Ye Ole Sweet Shoppe

402 State St, Erie
(814) 456-8755

Recent Reviews

Missy Smith

I ordered a two tier cake I get a one tier cake they don't know how to do their cakes and $40 is not worth the price for a small cake don't recommend them at all I will never go back to them ever again

Andrea Pijanowski

I truly cannot thank you enough for delivering those cookies to my son for his first day of class today! You have EXCEPTIONAL SERVICE! My son was so surprised & I am forever grateful to your bakery for helping me keep my tradition going & not missing a year! Brandon said your cookies are delicious and it was so awesome to hear about his first day back on campus! Many many thanks over to you& your bakery!

Ben Gallo

Nice people, good coffee, unbelievable bakery! Love their muffins and cake pops!!

Heather Vroman

Cookies were excellent, love how the tray turned out!

Khira Blackmond

I paid almost 40 dollars for 32 cookies, they were my babygirls babyshower. They were supposed to make a total of 6 different shapes and only did 3 with the same pattern on them. couldn't even get new cookies.

Spencer T.

Amazing selection - stopped in here when walking from the Lake to the Seawolves game. Delicious cookies, very friendly staff, and if we lived closer we would be here before most games! Couldn't recommend this place more, the Maple Walnut cookie was incredible!


If you are looking for the best, authentic pepperoni balls, then this is the place to get them. I think they have them only on Fridays, but they are simply heavenly and I could eat them all day if I could. Their prices are super reasonable as well and their staff is super friendly. They also have an amazing cookie selection as well as a couple other desserts, so it's a great place to stop when walking downtown or if you're in need of something sweet. But you definitely don't want to miss out on the pepperoni balls! Also! Because I just discovered this, there is a parking lot right behind the bakery so you don't have to park at a parking meter for a couple of minutes!


We were excited to find a bakery during our stay in Erie. Ye Ole Sweet Shoppe is lovely and convenient to get too. My only complaint was that the selection was very limited even though we were there mid-morning. Lots of cookies, some individual pieces of cake, and lady locks. We purchased cookies and a lady lock which were all very average. Staff was very friendly.

Maria Sahlani

Absolutely Amazing! If I lived in Erie or went to Ganon I would probably pick up a cookie everyday. These cookies are extremely delicious and have a thick, rich flavor. The staff is super friendly and even gave us some samples to try before we bought anything. Thank you so much! I would definitely add this to the list of places to try in Erie.

robert wheaton

Best No Bakes around

Chris Barwin

Absolutely perfect. Great staff great prices very clean and the baked good were delicious

Rod Showers

Cookies are delicious, staff was friendly and professional.

Wendy Velazquez

They have the best Peanut butter cookies

Faith Kindig

Love this place. The staff is always friendly and their Danishes are AMAZING!


An Erie staple! Delicious cookies and friendly customer service.

Load More