21 Best Italian Restaurants in Lancaster

1
LUCA

LUCA Italian • $$
436 W James St #101, Lancaster

Customers` Favorites

Salted Butterscotch Budino
Tagliatelle Bolognese
Burrata Appetizer
Margherita Pizza
Ricotta Fritters
Pepperoni Pizza
Beef Carpaccio
Piccante Pizza
Small Plates
Funghi Pizza

“Overall food was very good. Service was also good. Our seat felt crammed against a divider near the wait station so it wasn't as nice as some other places to sit. But this place is very hip and we would definitely go back!!EDIT: Food still good after several years. Only complaint is still certain seating areas are better than others. Definitely talk to hostess if you are not happy with the table you are given. Honestly sitting at the bar was a good experience if you don't like your table.Parking: Weekends it is fine to find parking. Weekdays, if you don't find a spot in their lot, you are going to park a few blocks away.“

4.5 Superb102 Reviews
Pasquale's Pizza • $
1657 Old Philadelphia Pike, Lancaster

Customers` Favorites

Homemade Garlic Knots
Trosed Salad & Soup
Chicken Parmigiana
Eggplant Parmesan
Mozzarella Sticks
Chicken Parmesan
Sauce for Dipping
Homemade Lasagna
Lobster Ravioli
Stuffed Shells

“The staff was very friendly and kind. The little cut in booths make for a private, quiet, date night! Frank, the owner, goes above and beyond. Excellent food, excellent prices! A great example of how to run and business and keep family first! Thanks Frank, we will return on our date nights or for family take and bake dinners!“

4.6 Superb120 Reviews
Caruso's Italian Restaurant & Pizza Shop Pizza • $$
3545 Marietta Ave, Lancaster

Customers` Favorites

Half Buffalo Chicken Half Meat Lovers
Spinach Broccoli and Garlic Calzone
Mushroom Cheesesteak
Meat Lover's Calzone
Breaded Cauliflower
Chicken Cheesesteak
Special Cheesesteak
Three Cheese Pizza
Breaded Mushrooms
Special Stromboli

“Stopped in quick the other day for lunch visiting for the first time and was pleasantly surprised with how great the pizza was... And the price for 2 slices and a soda would be hard to beat any where else I'm thinking. Service was great and place was very nice inside and was clean. I'll definitely be back for more of that great pizza and I hear the Stromboli is a must as well so I'll be trying that too :)“

4.6 Superb72 Reviews
Brooklyn Pizza - Grill Pizza • $
1750 Oregon Pike, Lancaster

Customers` Favorites

Pepperoni Sausage and Peppers Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
Chicken Wings
Garlic Knots
Garlic Bread
Veggie Pizza
Cheese Fries
Plain Pizza
Pizzas
Wrap

“LANCASTER...NEW. PIZZA. REVIEWER...OLDE..SCHOOL. 3rd..GENERATION..N.Y..PIEMAN.... 40. PLUS. YEARS. TOP. SHELF. & THEN SOME. FINIST. INGREDIENTS. $$$ .CAN. BUY. OUTSTANDING..SELECTION. SPOTLESS.. AUTHENTIC...SCORE. 9.3..WOW...“

4.5 Superb79 Reviews
Picasso Pizza Pizza • $$
1704 New Holland Pike, Lancaster

Customers` Favorites

Pickle Bacon Ranch Pizza
Chicken Salad Wrap
Medium Stromboli
Cheese Pizza
French Fries
Garlic Knots
Cheese Steak

“A friend recommended this place saying the pizza was really good. I stopped, looked at their menu and decided to order the chicken francese. That meal was superb! I made 3 meals out of it because I wanted it to last. I would highly recommend trying it and also trying the restaurant itself. I actually stopped by to tell them how much I loved it. I will definitely be ordering from them again!“

4.5 Superb56 Reviews
Two Cousins Pizza downtown Pizza • $
155 E King St, Lancaster

Customers` Favorites

Cheese Steak

“I have never really been "wowed" by pizza but Two Cousins downtown has changed that for me. The staff is very kind and is there to make sure you get excellent product every time. The pizza is perfectly crispy on the bottom, and nice and chewy on top. Combined with the perfect amount of sauce and cheese, call me hooked. I couldn't help but take a couple bites before I got a picture!“

4.7 Superb23 Reviews
Carrabba's Italian Grill Italian • $$
100 N Pointe Blvd, Lancaster

Customers` Favorites

Four-Cheese & Sausage Stuffed Mushrooms
Mama Mandola's Sicilian Chicken Soup
Tomato Caprese with Fresh Burrata
Spaghetti and Meatballs
Mozzarella Marinara
Traditional Cannoli
Chicken Fettuccine
Fettuccine Alfredo
Linguine Positano
Sausage Meatballs

“Last night, Valentine’s Day, my wife and I chose to meet our son and family at Carrabba’s to celebrate my special birthday ?.As expected, we were not disappointed with our meals or service. Courtney was our server, a very pleasant and efficient server at that! She truly made my family and I feel like she was serving her own family. I was not only impressed with her pleasant demeanor and performance, but she displayed what I would rarely call, a respectful heartfelt service attitude!I explained to Courtney that as a retired Human Resource Director of a fine dining restaurant, that if she left Carrabba’s seeking another fine dining experience at my former restaurant, I would not hesitate to hire her.Congratulations to Carrabba’s HR Professionals for hiring their professional and pleasant staff!“

4.3 Superb98 Reviews
Nino's New York Style Pizza Pizza • $
361 Comet Dr, Lancaster

Customers` Favorites

Buffalo Chicken Cheesesteak
Stuffed Spaghetti Pizza
Cheese Pizza Slice
Loaded Fry Pizza
Sicillian Pizza
Garlic Knots
Cheese Pie
Meatballs

“I purchased pizzas from here years apart, since I don't live nearby, but both times the pies were tasty and at least not mediocre, like most pizza in PA (I like many things in this state, but pizza is not something we're known for). I don't normally eat veggie pizzas, but their Veggie Lover is really good. Their hot wings were also excellent.“

4.4 Superb47 Reviews
Ruffino's Pizza & Pasta Pizza • $
572 Centerville Rd, Lancaster

Customers` Favorites

Pizza Burger Hot Sub
Cheese Pizza
Cheesesteak
Italian Sub
Lasagna
Sauce
Fries

“Hey, y'all remember that super cheesy pizza Max and PJ had in "The Goofy Movie"? If you order a White Pizza with extra cheese and ricotta, you'll get that cartoonishly delightful deliciousness Max and PJ enjoyed. I know my fellow millennials have been searching for it they whole lives.“

4.4 Superb45 Reviews
Pie In the Sky Italian • $$
Ground Floor, 105 Duncan St C, Lancaster

Customers` Favorites

Mozzarella Sticks with Sauce
Pizza de Bacon Y Peperoni
Boneless Chicken Wings
Cheesesteak Sandwich
Special Stromboli
Cheeseburger Sub
Pepperoni Pizza
Buffalo Chicken
Steak Stromboli
Sicilian Pizza

“Order here for the very first time traveling around lancaster and was lucky to come upon this great Italian restaurant! We ordered pizza and a calzon it was amazing, so delicious it's a good distance away but so worth it❣️❣️Best Pizza I have had here in PA and I have been here since 1972❣️ Looking forward to trying many more delicious foods they prepare! Hoping they make a true antipasta salad have not had a good one since leaving New York other then making my own?❤️❣️Vegetarian options: Had Vegetable Pizza was Superb❣️“

4.4 Superb44 Reviews
Salt & Pepper Italian Bistro Pizza Italian • $
486 Royer Dr #102, Lancaster

Customers` Favorites

Margherita Personal Pizza
California Cheesesteak
Broccoli Mushroom
Vegetarian Pizza
Italian Sub

“This place is a gem. I am a pizza lover. And, I like my pizza HOT. Like burn your mouth hot. The quality of the pies they put out is amazing. Totally consistent. Hot and with very high quality ingredients. Even the cheese is different. The staff is always friendly and orders are put up fast. Anytime I am in the area (I don’t live near) I grab a pie to go. Their white pie with spinach is very good.“

4.3 Superb48 Reviews
Lombardo's Restaurant Italian • $$
216 Harrisburg Ave, Lancaster

Customers` Favorites

Spinach & Cheese Ravioli
Bread Served to Everyone
Classic Chocolate Cake
Bolognese Pappardelle
Wild Mushroom Gemelli
New York Cheesecake
Chicken Parmesan
Veal Parmigiana
Calamari Fritto
Veal Parmesan

“Overall a good experience and would definitely recommendService- everyone was friendly. Our waitres was very nice, helpful and attentiveFood- I had the chicken parm and my wife had the salmon. Both were deliciousAtmosphere- very nice fine dining atmosphere“

4 Good92 Reviews
Venice Pizza and Pasta Pizza • $
3079 Columbia Ave, Lancaster

Customers` Favorites

Meatlovers Pizza and Italian Stromboli
Brooklyn Style Pizza
Deep Dish Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
Chicken Wings
Garlic Knots
Cheese Steak
Cheeseburger
Salad

“The staff was super friendly and the food was amazing for the price. Got a ton of food for the price. It came recommended from a friend and decided to stop to kill some time while in the area. Will definitely stop again when in the area. We had the Cheesesteak Stromboli and my son had the chicken Alfredo. Both were “

4.2 Good61 Reviews
Valentino's Cafe Italian • $
132 Rider Ave, Lancaster

Customers` Favorites

Spaghetti and Meatballs Prices
Spaghetti with Meat Sauce
Garlic Bread
Pretzels

“Small bar that's usually filled with an older crowd. But one of the few places with outside seating which is usually filled with younger people. Drink prices a bit above average. They also have food & a restaurant during certain hours. The main draw is the patio seating.Parking: Huge lot.“

4.3 Superb26 Reviews
Two Cousin's Pizza Bridgeport Italian • $$
1633 Lincoln Hwy E, Lancaster

Customers` Favorites

1 2 Cheesesteak Sandwich
Buffalo Chicken
Chicken Wings -
Cheese Steak
French Fries
Cheeseburger
Onion Rings
Italian
Alfredo
Salad

“1st time here. Ordered a pizza. Sraff was very friendly & accommodating. The pizza was fabulous. Fresh tasting & flavorful. I think what got me most it was worth the price (now days, I feel like everything is over priced & the quality/quantity & ingredients is compromised). Not here. I will definitely order again. Well done!!“

4.2 Good43 Reviews
Elimar's Bar & Grill Italian •
2309 Columbia Ave, Lancaster

Customers` Favorites

Mushroom Ravioli
Lump Crab Cakes
Chicken Marsala
Coconut Shrimp
New York 12 Oz
French Fries
Side of Pasta
Baked Potato
Tuna Steak
Alfredo

“I meet my daughters once a month for lunch. First time we were ever at Elimar. Atmosphere was cozy. Menu had a great variety to choose from. Food was excellent and plentiful (all of us needed boxes). Service was quick, and our server, Shamika, was outstanding. We all agreed we would return!“

4.1 Good116 Reviews
Ciro's Italian Bistro Italian • $$
605 Richmond Dr, Lancaster

Customers` Favorites

Steak Tips in Gorgonzola Sauce with Penne Pasta
Rustic Bread with Olive Oil
Sausage and Pepper Rustica
Spaghetti Bolognese
Peanut Butter Gelato
Chicken Saltimbocca
Fettuccine Alfredo
Fried Mozzarella
Chicken Parmesan
Margherita Pizza

“Absolutely fantastic Italian Restaurant - out of the way and severely underrated! We've dined here 1/2 dozen times and each time it gets better. First, the staff - Tony(owner), Louise, Abby, Giovanni, and so many others are friendly and courteous. There's clearly an excellent team in place here. On to the food - ridiculously good. Nothing is average or "OK" here, its all delicious. My favorite is the Seafood Fra Diavolo, Chicken Picatta and Pollo Basilica. The cocktails are excellent as well - If you don't leave room for the amazing gelato bar, then take some home with you. I cannot reccomend Ciro's enough.“

4.1 Good105 Reviews
Caruso's Pizzeria Pizza • $
1908 Fruitville Pike, Lancaster

Customers` Favorites

Any 2 Large Pizzas
Cheeseburger Sub
French Fries
Garlic Knots
Chicken Parm
Cheesesteak
House Salad

“Just happened to be in area and stopped in. What a positive experience. The pizza we had was the best we had in a long time. The employees were super nice, prices were fair, and the place itself was cute. Wish we lived closer to try other things on their menus. If we are ever in the area again we will definitely stop in.“

4.1 Good47 Reviews
Olive Garden Italian Restaurant Italian • $$
35 S Willowdale Dr Suite 1001, Lancaster

Customers` Favorites

Black Tie Mousse Cake Chocolate Cake Dark Chocolate Cheesecake and Creamy Custard with Icing
Chicken & Gnocchi a Creamy Soup Made with Roasted Chicken Italian Dumplings and Spinach
Chicken Parmigiana a Classic with Our Homemade Marinara and a Side of Spaghetti
Chicken Parmigiana with Spaghetti
Fried Seafood Platter
Crispy Chicken Fritta
Stuffed Mushrooms
Seafood Alfredo
Pasta E Fagioli
Shrimp Alfredo

“The waitress didn't really seem to like her job but, then most of us don't. Food was incredible as always. Prices were great to how much food you are given. Great time with friends!Parking: Plenty of space to choose from. Easy.“

4 Good84 Reviews
Rendezvous Pizzeria & Steak Shop Pizza • $
243 W King St, Lancaster

Customers` Favorites

Spicy Pepperoni
6 Cheese Steak
The Roni
Marinara
4 Cheese

“I've given the cheese steaks 2 chances since the opening, and I wasn't impressed with it. I will say that the pizza is very, very good and the customer service is VERY GOOD. I grew up right across the street as a child, and they are not what I remember. The cheese steaks had an overpowering peper taste to it.“

4 Good56 Reviews

21
Sbarro

Sbarro Pizza •
257 Centerville Rd, Lancaster

Customers` Favorites

NY Sausage Slice
Meat Primo

“I had a amazing experience. The gentleman working on Mothers day 5/14/23 was a all around a all star. He could not find his tongs but he managed to deliver my food without touching it. He went above and beyond. He washed his hands twice before delivering my food. Thank you for everything you did. Keep up the good work. I wish I could spell his name. I hope you tell him what a wonderful job he did.“

3.9 Good16 Reviews
Loading...
map Map