“I can't stop thinking about this place!! Everything was beyond incredible.... But that pasta..... A homemade pasta and pasta sauce is to literally die for!!! I also really appreciate how we ordered a pizza there and we didn't want mushrooms so we took them off and our waiter took some money off our pizza price to correspond with us removing a topping. I have never had a place do that for us but that's really smart and kind of them, so thank you for whoever came up with that clever idea. Also thank you to the staff there for making that whole experience as superb as it was!“
“Carlucci's is it. Super consistent and my favorite local pizza place. All the specialties are good, made fresh and made with care. Prices are pretty reasonable too. I highly suggest you check out Carlucci's as it will NOT disappoint.“
“Best pizza I've had in a long time! Usually at other pizza places there's one thing I don't really like whether it be the pizza sauce or just a topping I'm not crazy about compared to other places everything here that was simply amazing and the crust was awesome and everybody was really nice. It's a great experience as soon as you walk in the door. I've been wanting to try here for about 6 months now and I'm glad I finally did today!“
“BEST PIZZA IN THE COLUMBUS AREA!!This is NY pizza! I'm a born and raised New Yorker, and this is legit! It's literally the only pizza in Columbus I actually want to have. Sure there are a lot of pizza places around, and in a lot of ways they are all the same, with maybe some subtle differences. BUT, Brooklyn Pizza is the only place around where you can get a true NY pie, and a darn good one too!!“
“They have one of the best pizzas I've ever tasted! We have to travel about 20-30 mins to get to this location, but it's so worth it. We know everyone there in only a few visits cause they treat you like friends and family. If it wasn't so far away from my house, I'd literally order delivery everyday! Thank you, PIZZA COTTAGE.Starr and Brian Mays“
“Great deep-dish pizza. All edge pieces always have some crispy parts. Jet's Bread is always a good addition. Only ever once had a problem with my order and they fixed it quickly. If my family is craving some thick crust pizza, this is my go-to store.“
“I'd normally do carry out but the pizza is always good. Staff has always been on top of everything and I've never gotten the wrong order. Wish the price wasn't so high but still worth the money.Kid-friendliness: Definitely a fun place to take the family. Well decorated in. Not like a pub with a bunch of people drinking.“
“Shout out to the NICEST young man named Andrew, who provided exactly the kind of customer service of which Jane would be proud! It's so hard to find anymore, but he had the biggest smile and was so helpful - truly representing the neighborhood pizzeria.“
“Not sure if it's changed management or they just gotten new help but this visit was better than those I've had in the past. The pizza was cooked a little long on one side but still tasted good and everyone seemed to enjoy the cheese bread. Will definitely be giving this location a try again in the future.“
“I've actually never been to this café/restaurant but have ordered from them countless times: without question, one of the most amazing and delicious options for health-conscious lunch or dinner in the Columbus area. Their food is fresh, inspired and thoroughly satisfying. I regularly get their spectacular Buffalo Chicken Pizza, sometimes a wrap (love their Asian Thai!), plus maybe a side salad (such as egg) and a smoothie (Açaí is my favorite). And they have so many other options I haven't even tried yet! Check out their website - they list detailed nutritional information for each item which is super helpful if you're tracking what you eat. I am just really grateful this place exists and hope they keep going for a long time.“
“This was the first time in awhile that we went to Vittoria. And I don't know why we waited so long. The food was excellent. Service was top notch. The owner chatted with every table. It felt like my Italian grandma's house with everyone joyfully talking and eating. It's my new top choice for a dinner out.“