“A TRUE New Castle treasure!!! Everything I have ever had has never disappointed. Any sandwich is always spot on. Appetizers are awesome. Pizza has plenty of the sweeter sauce that is amazing if that’s your liking. Happy no one knows the secret to it and tried to duplicate it because they would mess it up!! Nice dense dough that is always cooked perfectly with a great chew and crisp crust!! Toppings and cheese are fresh and delicious perfectly proportionate to every slice!!! Love taking home a large order on a weekend when I don’t feel like cooking and grazing on it all for a couple days!!!! I would love to see them come out with a lamb pizza with a garlic and pepper sauce with feta cheese….. Just a suggestion???? If you ever questioned eating in or ordering from here…. Don’t second guess your decision and do it!!!!!“
“We ordered delivery, and the food got here early and pipping hot. It was so good, i had to call just to tell them my self. We got a traditional cheese pizza, a pepperoni pizza, a buffalo chicken pizza, and junies. Oh we love the junies!! Like biting into Grandma's apple pie. But in eggroll form. Delicious all the way around!!“
“Highly recommend! Come here often and always great service. Amazing food and hospitality. Amy was our waitress she is in training wouldn't have known till we were informed towards the end. She was waiting on our table like she's been there forever. Great waitress. If you can request her do it, won't be disappointed. Defiently can't wait to come back again and hopefully get Amy.“
“This is an amazing place to eat with fair prices and every meal I have personally eaten here has been great !The waitresses and everyone from staff were extremely professional and fast.They always seem to have a smile and a hello when you walk in I would absolutely recommend this place !“
“Sunday breastfast on our way home from a family wedding. Light, bright & pleasant atmosphere. Great coffe, hot & it keep coming. I got the cheddar potatoes eggs & it was perfect. Everyone seemed happy with their pancakes, omelets & crispy home fries, as requested.“
“Experienced the bar.. twice..last year in April for my birthday..what a tequila time I had with two friends...then I went back on a Friday evening...very pleasant time...at the bar..eats and drinks....!!funnn...service great....will be back...“
“Food was delicious! Atmosphere was very empty and dated. Only $60 for three people with multiple plates of food! Amazingly huge and delicious portions! Waitress name was Taylor! Excellent as well! Definitely recommendVegetarian options: PastasWheelchair accessibility: Large space“
“I love Mr. Pizza. It's one of the best small businesses in our little town. They have sub sandwiches that I don't think get enough recognition. Of course we all know how great their pizza is but Idk how many of our residents know how good the subs are. The staff I've always had a good experience with. Both over the phone and in person. Always friendly, always knows any answers to any questions about the food, always willing to go an extra mile no matter how busy they are. My family has ate here for generations and will continue to eat here for many more generations to come.“
“The pasta is good. The sauce is great. I like the option to purchase the sauce and pasta and prepare during the week for a quick easy dinner. They are busy when they're opened so don't expect immediate service but the service is great considering.“