Restaurants near Newcomerstown

April's Country Kitch'n 640 Heller Dr, Newcomerstown Family • $
640 Heller Dr, Newcomerstown

Customers` Favorites

Liver and Onions
Sausage Gravy
Salad Bar
Hash Browns
Mashed Potatoes

“After moving out of Ohio 9 years ago, April's was my first stop when I returned for a visit. It did not disappoint. The food is seriously good home style cooking and the staff is as friendly as I remember.”

4.3 Superb135 Reviews
Rainbow Hills Winery, Brewery & Pizzeria 26349 Township Rd 251, Newcomerstown Wineries • $$
26349 Township Rd 251, Newcomerstown

“Food was fantastic. We got delivery. The owner was an absolute sweetheart and actually gave me the location to propose to my now finance through brief talk. The calzone was a 10/10”

4.9 Superb24 Reviews
Dick's Place 102 N Bridge St, Newcomerstown American • $$
102 N Bridge St, Newcomerstown

Customers` Favorites

Fresh Cut Fries

“Important note, place only excepts cash. There is a ATM inside but it charges a fee to use. My first time here. Invited by coworker to check out. Outside is easy to miss because it is a plain building. Inside clean and old but clean. Many pictures of historic Newcomerstown. I order a 8oz sirloin steak medium well with baked potato, green beans and Dr. pepper for $19.02. It took awhile to cook steak. I order medium well as a test because I like mine well done but places tend to burn or dry them out instead. A little more red than I like but not bad and skillet fried. Very hot baked potato. I ate my green beans and steak before finishing the baked potato and it still was steaming hot. Green beans soft and good. My negatives is only butter for potato and nothing else. Steak a little rubbery and more red than I like but still tasty, and the cash only. I didn't take pictures since it is a local restaurant and the people seemed a little annoyed when I tried to take one. Local people are there for food and relax and expect the same from others. Friendly. I may check it again another time. It's not bad. Not exactly four stars but not a three either.”

4.3 Superb75 Reviews
Chilly Willy's 401 W State St, Newcomerstown Ice Cream Shop • $
401 W State St, Newcomerstown

“We love Chilly Willy's!!! Today only had ice cream--large hand dipped pumpkin in bowel and a medium chocolate and vanilla twist in a waffle cone. The pumpkin ice cream was really good. Wife said her cone was super good--she always says that. Service was by owners today, who are super friendly. They plan to stay open this Winter!!!! We always tip. Please consider doing so as well if you are able. Regardless, ENJOY”

4.4 Superb50 Reviews
Terry's Pizza Shoppe 433 W State St, Newcomerstown Pizza • $
433 W State St, Newcomerstown

Customers` Favorites

Mushroom Burger
Buffalo Wings
Chicken Wings
Tossed Salad
Onion Rings
Breadstix
Pizza Sub
1 Breast
Fish

“The food is absolutely delicious! Excellent,fish, chicken and subs. Pizza good too! Very caring staff who want to be sure you love your food and are enjoying yourself!!! Haven't tried everything to give an opinion but everything I have tried has been great ?”

4.2 Good34 Reviews
Damon's All American Pizza Pie 306 B, 306 S College St, Newcomerstown Pizza • $$
306 B, 306 S College St, Newcomerstown

Customers` Favorites

Meat Pizza
Homerun Pizza
Mexican Stix
Cheesestix

“This is a gem in Newcomerstown. Working this far from major businesses leaves people lacking in options for lunch. The pizza here I would compare to Flyers, Joeseppies, etc in Columbus but some of the options are not as good as them either. The pepperoni pizza or all meat pizza for example are top notch but everything else is above average. I order chicken bacon ranch subs often from them but only because it's better than Subway chicken and fresher tasting due to the oven baked method versus the microwave Subway uses but the sub is not as good as Penn Station or Charley's subs. The steak sub is not great but better than Subway due to being baked. The service is fast and friendly and they always deliver on time or ahead for me. The ambience, well this is in a run down looking building and I am not sure why but this could be out of their hands. They do appear to keep it clean every time I have been in there but it does need a facelift inside and out, and better sign for location and door to distinguish it from the other businesses. Overall not a bad place.”

3.8 Good27 Reviews

7
Subway

Subway 578 N College St, Newcomerstown Sandwich Shop • $
578 N College St, Newcomerstown

Customers` Favorites

All
Sweet Onion Chicken Teriyaki
Sunchips Harvest Cheddar
Italian B M T
Pizza Sub
Cookies
Lay

“A little disappointed this time. One guy made all the subs while I was in there while everyone else just stood around. My disappointment comes from the quality of the cookies I bought. The raspberry cheesecake cookie is my absolute favorite but the cookies were so burnt I couldn't eat them. Both the raspberry cheesecake and the new Reese piece's cookies were burnt.”

3.6 Good72 Reviews
China Star 240 E Canal St, Newcomerstown Chinese • $
240 E Canal St, Newcomerstown

Customers` Favorites

Sweet and Sour Combo Plate

“"Eat in" is a matter of opinion. Sat down and got our food as if we were taking it out. No plates, tiny plastic utensils. Good food, good value and the locals clearly have it figured out that this place is 95% take out based. The 8 years old running the place has a bright future.”

3.3 Good38 Reviews
Taco Bell 5275 E State Rd, Newcomerstown Fast Food • $
5275 E State Rd, Newcomerstown

Customers` Favorites

Mexican Pizza
Quesadilla
Soft Taco
Gordita Supreme
Nacho Fries

“I travel cross country at least twice a year. I've been to 40 states and countless taco bells in between. Never in my life has a taco bell delivered such fantastic service. Best taco bell I've been to from the west coast to the east coast this location takes the cake. If you're driving through Ohio, I highly recommend stopping here and getting a grilled cheese burrito with chicken. They're fast, attentive, and polite. The food was neat and accurate to order as well as the rest of the restaurant being very clean and well kept. Whoever was working on 08/17/2023, thank you for your service ?”

3 Average44 Reviews

10
Wendy's

Wendy's 110 Morris Crossing Ave, Newcomerstown Fast Food • $
110 Morris Crossing Ave, Newcomerstown

Customers` Favorites

Wendy
Hamburger
Baconator
French Fries
Fries And
Classic Chicken Sandwich
Jr Bacon Cheeseburger
Coke Products
Small Chili
Nuggets

“Love the baconator that burger rocks it. The service at the location route 36 off 77 n or south going towards New Comerstown has the best service I've seen since I live in Canton Wendy's is located at Faircrest and the intersection of 77n or s.these 2 Wendy's restaurants are by far the best places to get great service and have great parking for whatever your driving.Parking: Made for cars and has semi parking too.Wheelchair accessibility: Yes both locations have wheelchair accessibility.”

2.9 Average66 Reviews
McDonald's 211 Adena Dr, Newcomerstown Fast Food • $
211 Adena Dr, Newcomerstown

Customers` Favorites

Big Mac
Sausage Burrito
Baked Apple Pie
Hotcakes
Hamburger
Kiddie Cone
Egg Mcmuffin
Filet-O-Fish
Big Breakfast
Bacon Egg & Cheese Biscuit

“The service was fast and good. The food was very good comparatively speaking. The bathrooms were clean. A very big selling point was the pictures of Cy Young a great pitcher and Woody Hayes one of the greatest college football coaches”

2.8 Average78 Reviews
Wooly Pig Farm Brewery 23631 Township Rd 167, Fresno Brewery
23631 Township Rd 167, Fresno - 6.95 miles

“This is a local brewery. The atmosphere was fantastic. Everyone was having a good evening. We stopped there for my Birthday. We'll go by the next time we're in the area.”

4.9 Superb51 Reviews
Stonecreek Bar & Grille Inc 203 Marietta St, Stone Creek Bar • $
203 Marietta St, Stone Creek - 9.05 miles

“I am not a regular, but go quite often, i always get good food and good service, they have a nice selection of beers wines and liqueurs... i used to go in when i was a kid 50 years ago... it hasnt change a whole lot”

4.8 Superb12 Reviews
T J's Restaurant & Lounge 100 North St, Stone Creek French • $$
100 North St, Stone Creek - 9 miles

Customers` Favorites

Swiss Steak
French Fries
Home Fries
Double Cheeseburger
Roast Beef Dinner
Home Made Pie

“My mom and I were on the way back from Cleveland Clinic, and found this little place. The service was great and the homeiness of the atmosphere made me feel comfortable. Not to mention the food was great and out super quickly. I would absolutely go back.”

4.6 Superb33 Reviews
YOLO Winery 16286 OH-93, Kimbolton Wine Bar
16286 OH-93, Kimbolton - 8.61 miles

“Such a great laid back winery. This winery has tons of different wines to try and I feel like there's something for everyone. They seem to have a lot of different entertainment and activities that pop in throughout the days. I recommend getting the flight of different wines to taste. They have a great promotion to tagalong with this. If you purchase a flight you were able to purchase a small travel cup with a lid or a glass with their winery name. This makes for a super cute souvenir piece. I recommend grabbing a bottle of their heavenly nights.”

4.5 Superb41 Reviews
White Eyes Pizza & Carry Out 26366 Co Rd 171, Fresno Pizza
26366 Co Rd 171, Fresno - 8.38 miles

Customers` Favorites

Meatball Sub
Deluxe Pizza

“This place is sweet. Grab a pizza, gas, chips, and hardware. Libs should probably stay out, but I’m guessing there aren’t many of those in Coshocton county anyways.”

4.4 Superb64 Reviews
Raven's Glenn Winery & Restaurant 56183 Co Rd 143, West Lafayette Italian • $$
56183 Co Rd 143, West Lafayette - 5.26 miles

“Came here for an engagement dinner as we came from out of town to stay at an amazing nearby cabin. Everything about the place was delightful. Had live music, both our waiter and waitress had been outstanding personalities. The food was amazing, I got the expresso steak, my finance got the chicken Caesar salad. The wings for an appetizer were some of the best around and the buffalo sauce was such a treat, will be back.”

4.2 Good65 Reviews
Marvie's Park Market 13964 Freedom Rd, Kimbolton Ice Cream Shop
13964 Freedom Rd, Kimbolton - 10.72 miles

“Nice little shop to grab libations and necessities while you are camping. Near Rocky Fork Resort and Big Sky Campground.Found this delicious, perfect for summer beer!”

4.1 Good33 Reviews
Dari Hut 408 E Main St, West Lafayette Burgers • $
408 E Main St, West Lafayette - 7.43 miles

“Love the food! I don't recommend the kraken burger. The bun sounded like you're cutting through Styrofoam and it was hard as a rock. I'm thinking it was supposed to have bacon on it as well and it didn't. The macaroni and cheese bites were amazing!”

3.9 Good36 Reviews
map Map