick. I’m dead serious. There is absolutely NO WAY this was a porterhouse and definitely not 22oz before cooked. My wife’s sirloin was thicker and had more meat on it. What a joke. Then my steak was also medium well when I asked for medium rare, so it was tough. All of the steaks were completely unseasoned and bland as cardboard. My son’s chicken tenders were also the most generic tenders possible. We still tipped the waitress $100 even though we sure didn’t get $100 worth of service. The bill was over $500 for cheap, cold, bland food. Not worth it what-so-ever. You can go almost anywhere, get more food of better quality and pay less. It’s a real shame too. My wife and I went to the Brown Derby by us off Bagley several times, without issue. We went to this one because we saw they had fried green tomatoes, which my wife loves. We raved to my in-laws how good Brown Derby is and now they refuse to give the one on Bagley a try. We’ll be contacting corporate in the morning. This place is atrocious.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 2