29 Best Pizza Restaurants in Barrie

“Wow! What a pizza! Stopped here on the way back from a ski trip to grab a quick bite. We ordered the ‘Hand me a towel’ and it was definitely spicy as advertised. This is some of the best pizza I’ve had in Ontario. The quality of ingredients are evident in the taste from the crust to the sauce. Will definitely be back whenever I’m in the area again.“

“Great place!! Ordered a panzerotti and a pizza, the best I’ve ever had. They were both fresh, cooked to perfection and you really get the best value for your money. This place does not cheap out like other companies. The staff are always friendly and welcoming. I can’t say enough good things about this place, highly recommended if you’re looking for a great pizza/panzerotti!“

“Chelyn was our waitress and she was absolutely wonderful. Right from the beginning she made my boyfriend and I feel very welcomed. She was very attentive to all of her tables including ours. Every time she came to our table, she had a big smile on her face. She consistently checked in on us to make sure everything was tasting good and we had everything we needed. The food was wonderful as well but we had a wonderful experience with our waitress and I wanted to make sure she was aware of it.“

“Hands down the best pizzahut franchisee in Barrie. I have tried almost every single one, even all the way in Angus and this location hands downs has the cooks the best pizza. They're always consistent with the overall quality of food and they are extremely friendly.“

“The taste of this pizza is absolutely mouthwatering! The cheese, sauce, and crust was made to perfection. Words can’t describe how delicious this pizza was!!! It’s also on the way to Wasaga Beach, so great to take out and enjoy with your family and friends!“

“Super impressed with this pizza place. Tried it for the first time while I was in Barrie last week, pizza was delivered to the hotel fast and hot. Lots of toppings, good quality ingredients and good value. 2 extra large with 4 toppings on each with 2 dipping sauces were around 40 bucks with tax and delivery. Definitely give them a try!“

“My wife and I ordered from Sicilian Gourmet Pizza & Pasta last weekend for the first time , and we were blown away by how tasty everything was. The selection of food was amazing, the prices were very good, and our order was prepared very quickly. We will definitely be ordering from Sicilian Gourmet Pizza & Pasta again! Thank you Papa Rez and your entire team! - Tatyana and Keith“

“Ordered from Cocelli Pizza a week or so ago after heavy recommendation and really enjoyed the food. You can tell they use high-quality ingredients in their cooking and have a unique taste compared to fast-food/chain pizza places. Looking forward to my next “

“Quickly becoming one of our favorite restaurants. Food is fantastic. Burgers (home-made) delicious. Mac and Cheese, ohhh yeahhh. Club, amazing. Poutine, to die for. Shaved beef sandwich au jus... *sigh*. The staff, great! I suggest making a reservation, especially on Friday and Saturday evenings. We love this place!“

“I have been going to Dino's pizza for 12 years now because it is by far and away the best spot in Barrie for a slice. Never had a bad experience and the Owner, Tony, is always a friendly face to see. The man has mastered his Craft over the 34 years he has been working there and it shows in every pizza. I recommend his pizza over any other in Barrie. It's just better than the restKid-friendliness: The owner is friendly to allWheelchair accessibility: Plenty of ramp access“

“Okay so i order from dominos once a week and my pizzas are incomplete without garlic cheese sticks. It is so so yumm.Vegetarian options: So, there are certain days that i don’t consume meat. So, i order a pizza with veggies, and kid you not the pizzas are fully loaded with veggie. They are awesome and taste so fresh.“

“Market priced for Barrie. Excellent thin crust pizza, arrived hot out of oven.One surprise? Asked for some Parmesan cheese, didn't notice until Bill arrived, was charged $3 for a tiny tub! Other places, say pizza hut, waitress comes over and asks if you want some on your 'za for free.“

“Really like going here. The atmosphere, service and food are great, and of course the beer. Food is a bit pricey as is everywhere .The one thing I questioned was the cost of the brisket tacos which were a little underfilled if you ask me. $19 dollars for 3 tacos, but you can buy extras for $4 each. The math doesn't make sense.Liked the beer but the Leather Brown Ale which was a guest tap from Redline tasted like they just threw a pile of cocoa into a dark beer.“

“Service was pretty good! Friendly and straight to the point. I ordered my food and the online email said it would take 13 minutes, but since I live close I got there very early,And the pizza was finished within like 10 minutes topsVery quick servicePlus it tastes amazingDefinitely go here for a good deal and a decent slice of pizza :)“

“What a great experience tonight! We had an earlier appointment downtown, so, an additional trip would have been required to pick up our pizza. Instead, we ordered and and asked for the pizza to not be fully cooked and OH MY... Once we reheated (on a pizza stone), it tasted exactly like the original! Will DEFINITELY do that again! Highly recommend! Thanks again, Pizzeria Italia Restaurant!“

“This has been one of the most awsome experiences regarding custumer service from a food local store in Barrie, I am totally Flabbergasted concerning the positive way to solve from Tim Coburn general manager in Bell Farm Ave. Papa John's in Barrie. Amazing service , and thanks to him now I can give 10 stars, not only in custumer service, also, in Pizza flavor, taste and quality .What a incredible experience, stand up ovation to this great place, now this pizzas are our favorites, try the garlic crusty dough with Italian sausage, Philly steak, bacon and don't forget the jalapeños, or just try any from the Menu. Yummyyyyy.“

“This pizza was the best I have had in barrie by far good price i paid like $16 for large 3 toppings i would kiss the chefs hands....I love this new joint my go to for pizza also the service is amazing and staff is super friendly. I will next time try their burger with bacon ? ?“

“Tried Pizzaville for the first time and wasn't disappointed. Our pizza was made fresh and stone baked. We got a medium pepperoni with spinach and Italian sausage too. All ingredients tasted fresh. Service was great. I recommend trying Pizzaville if you haven't already. Pizza came quick.“

“Love this place. Great pizza, decent pricing. Not gonna lie, I love the pepperoni placement!Had a slight issue one time where onions were put under cheese, so they still were a bit too crunchy, but it was still decent. I just chalked it up to assume they were training someone new. Regardless, I have ordered pizza from here a couple dozen times, and that was the only hiccup. Keep up the good work, staff!“

“Love Boston Pizza however, At lunch on a Saturday April 22 sat down 3 other tables got served not us The place was on the empty side for time off day. This Boston Pizza used to be so busy and great service so disappointed We walked out leaving menus on table, went elsewhere That place was always packed and had excellent service Boston Pizza South better shape up or they’ll be closed soon and not necessary at all.“

“I have visited the place multiple times now. The pizza is amazing in taste, smells enticing and looks are 10 on 10. I have tried almost all the pizzas they have and never had any complaints.Vegetarian options: There are a couple of vegetarian options that you can choose from. Personally, I like the Indian Style Pizza.“

“Absolutely love hitting up Papa Joe's whenever I'm around the city. Honestly, their pizza is just on another level - so much flavor packed in that you won't even think about grabbing a dip or a soda. You can tell they really care about what they're doing too; the toppings are chopped up perfectly and spread out just right. You've gotta give it a shot if you haven't yet!“

“This place, ESPECIALLY, have their pizza the same taste and shape for the past 3 years... we tried other places but everytime they do it differently...BUT this place makes the BEST THIN CRUST PIZZA with light sauce.. please stay the same and don't change.. the whole family and the whole nieces and nephews LOVE YOUR pizza..“

“Francesca was a great and attentive server. Food was delicious as always, which keeps me coming back each time.Came back second time and Prachi was super attentive, checked in with us several times, which was awesome ! and dinner was great! Loved the food! Happy to come back again!“

“Barrie, your doing it right. Your server was friendly and helpful, your pizza was cooked perfectly and your walk in purchasing was hot and ready with no wait. Loved that the price was also right. We need the likes of you and your staff in the big city. It shows that you “

“It’s been 5 years i am eating from pizza pizza, recently moved to barrie tried this location and m soo satisfied with their pizza taste tried that tandoori pizza, and cook suggested me the toppings and he actually know how pizza gonna taste and it was best.“

“Recieved a gift card from a coworker. Went in on a Friday and as I walked in I could smell the fresh tomato sauce and basil. I chose to get a panzerotti and meatball sandwich. The meatball sandwich was delicious and oozing sauce. Mozzarella was gooey and fresh. 8.1/10. Panzo was a bit underwhelming. Toppings inside were a bit light and pepperoni, as it wasn't baked and crispy was more like baloney flavored. The star of the show is their marinara sauce which I believe you can purchase. Overall a great experience.“

“Tbh the prices are bit high to the other stores but the quality is really great. So I'll still buy from here. The offers they have are the best, last week I bought a large pizza(around $25-$30) then the staffs who took my order suggested to buy one more large pizza for just a $1 !!!!!. This was amazing.Good staffs who help you giving a good price, and pizza was fresh and delicious . I definitely recommend to everyone. I'll be coming back for sure.“

“Just tried ordering a party size pizza for the first time because it was kind of cheap and didn't expect the quality to be that great but it turned out to be one of the best pizzas that I have ever had in my life super amazing pizzas you should give it a try.“