15 Best Pizza Restaurants in Pickerington

MOD Pizza Pizza • $
1301 Hill Rd N, Pickerington

Customers` Favorites

Create Your Own Pizza
Mad Dog
Salad

“Came into MOD pizza on pickerington tonight at 8pm and had the best experience I've ever had in "fast food" the place was clean, and the staff were all amazing ! Jaz made our pizzas with so much love. She explained the process of making my pizza, offered all Toppings and I didn't feel rushed. I also want to shout out the rest of the staff ! You could tell every person cared about their job and put their all in their task. Everyone I interacted with was polite. Thank you for the positive interactions and making my night smooth and my belly full.“

4.5 Superb51 Reviews
Omezzo Restaurant & Pizzeria Italian • $$
1755 Hill Rd N, Pickerington

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Parmesan and Angel Hair Pasta
Chicken Penne Carbonara
Lobster Bisque Soup
Italian Wedding Soup
Eggplant Parmesan
Chicken Francaise
D Lobster Ravioli
Chicken Milanese
Chicken Marsala
Garlic Bread

“We recently dined at O’mezzo Italian Restaurant, a charming and unassuming eatery nestled among other shops in Pickerington. The small and quaint dining room exudes a cozy atmosphere. On a bustling Saturday evening, finding a seat proved a bit challenging amidst the crowd. While it wasn't clear whether we should wait for seating, we eventually approached the counter to inquire. Once seated, a prompt server attended to us.Exploring the menu, we opted for the chicken gnocchi, spaghetti and meatballs, and fettuccine Alfredo with chicken. It was a letdown to discover that bread and the starter salad came at an additional charge. While browsing the wine list, I found the red wine offerings somewhat limited.When our entrees arrived, our disappointment waned as the dishes proved to be truly delightful. The pasta boasted a perfect texture, and the meatballs accompanying the spaghetti were exceptional—among the best I've had in a restaurant. My fellow diners also raved about their choices. It's worth noting that the overall cost of the meal, considering the absence of included salad or bread, leaned toward the higher side for a non-chain, family restaurant.Despite these limitations, I would gladly return for dinner, now armed with this information. O’mezzo Italian Restaurant offers a worthwhile dining experience, especially for aficionados of Italian cuisine. The delicious entrees and cozy atmosphere make it a destination worth considering, despite a few minor shortcomings.“

4.4 Superb57 Reviews
Grapevine Pizza & Cafe Pizza • $
8581 Refugee Rd, Pickerington

Customers` Favorites

Medium Pepperoni Pizza
Traditional Wings
Baked Spaghetti
Buffalo Chicken
Fried Pepperonis
Fried Mushrooms
Hawaiian Pizza
Meatball Pizza
White Pizza
Popcorn

“Just heard about the new Burger special that was recently added to the Lunch menu. Well I gotta tell you, Josh the owner cooked that Burger to perfection. Anyway I guess the burgers are only available during lunch hours for now, as Grapevine is mainly known for their outstanding pizza and subs. keep up the good work Grapevine.“

4.3 Superb77 Reviews
Pizzeria New York Pizza • $
833 Hill Rd N, Pickerington

Customers` Favorites

Pepperoni Pizza
Zucchini Sticks
Stuffed Shells
Cheese Pizza
Garlic Knots
Breadsticks
Meat Pizza
Pinwheels

“Just came to say the customer service here is wonderful. I had a small issue with a charge on my credit card and the owner of the business gave me her personal cell phone number, told me to message her the details, and even replied to my texts when she was on vacation out of the country!!“

4.4 Superb46 Reviews
Cardo's Pizza & Tavern Pizza • $
7897 Refugee Rd, Pickerington

Customers` Favorites

Sausage Onion and Pepperoni Pizza
Spaghetti and Meatballs
Chicken Parmesan Dinner
Chicken Tenders
Chicken Wings
Gondola Sub
Meat Pizza
Cardo

“Our go-to pizza place for Friday night. They began a drive up pizza pick up service that is ideal for grab and go, for you are home while the pizza is still piping hot. Very competitive prices for the area and some of the best pizza + crusts in town“

4.2 Good58 Reviews
Flyers Pizza Pickerington Pizza • $
8220 Refugee Rd, Pickerington

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Wings

“We may be slightly biased because our oldest son works here but honestly, we love the food, too! The pizza crust is a great middle ground between thin and traditional, not too dry/crispy, not too doughy. Our boys also love the subs and wings! We hear compliments from the community all the time on the friendliness of the high school staff members and are proud that ours is included in that group. It says a lot about the owners/management. Keep up the great work!“

4.4 Superb33 Reviews
MacKenzie River Pizza, Grill & Pub American • $
1281 Hill Rd N, Pickerington

Customers` Favorites

California Chicken Flatbread
Reuben Sandwich
Pepperoni Pizza
Artichoke Dip
Spicy Chicken
Cowboy Nachos
Flat Bread
Flatbreads
Cobb Salad
Tortilla

“1st time there. The food is great. Good portions. Willing to substitute menu side. Arnold-Palmer beverage required simple syrup. Service was a bit slow. (It's like that just about everywhere anymore, unfortunately.) However, staff were friendly and accommodating. Clean facility. Even the laminated menus were clean. YES, real menus a huge plus! Will return.Vegetarian options: Bean burger“

4.1 Good86 Reviews
Pizza Cottage Pizza • $$
1000 Old Diley Rd, Pickerington

Customers` Favorites

Pepperoni Pizza Small Pizza
Garlic Bread with Cheese
Loaded Baked Potato Pizza
Cauliflower Pizza
Personal Pizza
Meatball Sub
Italian Sub
Chef Salad
blt Pizza
Hawaiian

“Stopped in after an exhausting hour at the trampoline park tonight. Beth was such a great waitress. My 9yr old and her complimented each other and joked together. The food was soooooooo good. Very clean inside and very comfortable. I love the size of their booths “

4.2 Good52 Reviews
Gionino's Pizzeria Pizza • $$
12983 Stonecreek Dr, Pickerington

Customers` Favorites

Medium Pepperoni Pizza
Pep Pizza and Jo
Specialty Pizza
Salad Dressing
Fried Chicken
Cheese Pizza
Deluxe Sub
Jojo's
Wings

“Got chicken and JoJo's... Pizza.. Italian sub.. and wings ?? all ranged from pretty good to killer... My kids approved, it's going to be added to the rotation!!! Kinda wish they had a proper dining space, but I don't hold it against em!!“

4.2 Good50 Reviews
Omezzo pasta bowl + Rice & Curry Halal Bistro Italian • $$
1757 Hill Rd N, Pickerington

“Had dinner at Omezzo. Very homely and excellent food. Lobster ravioli (we took the appetizer version) was amazing! Lobster bisque was good. We also had Trio Omezzo which is a selection of three types of pastas on one plate (better to share as the portion is quite big). Overall delicious!“

4.5 Superb22 Reviews
IL Forno Pizza • $
1146 Hill Rd N, Pickerington

Customers` Favorites

Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Margarita Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
Cheese Pizza
Meat Pizza

“This place is simply amazing!The owner is a good buddy and the pizza is fantastic! And to that Christopher dude, I talked to the owner about that and he showed me his order receipt, he made that pizza and gave it to the dasher. If you didn’t get your pizza complain to DoorDash, not Il Forno. Oh and you didn’t leave a $10 tip for him ?I tell the owner ever time I get a pizza that it’s the best in Ohio, and as a pizza lover I don’t make comments like that lightly. This place is phenomenal, keep up the good work man!“

4.2 Good37 Reviews
Marco's Pizza Pizza • $
1745 Hill Rd N, Pickerington

Customers` Favorites

Pepperoni Magnifico
Steak and Cheese
Build Your Own
Chicken Wings
Cinnasquares
Deluxe Pizza
Italian Chef
Cheezybread
Italiano

“I love me some Marco's Pizza. The subs are absolutely my favorite. I haven't had a bad pizza from here at all. Marco's provide quick service and my food is always hot and fresh every time. Hands down my one of my favorite spots. You will not be “

4 Good48 Reviews
Twin's Tavern Pubs • $
1128 Hill Rd N, Pickerington

“If you are looking for a fancy place with a big menu full or fine dining foods and pinkies-out cocktails, this is not it.If you are looking for a corner bar where everyone knows each other by name, plays pool and darts together, shares pizza, and does shots until closing time, Twins is definitely worth checking out.“

3.9 Good10 Reviews
Donatos Pizza Pizza • $
1214 Hill Rd N, Pickerington

Customers` Favorites

Big Don Italian with Sausage
Medium the Works
Pepperoni Pizza
Create Your Own
Boneless Wings

“We went here for my nephews 4th birthday! He loves donatos pizza. They had a private room that you could reserve free of charge. The room had a door to close off from the rest of the dining area with a TV equipped with cable. We ordered 5 large pizzas watched TV and even cut a cake that they allowed us to bring in. Will do this again. Nice intimate but casual setting to enjoy food and family.“

3.7 Good40 Reviews
Jet's Pizza Pizza • $
201 Clint Dr, Pickerington

Customers` Favorites

Pizza
Wings

“There is a fabulous deal going on with Jets and the Columbus Blue Jackets hockey team. 50% off on only the pizzas the next day when the team scores 2 or more goals. I do online orders for pick up. Note there is NO place online to put in a tip for the kitchen folks. I always tip cash (at a percentage as if there were no discount) when I pick up the pizzas. I asked the last time I went why tipping isn't on the website and the employee said that option was removed from the website. They do 4 kinds of pizza - Detroit, New York, hand tossed and thin (cracker crust).Parking: Lots of space“

3.6 Good38 Reviews
Loading...
map Map