13 Best Italian Restaurants in Mentor

Nonna T's Italian Restaurant Italian • $$
7345 Center St, Mentor

Customers` Favorites

Lamb Chops with Mushroom Risotto and Asparagus
House Bread and Dipping Oil
Italian Wedding Soup
Mediterranean Salad
Linguine with Clams
Stuffed Hot Peppers
Eggplant Parmesan
Homemade Tiramisu
Cheese Tortellini
Sautéed Calamari

“I was taken to Nonna's for the 1st. time to celebrate my birthday recently. The ambiance and servers are exceptional. Before ordering Nonna came out to introduce herself and wish me a happy birthday. I had the veal marsala. Every bite melted in my mouth. Then she came out with my favorite homemade tiramisu and enough cannolis for my family to enjoy. If you haven't experienced Nonna T's Restaurant make a reservation and get ready for some pampering. And you will definitely be taking some food home with you as her portions are like family style. Grazie Nonna see you again soon ??❤️??“

4.8 Superb87 Reviews
Maxim's Pizza Pizza Delivery • $
6966 Heisley Rd, Mentor

Customers` Favorites

Sausage and Cheese Pizza
Sausage Pizza

“Went in today and was taken right back to my childhood! Growing up near 185th we ate this pizza all the time! And happened to stop in at Mentor today and it’s the same great taste! Same wonderful friendly people and great conversations! A little slice of old world right in our backyards!!!“

5 Superb16 Reviews
Pastina Rustic Italian Restaurant Italian • $$
9354 Mentor Ave # 1, Mentor

Customers` Favorites

Butternut Squash Ravioli
Grilled Atlantic Salmon
Shrimp Scampi Pasta
Chicken Marsala
Chicken Alfredo
Pasta Bolognese
Chicken Piccata
Bread Pudding
Mushroom Pizza
Caesar Salad

“Great pasta dishes in a restaurant that resembles its rustic Italian name. I got the Chicken Diavolo and it was very good. There is one page of the menu that features what says is daily fresh made pasta...want to try some more of those. Prices are a bit high compared to other Italian places in the area, but portions are pretty good and food seems pretty high quality. Service was great at the bar. Restaurant is pretty large but it was busy and pretty full when I was there on Saturday. Will definitely go back again.“

4.4 Superb67 Reviews
Campola's Italian Bistro Italian • $
7224 Center St, Mentor

Customers` Favorites

Penne and Meatballs Side
Chicken Parmesan
Italian Calzone
Pasta Fagioli

“We stopped here to eat on a road trip.The food here was quite good.I got the chicken parmesan, and it was excellent. The chicken was not overcooked and dry, as is sometimes the case with that dish, and the sauce on the spaghetti tasted good, and homemade.My wife got the Spaghetti Aglio Olio with chicken. She enjoyed it quite a bit as well.Our kids split a cheese pizza, which of course they liked.Finally, we got some deserts. The kids each got a chocolate chip connoli, which was quite good and definitely sweet. They loved them.The service here was good, but slow. When we arrived, they were trying to keep everyone seated outside, and it seemed like there were 4 people doing everything (waiting tables, and cooking food). While it is understandable why this would slow them down, it did take a long time for us to get our deserts, and then the check, as a result.“

4.4 Superb12 Reviews
TJ's On the Avenue Italian • $
7485 Mentor Ave, Mentor

Customers` Favorites

Gluten Free Pasta with Meatballs and Marinara Sauce
Chicken and Shrimp Florentine
Italian Wedding Soup
Eggplant Parmigiana
Chicken Pecan Salad
Breaded Ravioli
Soup of the Day
Seafood Alfredo
Chicken Alfredo
Chicken Piccata

“Fantastic food! Our server was excellent as well. She kept 13 separate orders straight. And she joked and laughed with us as well.I highly recommend this restaurant. They have mainly Italian fare. But offer other dishes and sandwiches as well.“

4.3 Superb66 Reviews
Mama Roberto's Italian Restaurant Pizza • $
8658 Mentor Ave, Mentor

Customers` Favorites

Lasagna and Pasta Al Olio
Homemade Spinach Ravioli
Pull Apart Monkey Bread
Italian Wedding Soup
Stuffed Hot Peppers
Meat Lovers Pizza
Chicken Parmesan
Chicken Marsala
Fried Mozzarella
Pepperoni Pizza

“I'm Italian and grew up eating authentic Italian food prepared by my grandmother and great grandmother. I usually don't order Italian food from restaurants because it just doesn't compare. I decided to try lasagna from Mama Roberto's restaurant and I was surprised by how delicious and authentic it was! I will definitely be ordering again when I'm in the area. The quality and amount of food was exceptional! Thank you.“

4.3 Superb57 Reviews
Trios Italian Grille & Catering Italian • $
7537 Mentor Ave #23, Mentor

Customers` Favorites

Lemon Thyme Chicken Piccata
Bucatini Chicken Carbonara
Firecracker Shrimp
Chicken Parmesan
Mozzarella Sticks
Chicken Marsala
Garlic Bread
Veal Marsala
Trios Burger
Maui Pizza

“Our first time trying & we ordered take out, everything was amazing!! We ordered a lot to try a bit of everything and I highly recommend the inferno Alfredo pasta, firecracker shrimp, and Ebony & Ivory for dessert. We’re excited to dine in next time.“

4.3 Superb55 Reviews
Longo's Pizza Pizza • $
7314 Lakeshore Blvd, Mentor

Customers` Favorites

Meat Lovers Calzone
Large Deluxe Pizza
Eggplant Parmesan
Margherita Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
Meatballs Side
Cheesy Bread
Garlic Knots
Bruschetta

“We had our baby girls 1st birthday party here at Longos on Lakeshore. I have to say from the first call speaking to a young man named Sam who took my party reservations, giving me all the details lf my options for my party, being so kimd and patient with me and all of my questions, to the manager who called me the week before our party (I apologize I forgot her name) but she was absolutely a pleasure! And helped me out by telling me which way I would order would be the best for me financially and took my order. Today showing up early and Brittany our waitress was an absolute delight! She was on her game! She was kind, attentive and caring. She made sure our food came out quickly, and fresh! She came in often to check on us. We never had to wait for refills, we did not have to wait for her to come in to see if we needed more food, more drinks, plates and extra silverware for cake. When we did need to order a little bit more food, she was on top of it, it came out quick, and fresh again. My entire Party loved the food, the service, the atmosphere. The restaurant is clean. Everybody was so friendly. And honestly the last few years it’s really hard to get good service places. Longos did not disappoint. I will not only recommend this restaurant for dine in, but also for parties. Our gratuity was added into our check rightfully so but I honestly feel like Brittny deserves more money and should have given her more of a tip before we left. Our one year-old baby was screaming and crying so I’m definitely going to go back when Brittny is working and give her a little bit more because she definitely deserved it. She helped make , our babies first birthday party better than perfect and I am extremely grateful for that. Thank you Brittny, thank you to the managers, The cooks for making our wonderful, delicious food and everybody else who is involved in helping making this day. Perfect for not just my baby but my family as well.Vegetarian options: Longos has a wonderful vegan cheese, delicious marinara, and tons of veggies! Would love if they offered the garlic knots with either oil or vegan butter.Dietary restrictions: Vegan! ❤️?Parking: Great for this locationKid-friendliness: What kid doesnt love pizza! And we are vegan and longos has tge best vegan pizza around!!!!“

4.3 Superb37 Reviews
Spats Cafe Cafe • $
9853 Johnnycake Ridge Rd, Mentor

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Breast Grilled
Italian Style Burger
Beer Battered Cod
Chicken Parmesan
Spats Big Burger
Perch Sandwich
French Fries
Onion Rings
Patty Melt
Tuna Wrap

“Alas, another empty pizza box. What do you think that means?Such a gooooood pizza (I went Andy Griffith there on ya).Tremendous service, cold beer, really good food.If you’re reading this the ? Parm sandwich is also out of this world. Especially during the Monday Lunch Special.Nothing but Goodness ?….“

4.1 Good19 Reviews
Zappitelli's Pizza, Pasta & Parm Pizza • $
9570 Mentor Ave, Mentor

Customers` Favorites

Homemade Spaghetti with Meatballs
Chicken Parmigiana Dinner
Lasagna with Meatballs
Fettuccine Alfredo
Eggplant Rollatini
Fettucini Alfredo
Chicken Parm Sub
Chicken Marsala
Chicken Piccata
Homemade Pasta

“Being Italian , I have a hard time eating italian food in a restaurant, I have never had pasta sauce worth eating outside of my home.Zappitelli's does it right ! I ordered chicken Parmigiano, and it was enough for 2, but it was so good I ate all of it ,I was just amazed that it was as good or better than home cooked ,I will recommend this place for Italian food to anybody who asks me .“

4.2 Good72 Reviews
Longo's Pizza Italian • $
8907 Mentor Ave, Mentor

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Parmigiana Sandwich
Ullimate Pepperoni Pizza
Smashed Meatball
Garlic Rolls
Small

“We had our first date at Longo's Pizza over 24 years ago and like Longo's we are still going strong. Now our daughter gets to enjoy Longo's too! Our daughters favorite is their housemade fried pickles. My favorite is their out of the world smash burger it is huge and delicious. Of course my husbands favorite is the Pizza. My point you cannot go wrong with anything on Longo's menu. We order take out alot these days and they pack the food with such care. Here is to another 24 years or more!!!“

4.1 Good44 Reviews
Zeppe's Pizzeria Pizza • $
9950 Johnnycake Ridge Rd, Painesville

Customers` Favorites

Joey's Original Clevelander
Chicken Bacon Ranch
Chicken Tenders
Half Sheet Pizza
Zepperoni Rolls
Antipasta Salad
Wraps

“Hi. Just wanted to drop you a quick note about your Johnnycake Ridge Rd. location. We were on our way home from the Cleveland Zoo. We wanted good pizza. So we looked up nearest Zeppe's locations, as we live in Ashtabula, and we usually go to Geneva on the Lake for Zeppe's Pizza. We walked into the Johnnycake Ridge location, placed our order, the person that took our order was extremely kind and polite. Told us about 20 minutes for our food, which was a chef salad. 2 pizzas, and some zepperoni rolls. Came back in to pick up our food about 20 minutes later, food was ready to go, manager took care of us this time, she was also very polite and made us feel welcome and appreciated. You have some great team members in this location. Now, onto the food. The food, was EXCELLENT!!! Like I said earlier, we live in Ashtabula, and usually go to Zeppe's at Geneva on the Lake, because we know we will get great food. This location did not disappoint. Just a tremendously great experience all the way around. Thank you so much for the great personal treatment, the great food, and the overall just excellent customer experience.“

3.8 Good27 Reviews
Olive Garden Italian Restaurant Italian • $
7740 Mentor Ave, Mentor

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Parmigiana a Classic with Our Homemade Marinara and a Side of Spaghetti
Shrimp Alfredo Fettuccine Alfredo Tossed with Sautéed Shrimp
Asiago Tortelloni Alfredo with Grilled Chicken
Long Island Iced Tea and Frozen Margarita
Never-Ending Soup Salad & Breadsticks
Chicken Parmesan with Spaghetti
Chicken & Shrimp Carbonara
Five Cheese Ziti Al Forno
Create Your Own Pasta
Chicken Gnocchi Soup

“I ordered ahead on Easter Sunday. I had the chicken parmesean and a salad ? I arrived early, and upon arrival, my food was already ready. The service and staff were friendly and polite. I have it 4 stars because of the salad. It's not what it used to be.“

3.9 Good155 Reviews
Loading...
map Map