Restaurants near New Middletown

Hallowed Grounds Coffee Co. 13.5 Sycamore Dr, New Middletown Coffee Shops • $
13.5 Sycamore Dr, New Middletown

Customers` Favorites

Bagel with Cream Cheese for an Additional Charge
Mothman Mocha Latte
Shots of Espresso
Strawberry Latte
Iced Latte

“I come here a lot to study and it's the best! I'm a hardcore emo who has a large interest in everything creepy. Cryptids and all those things are a major aesthetic here. And they're always playing the best music. This place truly feels like home.”

4.9 Superb46 Reviews
Golden Rye Grille 10745 Main St, New Middletown American • $
10745 Main St, New Middletown

Customers` Favorites

Pancake
French Toast

“I love this place! Excellent service, excellent food and great prices. Waitresses are very friendly and efficient. Clean environment with a very interesting wall.”

4.7 Superb35 Reviews

3
Subway

Subway 10651 Main St, New Middletown Sandwich Shop • $
10651 Main St, New Middletown

Customers` Favorites

Steak
Cold Cut Combo
Bacon Egg
Cookies

“Best staff and quality of food. I know I’m not going to get skimped or poorly made food when I come to this subway. Other locations it’s a toss up what you will get-but never here. The ladies working are phenomenal!”

4.9 Superb13 Reviews
Dairy Queen Grill & Chill 10201 Main St, New Middletown Fast Food • $
10201 Main St, New Middletown

“Bad franchise owner/management period. They only staff 16 year olds and to their credit they get it done but still they leave 3-4 16 year olds unsupervised with no manager or someone old enough to buy cigarettes all the time. Crazy. 5/5 for the employees 0/5 for the greedy ”

3.7 Good23 Reviews
Cocca's Pizza 10829 Main St, New Middletown Pizza • $$
10829 Main St, New Middletown

Customers` Favorites

Pepperoni Roll
Rolls
Pepperoni & Meatball Grinder
Pepperoni Pizza
Deluxe Roll
Wings
Salad

“The best pizza around, hands down. And surprisingly for a pizza joint their subs are very good. The Philly Cheesesteak is on another level! The best one I have had in a long time!”

3.7 Good32 Reviews
De Chellis Italian Cafe 11092 Main St, New Middletown Cafe • $
11092 Main St, New Middletown

Customers` Favorites

All You Can Eat Fish
Sauce
Seafood Primavera
Salad

“Wonderful experience.The Cook was the one that took my carry out order, prepared it and also cashed me out. I can't speak for everyone but this guy was 100% awesome! Got the fish dinner and meatballs ....all delicious.Will be back!”

3.5 Good21 Reviews
KABOB HOUSE 621 Boardman-Canfield Rd, Boardman Mediterranean • $
621 Boardman-Canfield Rd, Boardman - 7.73 miles

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Kabob
Sauce
Kebabs
Eggplant Appetizer
Salad and Hummus
Lamb Chops
Custard
Feta Cigar
Turkish Coffee and Rice Pudding
Red Lentil Soup

“Absolutely the most wonderful restaurant in the area. The food is beyond fantastic and flavorful. The staff and owner are incredibly diligent to their customers and are wonderful and kind. It was my first time dining here and the owner personally came to my table to see what I liked and specifically created a dish just for me. I was served the most flavorful and best chicken I have ever eaten in my life. I completely recommend this restaurant and I personally cannot wait to go again.”

4.9 Superb100 Reviews

8
Pho LV

Pho LV 72 Boardman Poland Rd, Youngstown Vietnamese • $$
72 Boardman Poland Rd, Youngstown - 6.87 miles

Customers` Favorites

Vegetarian
House Special Combo Noodle Soup

“Food? Wayyyy better than the other Pho place around here. The service is 10/10,too. Bonus points for being a local family owned place. Prices are good. New fave.”

4.7 Superb186 Reviews
Sespe Burger 8252 Market St, Boardman Fast Food • $$
8252 Market St, Boardman - 6.1 miles

Customers` Favorites

Onion Rings
Avocado
Hamburger
Double Cheeseburger
French Fries
Double Burger with Bacon and Egg
Sespe Cart Burger Double
Sespe Burger and Fries
Single Cheeseburger
Avo and Egg Fries

“Hmmm… Someone has been to In-N-Out ??? honestly terrific food and cures the craving I have from not being close to an actual In-N-Out. I would give 6 stars if possible. Good job. Really wish your hours weren’t so weird. Would love to have for this dinner on a weekend or something. But I don’t run the place. ??‍♂️”

4.7 Superb167 Reviews
North Lima Pizza 11681 South Ave, North Lima Pizza • $$
11681 South Ave, North Lima - 5.31 miles

Customers` Favorites

Pepperoni & Cheese
Round Pizza

“BEST PIZZA EVER, NO ONE COMPARES TO THEM. GREAT PEOPLE THAT OWN IT. SASUAGE SANDWICH SO GOOD AND ALSO YOU CAN BUY BREAD AND ROLLS TO GO. I ALWAYS GET LIGHT ON THE SAUCE ON PIZZA. AND ANOTHER GREAT PIZZA IS THW WHITE PIZZA WITH MILD PEPPER RINGS AND SAUSAGE. BEEN GOIMG THERE FOR OVER 10 YEARS. IF U ARE AROUND THERE STOP IN AMD PLACE AN ORDER TO GO THERE IS NO SEATING INSIDE HOWEVER THAT DIDNT STOP US FEOM EATING THAT WHITE PIZZA ON THE CAR RIDE HOME.”

4.8 Superb104 Reviews
Sauceenio Boardman & sauceeino Mobile Food truck 4721 Market St, Boardman Mediterranean • $
4721 Market St, Boardman - 8.26 miles

Customers` Favorites

Wrap
Falafel
Boardman
Lamb Bowl
Smoky Barbecue Chicken Bowl
Sauceeino Lamb Plate
Chicken and Rice
Walnut Eggplant
Baba Gannouj
Youngstown

“I have never had a bad experience at Sauceeino. I love the food, especially the wraps and the homemade sauces! I would say that the portion size is generous especially given the affordable cost. The owner is very kind and always has great recommendations. Sauceeino is always a must-visit when I am home from school. I look forward to seeing how this family-owned business grows in the future ! :) #SupportFamilyOwnedBusinesses”

4.7 Superb135 Reviews
Horst Sub & Deli 5437 OH-7, New Waterford Sandwich Shop • $$
5437 OH-7, New Waterford - 10.5 miles

Customers` Favorites

Ham Salad
Chicken Salad
Meatball Sub with Cheese on Italian Bread
Pizza with Pepperoni Sausage and Peppers
Sausage Egg and Cheese Croissant
Roast Beef and Turkey Sub
Roast Beef Sandwich
Philly Cheesesteak
Chicken Salad Sub
Pepperoni Pizza

“It's a long drive but when we work in the area this is always the place we make sure to stop and eat it's our absolute favorite subshop you can't get a better sandwich or better service everything is excellent and we always end up leaving with extra odds and ends we haven't tried anything that wasn't great here stop in say hi you'll be treated like a friend and with the best service and food”

4.9 Superb64 Reviews
Condado Tacos 1051 Boardman Poland Rd Unit C, Youngstown Tacos • $$
1051 Boardman Poland Rd Unit C, Youngstown - 5.85 miles

Customers` Favorites

Beef
Dirty Sauce
Blue Dream
Korean BBQ
Tequila-Lime Steak Tacos
Bad Habit
Dr Pepper
Margarita Flight
Hard Shell Tacos
Traditional Guac

“When you make a stop after hours of caregiving and running errands, there is nothing you appreciate more than a friendly face when you stop to grab a quick meal. Miss Maya fills the bill. She’s a rockstar! Thank you!”

4.6 Superb220 Reviews
Sweet Melissa's Good Eats 85 Town Center Ave, Columbiana Comfort Food • $$
85 Town Center Ave, Columbiana - 7.04 miles

Customers` Favorites

Sweet Melissa
Tuscan Chicken
Cinnamon Harvest Salad
Purple Haze Salad
The Godmother
Quinoa and Cucumber Salad
Dr Feel Good Chicken Wrap
Jimmy-Crack-Corn Salsa
Buffalo Chicken Wrap
Greek Quinoa Salad

“Salads are great! Dips are great as well. Highly recommend if your in the area of this place. Atmosphere is great and staff were very pleasant and friendly. Looking forward to the next visit!”

4.9 Superb60 Reviews
C's Waffles Boardman 6526 South Ave, Youngstown Family • $
6526 South Ave, Youngstown - 6.36 miles

Customers` Favorites

Southern Mess
Hash Browns
Hungry Jack
Wednesday Special Meat Lovers Scramble
Waffle with Strawberry and Banana
Eggs and Waffle with Sausage
Scrambled Eggs and Bacon
Ham and Cheese Omelette
California Scrambler
Philly Cheese Steak

“Great food, great people. Only drawback is the entrance is very small and little room to wait for a table. Service has always been phenomenal and food done amazingly fast. Big fan of the pecan pancakes.”

4.7 Superb102 Reviews
Whistle and Keg 101 W Federal St A, Youngstown Bar • $
101 W Federal St A, Youngstown - 10.78 miles

“Came in tonight on my birthday. John was working and he was great! So friendly, answered all of our questions, we came in a bit later and he did not rush us. We had such a great time and chatted with John a bit. There are so many bars out there but the set up was special, and so was the service. Beer drinkers, you will love the selection, others will enjoy the hard liquor available, but everyone will enjoy the ambiance and friendly service you'll get when going to whistle and keg! Thank you!”

4.7 Superb101 Reviews

17
Sabi's

Sabi's 85 Town Center Ave, Columbiana American • $$
85 Town Center Ave, Columbiana - 7.04 miles

Customers` Favorites

Burger
French Onion Soup
Brussels Sprouts
Steak Salad
Gnocchi
Risotto
Butterscotch Cheesecake
Chicken Sandwich
One Hot Chick
Scallops Vol Au Vent

“Had dinner here last night and the food and service and price were excellent! We both had the Huli Huli Tomahawk Pork.... It was the best pork chop I have ever had! Every bite, including salads and sides was perfectly presented, excellent quality and deliscious. The wait staff were friendly, knowledgeable and attentive. The price was great, $52 for 2 and that included craft beer!The atmosphere is that of a neighborhood pub and I got the impression this is where the locals go. I am not a fan of televisions in restaurants, and they had 4 over the bar, volumes were low or off, but why? Maybe turn them off when there is not a game event, did not enhance the vibe. The lighting in the dinning room is weird. Canned ceiling lights shinning directly on the table made me feel like we were in a spotlight, but at least we could read the menu! With a few small tweaks in atmosphere, they are getting close to perfection. For an upscale healthy meal at a reasonable price, I highly recommend Sabi's, it is a hidden gem and worth the drive!”

4.8 Superb70 Reviews
Donavito's Restaurant & Catering Co. 139 S Bridge St, Struthers Italian • $$
139 S Bridge St, Struthers - 6.79 miles

Customers` Favorites

Ribs
Chicken Parm
Seafood N Pink
Wedding Soup
The Reuben
Steak and Mashed Potatoes
Sirloin Steak Dinner
Chicken Parmesan
Chicken Marsala
Pecan Chicken

“My new go to place when visiting family in Struthers. Never been dissapointed. Great selection, food, service. Nice to not be rushed out the door like some chain restaurants. Lamb lollipops are delicious.”

4.7 Superb90 Reviews
East Side Civics 968 E Midlothian Blvd, Youngstown Bar • $$
968 E Midlothian Blvd, Youngstown - 7.99 miles

Customers` Favorites

Pancakes
Grilled Chicken Wrap
Steak Salad

“Food is BEST when Blaine or James is cooking. They are fast, & on point. (Blaine is my favorite & I'm sad he doesn't work weds anymore) Best bartenders are Leslie, Heather, & Moe. Leslie has one waiting on the bar b4 I even walk in the door! I don't have to wait for drinks & Moe delivers to the patio if I've been out there too long & she knows I'll be out. Some nights are slower than others, but that's expected anywhere. Karaoke is on Wednesdays & great fun. I've held 3 adult birthday parties there & Leslie went out of her way to make each one special! She even picked a cake up FOR me to help with preparation bc I was running around ragged! If I had to complain about something, it would be that certain liquors that I drink aren't always in stock & their one fridge doesn't keep the beer quite as cold as it should be. But the bartenders adjust & compensate by putting them on ice when they see someone is drinking a brand from that fridge. Then they're ice cold & perfect. They hold free comedy nights, & have bands play occasionally. They do holiday parties w/ free food & involve the kiddos during the day for Halloween & Christmas. (sign up req) Annual membership price is very reasonable & event nights are open to the public w/out memberships.”

4.7 Superb90 Reviews
Butter Maid Bakery 425 Boardman-Canfield Rd, Boardman Bakery • $$
425 Boardman-Canfield Rd, Boardman - 7.51 miles

Customers` Favorites

Walnut Rolls
Chocolate Chip Cookies
Nut Kolachi Cookies Aka Kolacky Kolaczki Kiffles
Pecan Tarts Aka Tassies Caramel Cups Pies
Butterballs - Toasted Walnut Cookies
Poppy Seed Filled Kolachi Roll
Raspberry Walnut Kolachi Roll
The Original Nut Kolachi Roll
Chocolate Walnut Kolachi Roll
Apricot Filled Kolachi Roll

“Ordered the pecan cinnamon, kolachi nut roll online. It is so delicious!? The order came quickly with a sweet card from someone at the bakery. 2nd time I have ordered from Butter Maid Bakery. I have frozen the lemon cream & cream cheese rolls for Easter. The pecan roll never made it to the freezer, lol. So yummy!”

4.6 Superb141 Reviews
La Casa Mexicana 7334 Market St, Boardman Mexican • $
7334 Market St, Boardman - 7.04 miles

Customers` Favorites

Salsa
Guacamole
Birria Tacos
Refried Beans
Burrito
Street Tacos
Quesadilla
Flan
Enchiladas Santa Fe
Carne Asada Fries

“So happy they are here! It’s such a nice alternative to the others. The service is spot on like it should be. The food if fantastic. The management is hot on everything. Great place with great food! Thank you for being here.”

4.8 Superb64 Reviews
Hackett's Pub Youngstown, Ohio 1597 Mahoning Ave, Youngstown Bar & Grill • $$
1597 Mahoning Ave, Youngstown - 11.67 miles

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Tenders
French Fries
Hamburger

“We recently hosted a surprise party at Hackett's and it was absolutely wonderful! The owner Danny & his team were all very accommodating and helpful in the whole process! The bartender was a rockstar and the managers/staff were so nice! The outdoor patio is beautiful. And the bar has good food & cold beer! What more could you ask for! We will definitely be back to relax & enjoy a football game in the near future!”

4.8 Superb61 Reviews
MISSION BBQ 1051 Boardman Poland Rd Unit A, Boardman Barbecue • $$
1051 Boardman Poland Rd Unit A, Boardman - 5.84 miles

Customers` Favorites

Sauces
Pulled Pork
Cornbread
Brisket Sandwich
French Fries
Coleslaw
Baby Back Ribs
Meat Sampler
Pulled Chicken Sandwich
Potato Salad

“Such a friendly and attentive staff, great food no matter what you choose, and the atmosphere is the most patriotic I've ever experienced! Go before noon and stand for the national anthem. If you love our country, and love great food and service, you must go here!”

4.6 Superb127 Reviews
Sweet Melissa's Good Eats 6810 Market St, Youngstown Comfort Food • $
6810 Market St, Youngstown - 7.26 miles

Customers` Favorites

Salads
Dressing
Vinaigrette
Tuscan Chicken
Cinnamon Harvest Salad
The 305
Sweet Melissa's Signature Cookie
Chicken Gyro Power Bowl
Garlic-Chicken Salad
Chicken Wrap

“This place is a gem! Great healthy choices very clean. I love how Melissa makes all of her own dressing. Everything is fabulous great attitudes And the establishment is always clean. when I picked up my food today I only seen one thing that stood out to me, in the staff members in the back don’t wear gloves when handling food. I do know human behavior and sometimes no matter how clean we want to be with our hands sometimes that isn’t the case and with so many viruses and colds going around. I really like seeing establishments I eat at that is working with my food have gloves on there hands when maintaining or touching any type of food that Hass to go into my mouth. so for me that is the main thing that stands out to me and has me a little bit more cautious. however overall this establishment has four stars Melissa is doing a great job her staff is amazing in the environment is calm and chilled! However the members not having gloves in their hands definitely is a big deal to me and that is a personal observation .”

4.7 Superb81 Reviews
The Rod Tavern 3726 Loveland Rd, Youngstown Bar & Grill • $$
3726 Loveland Rd, Youngstown - 7.59 miles

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Strip Gyro

“The owner is a great guy, always around running a tight ship. The drink prices are reasonable. The kitchen staff are all very helpful, and cute! And the food is always a great deal for your money!”

4.7 Superb76 Reviews
Nicky's Pizzeria 1916 McCartney Rd, Youngstown Pizza • $
1916 McCartney Rd, Youngstown - 9.29 miles

Customers` Favorites

Pizza with Pepperoni and Mushrooms Extra Cheese Pizza
Large Sausage and Mushroom Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza and Hot Pepperd
Pizza with Sausage and Peppers
Spicy Ranch Wings
Pizza and Wings
Veggie

“Nickys Pizzeria in Youngstown, Ohio, is a local treasure that consistently delivers on the promise of mouthwatering pizzas and Italian delights. The menu boasts a tempting array of pizza options, all crafted with fresh ingredients and a perfect balance of flavors. Whether you prefer a classic Margherita or a specialty creation, Nickys excels in taste and quality. What sets this pizzeria apart is the friendly and welcoming atmosphere, making it a go-to spot for families, friends, and pizza enthusiasts. The attentive staff enhances the dining experience, ensuring guests feel right at home. Nickys Pizzeria is a must-visit in Youngstown, offering a slice of Italian culinary excellence that will leave you craving for more.”

4.8 Superb55 Reviews
Tebo's Caribbean Cuisine 4150 Market St, Boardman Caribbean
4150 Market St, Boardman - 8.62 miles

Customers` Favorites

Patty
Cornbread
Carrot Cake
Curry Chicken
Curry Shrimp
Brown Stew Chicken
Coco Bread
Cabbage And
Jerk Pork
Pulled Pork

“More of a take out joint. Friendly, efficient staff, amazing flavorful food! Try jerk chicken, cucumber salad (not sure of name), cabbage, rice, Mac and cheese! Great prices!”

4.8 Superb55 Reviews
Aladdin's Eatery Boardman 7325 South Ave, Boardman Mediterranean • $$
7325 South Ave, Boardman - 5.82 miles

Customers` Favorites

Spicy Cauliflower
Baba Falafel Rolled
Vegetarian Combo
Chicken Salad
Tabouli
Chili
Chicken with Hummus
Chicken Dijon Rolled
Baklava Cheesecake
Lentil Soup

“Unbelievable service came with my 93 yo mom and staff saw us and helped with doors and getting mom in! Food was outstanding ! We had taboule and the falafel wraps! Amazing ! Waitress was so kind and cheerful and helpful! We will be ba k every time we drive from pa to see mom! Cannot recommend good and kind staff enough. Waitress followed behind us and helped with doors without being asked. A five star experience all around!”

4.7 Superb70 Reviews
The Federal 110 W Federal St, Youngstown Burgers • $
110 W Federal St, Youngstown - 10.81 miles

Customers` Favorites

Grilled Cheese Burger
Sweet Potato Fries
John Wayne Burger
French Fries
Buffalo Chicken Sandwich with Garlic Parmesan Fries
Jack Frost Martini & Frosted Sugar Cookie
Vodka Penne with Blackened Chicken
The Grilled-Cheese Burger
Pulled Pork Nachos
Traditional Wings

“Great St Patrick's day pop up bar! Was in from out of town for an event, themed food was good but slightly overpriced for what it was. Would have been great to have been able to try the regular menu and not just the pop up items offered. Other than that overall great experience, our server was wonderful despite being super busy! Will try again next time I am in the area”

4.7 Superb69 Reviews
Hogan's Baking Co 113 S Main St, Columbiana Bakery • $$
113 S Main St, Columbiana - 8.8 miles

Customers` Favorites

Cookies
Doughnut
Birthday Cake
Apple Strudel
Bear Claw
Lemon Cupcakes with Blueberry Frosting
Italian Cream Cake
Kevin's Groom Cake
Black Forest Cake
Birthday Donuts

“They actually make you the cake you want! It turned out absolutely beautiful for our birthday party! Use alot of icing! Staff listens as you place your order and is very helpful. Love the holidays because they always have different and unique creations for each holiday ,cookie and cake wise! Great little bakery.”

4.7 Superb69 Reviews
map Map