Restaurants near Tarlton

“Our new pizza spot! The best pizza we've had since we were kids! The crust was perfect! The toppings were awesome! And the customer service was friendly and welcoming. So glad we were told about this place! We'll definitely return on a consistent basis!”

“In a quiet town of Tarlton Ohio.Is the best little restaurant called Crosstown Creamery with the BEST hand dipped ice cream.Whether it's Feb . Or July stop by to enjoy lunch, leave some room for ice cream. Shakes, sundaes.Are there as well.We travel one and a half hours to visit old friends and to get some ice cream. Beautiful area to go for a country ride. Look them up tell them Barb sent you.Enjoy your dY.Parking: Nice and flat to get in.Wheelchair accessibility: Nice and flat to get in building.Closest to building.”

“Food prices on the menu were good for the portion size that came from the kitchen. Only got a couple draft beers. Nice environment inside and looks like the place could be lots of fun for a night of music and pool.”

“Best pizza around these parts for 30 miles of better. Always hot and always good. We've bought from them countless times, and never once had any issues. that's saying a lot these days! The place is always clean.”

“The owner, Nicole, and her husband are so amazing! A group of 6 of us came to celebrate my birthday and we tried a bunch of their wines and ciders and we never had a bad one. They were so welcoming and sweet and the meat and cheese and Mediterranean boards were so good! 10/10 recommend stopping by”

“Long time customer here - contacted Clearcreek Cakes and Bakes for my 8 year old's birthday cake and gave them an idea of what I envisioned, something girly and candy themed and popping with color including the actual cake. Per usual, the cake was absolutely perfect upon pick-up and we received compliments from almost everyone, including strangers, in regards to the creativity of the cake. It also tasted delicious!”

“Great small town Cafe, very much a "mom & pop" type atmosphere with great comfort food including homemade pies & cakes. Located near hocking hills state park. Very reasonably priced home cooked food.Vegetarian options: Kinda scarce.... this is more a meat and potatoes place”

“This mom and pop shop right on the outskirts of Amanda and Lancaster is top-notch! We have been fortunate enough to try many menu items and have never been disappointed. I personally could eat the brisket daily! They offer weekly specials and always have excellent pricing with generous portion sizes.”

“One really nice place. Food was excellent, service top notch, price very reasonable and the atmosphere was relaxing. Will make it a point to stop back in. Five Stars across the board!”

“Ended up here by accident and it turned out amazing. Small town homey feel, and our waitress may have been the nicest lady alive. The food was all homemade and delicious. We started with deep fried mushrooms and I got a smokehouse steak sub w/ fries. The in house smoky mayo was great on the sub and fries, my girlfriend got a Ruben it was also delicious. Grabbed a couple of there "famous donuts" for the road. And it was the best d*** glazed donut I ever tried.”

“We were staying in an air B&B nearby and decided to stop for a beer. We enjoyed Friday evening so much we went back Saturday evening. Great service and excellent prices. I highly suggest it. We will be back!!!”

“Stopped in for breakfast and what a gem this place is.The food was hot, taste and plentiful. Ali was just wonderful.The atmosphere was inviting and has the small town charm that makes you want to return. Give Steve's a try you will be glad you ”

“We went to Mam's for our Valentine's Day dinner. Our builder, Jeremiah Cradlebaugh with Cradlebaugh Builders recommended it to us tonight so we stopped in and had burgers and fries and cheesecurds. They were all pretty good. Our waitress was so nice and the restaurant was clean and tidy.”

“SO GOOD!! The baristas here are all so so nice, the drinks are reasonably priced, and so delicious!!! Making the drive is worth it, would highly recommend people to come try this place!”

“My cousin and I stumbled across this little gem! Laurelville’s Pizza is definitely the spot to dine when in the area!!! Great food, excellent service!!! I would give 10 stars if I could!!!”

“Stopped by here during our day trip around Ohio. They make fried pies to order. I ordered an apple fried pie and it was delicious. My husband got a milkshake and I tried some chocolate hand dipped as they was out of chocolate soft serve. Very good sweets and awesome service.”

“We eat here a lot, it's one of our family favorites. We sometimes get their pizza which is our favorite. Sometimes we get burgers and milkshakes and those are delicious too. We have not really been disappointed with anything we have tried. We usually do takeout but have eaten there a few times too and have always been happy with the service. It's a casual place and has a relaxed atmosphere. Great for a quick lunch too.Kid-friendliness: It's a great place to take kids. They love the food here.”

“Great local place to have s cold beer & great pizza. Nice patio to enjoy. Everyone was very friendly & seemed like you were part of the “Cheers” gang. Will definitely go back.”

“Cash or check only, so be prepared. It was very busy on a Wed night. Try to sit closer to the bar, as the area near the door is used by parents as a place to let their kids cut loose. Wed must be karaoke night - there were some truly talented singers.”

“Just popped in for a celebratory adult birthday beverage. It was ice cold, the remodel looks very nice and the atmosphere was enjoyable. Look forward to visiting again.”

“I tried the cauliflower pizza, their everything one. I didn’t get the name. The crust was crunchier than most, which I loved! A lot of times they tend to be soft/soggy. It used to be a sit down restaurant, but it’s now a drive through. The way it’s roped off is confusing at first. The sign has a Bible verse “man shall not live by bread alone, but by every word of God” Luke 4:4. Lol”

“I have always loved Cristy's Pizza since I was a kid growing up in Lancaster. Their pizza is always amazing and quality very consistent and great. I'm super cheap though and sometimes they're just a little out of my range especially without deals or coupons, but I highly recommend for a great pizza!Vegetarian options: They even offer a cauliflower crust pizza for vegans or gluten free option”

“I've liked the changes I've seen in this sub shop over the past few years. My only complaint would be the workers & their gloves. The last 3 times I've had to tell them to not touch my food with the gloves they just scratched their face with, touched cash or scratched their head. Workers are nice enough but it gets weird when you tell them to not touch your food.”