“Ok! I came, I saw, I conquered!! Or, Veni, Vidi, Vici if you’re Julius Caesar! ? I’ve been saying I wanted to go check this place out for MONTHS and I finally made it in!!! I had looked up the menu and a couple things caught my eye that I wanted to try but mostly I was interested in the Root Beer on tap and the Homemade Cheesecake!!! I did try a couple items on the menu that were really good but I have fallen in love with the Root Beer and Cheesecake and will for sure return for those! ❤️❤️❤️ Thank you so much for the little visit, I know I was quiet tonight but I’m typically not!!! — Signed, Coriander ?“
“Excellent. Such a breath of fresh air to still have non-chain options for pizza. The value here is off the charts. I recommend Carmen's!We need to make it a priority to support these types of places... In this case, their good pizza makes it easy. They earn the support!“
“Several years ago I had a buffalo chicken pizza here and it was (sadly) kind of dry. When I went back I asked them for a buffalo chicken pizza with extra sauce-super saucy- and they did an amazing job. It was very sloppy and delicious. Not the normal but they did what I asked and it was exactly what I love. Thank you ?“
“Delicious, consistent pizza. They use a sweet pizza sauce and the cheese is always perfect. I'm not a fan of their sausage but that's ok. Also their bread sticks without cheese are craveable!Parking: The location is downtown Newark. Depending on whether there is a show at the Midland or not you may be walking a few blocks to get to the restaurant.Kid-friendliness: The atmosphere is super friendly and clean with a table of simple kid toys as well.“
“During our weekend getaway to Newark, from Columbus, we wanted to try a local pizza spot. Bavellies is a small establishment with great customer service. We decided to eat in their dining room. Ordered a small veggie pizza, steak sub, and small salad. The sub was delicious as the bread was really fresh. I enjoyed the thi. crust of the pizza and toppings were fresh. I would visit again if in the area.“
“This is probably the cleanest food place I have ever walked into! Somehow I missed that they have been in that location almost 6 yrs. Because my first question was did you just get this location it’s so clean! The 2 ladies working were absolutely wonderful very pleasant, I was greeted at my entry and they both were very kind “good cs skills”“
“Definitely not for the donatos crowd. This pizza is saucy and has an incredible thicker buttery crust. It honestly reminds me of how pizza hut pan pizza used to taste in the 80s. It's a very distinctive style and none of the places around newark make a pizza like this.“
“Tried a larg b.l.t. pizza and it was good and had a very fair share of toppings...... So the next day decided to try some wings bone in and bone out the garlic Parm sauce was fire. Potato wedges and cheese bread was fire to..... Oh and got delivered in like 40 minutes food was plenty hot when it arrived!“
“Panther Pizza is a hidden gem in Licking County. Not only is the pizza crust amazing, but the quality ingredients are what really makes the difference with their pizzas. The restaurant is charming and I have no trouble driving the extra miles to get a pizza from Panther. If you haven’t tried it, you are missing out on The best pizza in Licking county!“
“Past 30 yrs I've lived in Pataskala and Glenford , and I'll drive here without any regret. Won't find better prices . The best Italian sub I've ever had . Dressing absolutely amazing. Good variety of ice cold beverages. Have always treated me wonderfully .“
“Food is always great and I’m satisfied with my order. Occasionally it might take a little longer but it’s so worth it! Employees always seem to be in great moods too! Jen the GM is the best! Always double checks the orders and from the times I go in when she deligates the delivery orders very well between her drivers and always jumps in to help her staff when needed (you don’t see that much!)“
“Three generations of my family and just as many on my wife's side have been eating pizza here. My Dad went to school with a lot of the folks who run this place and my wife's grandparents got a massive pizza order every Friday for decades. This pizza is good feelings, great memories, and tradition for me. It's fantastic pizza as well with a completely unique crust. If you're looking for one of the absolute best pizza places in Newark, you'll be hard pressed to find something better than Louie's. I love this place and hope it never changes.“
“I buy pizza from here weekly, their pizza is the best in Newark in my opinion, I’ve ALWAYS had good experience here. But this evening I ordered a medium mario pizza at 830 (they close at 9pm)I added ranch topping on top, not sure but almost positive they forgot my hot honey. (Compared to other times I’ve had it)Other than that which made me make this review is my bad experience, my good experience overweighs the bad ones, everyone has their day and I get it. No one is perfect. But if you are looking for an amazing deep dish pizza order it well done! And you will not be disappointed. (From a pizza perspective of many different company’s)Company reached out to me directly and fixed my issue! It was a honest mistake!“