18 Best Italian Restaurants in York

Victor's Italian Restaurant Italian • $$$
554 S Ogontz St, York

Customers` Favorites

Spaghetti and Meatballs
Italian Wedding Soup
Chicken Parmigiana
Sauteed Mushrooms
Short Rib Risotto
Charcuterie Plate
Blackened Salmon
Crispy Calamari
Shrimp Linguini
Toasted Ravioli

“Where do I begin... lord have mercy this place was AMAZING!!!!!! GILLIAN our waitress was AMAZING!!! the food was AMAZING!!!! It was just such an incredible experience. I've been to some "fancy" restaurants and this hidden gem blew our minds. I recommend this restaurant 100000%.“

4.5 Superb203 Reviews
Pizza Al Bacio Pizza • $
555 Ryan Run Rd, York

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Parmigiana
Four Cheese Pizza
Cheeseburger Sub
Pepperoni Pizza
Original Pizza
Slice of Pizza
Sicilian Pizza
Garlic Knots
Italian Sub
French Fries

“Our family loves Pizza al Bacio! My son's favorite salad is their grilled chicken salad. And their bread is the best we've had. My family usually also gets the mozzarella sticks, fried mushrooms, pizza, and stromboli. We always do take out because we prefer to eat at home, but the shop owners and workers are friendly, and our food is hot and ready quickly. We highly recommend Pizza al Bacio for casual Italian food!“

4.6 Superb60 Reviews
Jim & Nena's Pizzeria Italian • $$$
2755 W Market St #2, York

Customers` Favorites

Cheesesteak Without Onion Stromboli
Italian Cold Cut Sub
Round Steak Sandwich
Cheeseburger Deluxe
Breaded Cauliflower
Farmerboy Sandwich
Mozzarella Sticks
Italian Stromboli
Regular Stromboli
Chopped Steak Sub

“I live in Maryland and was visiting a friend in the area. Wanted pizza, found this place on google and it was close, so we decided to try it. We ended up getting strombolis. The staff was amazing, and the food was outstanding! Very reasonably priced and giant portions! We already decided to come back next time I visit and we're trying the pizza lol. We ate inside and the staff was very nice and personable. Highly recommend!Parking: Plenty of parking“

4.8 Superb29 Reviews
Vincenzo's Place Pizza • $
2509 S George St, York

Customers` Favorites

Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Cheese Pizza Slice
Cheeseburger Sub
Chicken Alfredo
Pepperoni Pizza
Cheesesteak
White Pizza

“Vegetarian options: They were so kind. Had an issue with the app I ordered on and they were more then helpful explaining things. The food was so fresh everything was amazing!This was our first time but absolutely will be back. Way better than jojos lol“

4.3 Superb49 Reviews
Mexitaly Brick oven Brewhouse Brewery • $$
2440 E Market St, York

“Open spaces. Table seating. Private booths. I was a little shocked by the size of the room tbh.Absolutely authentic cuisine. My order was a to-go burrito w/guac no sour cream. Great hospitality, compassion, leadership-suited deck come meet the aces!I offer up Juarez, MX (founding of the burrito) better have a check-in because this cuisine’s got something that might have a person reconsider their definition of burrito. Go strong! Stay long! I know their bar serves nicely so bring your friends! Muchas gracias! Gratzie!:) Salud.“

4.2 Good71 Reviews
Olive Garden Italian Restaurant Italian • $
1340 Kenneth Rd, York

Customers` Favorites

Spaghetti Topped with Your Choice of Homemade Marinara or Meat Sauce Prepared Fresh Daily
Chicken Parmigiana a Classic with Our Homemade Marinara and a Side of Spaghetti
Shrimp Alfredo Fettuccine Alfredo Tossed with Sautéed Shrimp
Sweet Red Roscato Rosso Dolce Italy
Chicken Parmigiana with Spaghetti
Crocketas Empanadas Con Queso
Chicken & Shrimp Carbonara
Five Cheese Ziti Al Forno
Jumbo Famous House Salad
Calamari with Marinara

“Came in as a walk in for a large group and they were more than willing to do what they could to seat us in a reasonable amount of time. Gladly, our group shrank significantly, and they still did all they could to make our late dinner very pleasant.“

4.1 Good108 Reviews
Tapenade Bistro Bistros • $
2509 S Queen St, York

Customers` Favorites

Bourbon Soaked Cherries over Pork Chops
Florentine Omelette
Steamed Broccoli
Caprese Stack
Featured Soup
Cordon Bleu
Tomato Soup

“Always love this restaurant, excellent homemade, quality food. Great service every time. It's so nice to go to a restaurant that is not a chain and have excellent food consistently. I love that they have freezer food you may purchase for food prep in a pinch .“

4.6 Superb20 Reviews
Brother's Pizza Pizza • $
1000 Hanover Rd, York

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Cheese Steak Hoagie with Cheese Lettuce Tomatoes Mayo Onions
Spaghetti with Meat Sauce
By the Slice Cheese Pizza
Sicilian Special Pizza
Bacon Cheeseburger
Mozzarella Sticks
Cheese Steak Sub
Chicken Fingers
Stuffed Pizza
Wings

“We went through the Drive thru and ordered a pizza. Delicious ? the wait wasn't bad either!Parking: Close quarters, but at least it's not street parking or paid. Just be cautious backing out and watch for other people's doors.Kid-friendliness: Not a pizza + barWheelchair accessibility: Flat surfaces to enter and exit. I believe the door is wide enough for a wheelchair or walker.“

4.2 Good26 Reviews
Marino's Pizza & Pasta House Italian • $
3595 E Market St, York

Customers` Favorites

Angel Hair Pasta w Meat Sauce N a Side of Meatballs
Veal Parmigiana with Spaghetti
Large Sicilian Thick Crust 16
Marino's House Side Salad
Garlic Bread Parmigiana
Tortellini Alla Panna
Italian Wedding Soup
Classic Caesar Salad
Spaghetti Carbonara
Chicken Cacciatore

“Food was good. Service fine. But when you go to pay and your paying with cash they always charge you higher at the register than what the cash price says on your receipt. It's only by a cent or two but still..... It makes the customer feel like they are being ripped off. The receipt the waitress gives you and the cash register should BOTH say the same amount.“

4 Good67 Reviews
Infinito's Pizza Buffet Pizza • $
2144 S Queen St, York

Customers` Favorites

Pepperoni Pizza and Salad Buffet
Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza
Cinnamon Rolls 16
BBQ Chicken Pizza
Broccoli Alfredo
Bacon Cheese Fry
Buffalo Chicken
Dessert Pizza
Apple Pizza
Cheese Pizza

“Yum! Visiting town for business and had to try this. Very good. Quality of food is excellent! Variety of pizza hot and fresh. They’ll make one if they don’t already have the variety. Bread sticks are delicious, everything was! Customer Service was top notch, all employees friendly and smiling. Troy was very friendly and informative when I checked in for a table. Price was a value. Would visit again when in the area. Give it a try you’ll be glad you did!Kid-friendliness: There were many kids here. Very kid friendly.Wheelchair accessibility: Open spaces between tables.“

4 Good49 Reviews
Genova's Italian Restaurant & Brewery Italian • $
2530 W Market St, York

Customers` Favorites

Shrimp Alfredo
Large Pizza
Baked Ziti
Marinara
Italian
Fries
Wings
Sub

“Shame that we were only here on a visit. This place would be a regular stop for sure. Very comfy ambiance. The wait staff was very friendly. The food was out of this world. Plenty to take home and not at all pricey.Dietary restrictions: Most veggie options can be made vegan.“

3.9 Good45 Reviews
Marcello's Pizza Pizza • $$
7 S George St #1406, York

Customers` Favorites

Marcello's Favorite Steak Sub
Marcello's Special Pizza
Chopped Steak & Fries
Chicken Fajita Pizza
Buffalo Chicken Wrap
Shrimp Avocado Salad
Kid's Cheeseburger
Cheese Quesadilla
Mozzarella Sticks
Ham & Cheese Sub

“To start, they were very polite on the phone, and made sure to repeat the order back to ensure it was correct.I was greeted with smiles and a very positive attitude as soon as I walked in, which not many places seem to do anymore. Both ladies working there made it an awesome experience.I ordered a large pepperoni, a California cheese steak and a order of fries. Everything was very well made, exactly how I wanted it. The pizza had great flavor and they weren't stingy with the pepperoni. The fries were crispy and plentiful. My sub was above average but not the best I've ever had, the lettuce tasted a little old and it could have used some more meat, but nonetheless it was good.I would recommend Marcello's over any other pizza shop in York.“

3.9 Good38 Reviews
Presto Fast Italian- South York Italian • $
2058 S Queen St, York

“Presto South York, my new favorite Presto. Matthew and the zoodles are the reason I keep coming back. He knows customer service, always polite and engaging. Love the recommendations, so far every suggestion has enhanced the meal. The zoodles and sun dried tomatoes are a must. Go try them out, they are open, you won't be disappointed!“

4 Good13 Reviews
Tutoni's Restaurant Italian • $$$
108 N George St, York

Customers` Favorites

Spaghetti with Meatballs
Bread and Dipping Sauce
Seared Duck Breast
Gnocchi Bolognese
Grilled Octopus
Fried Calamari
Potato Gnocchi
Tiramisu
Burrata

“Went on 3/1/24:The food, timing, and ambiance was all perfect. Orders of apps, sides, and entrees all came out and were timed to be ready a little minutes after we finished one. We got the pork belly to start, which at first I was taken back by the only three small pieces of it, but it was absolutely delicious and worth it. Then we had the charcuterie board, which they let us choose everything that came on it, and when gouda cheese was moldy due to being aged (it was not clear in its name), they took the board back, gave us a new cheese, and a side of chorizo to make up for the mistake. All delicious, especially the side of pear jam.For entrees, my girlfriend got the duck confit/foie gras raviolis, which they adjusted for her mold allergy (normally it has gorgonzola in there somewhere), and her dish was phenomenal, she ate it all and loved every bite. I had the pork shank, which came with TWO pork shanks, over a celery root puree that was fantastic, and the pork was so incredibly tender with every bite. The only thing I may change would be a side of some kind of sauce for it, but that is only because I love sauces with things, especially pork, but it does not take away from the dish.For dessert, they actually gave us two small mini desserts since we were celebrating our anniversary, which was really nice and unexpected. They were the perfect mini size for something sweet after dinner, but not too much. My girlfriend got the cannoli mini dessert, and I got the panna cotta with chocolate on top, both great.Service wise, we had Trey, and we could not of gotten anyone better. He was incredibly available, sweet, caring, on point with attending and helping us, and was so easy going with a nice sense of humor that it just made the night even more perfect. You would never of known it was his first night working there! He carried and acted as if he had been there for years.Overall, the dinner was fantastic, service and food wise. We felt heard and cared about, never pushed in any direction or rushed at all, and would recommend the place to anyone. They also have an upstairs bar and tapas area that seems to be open later than the downstairs dinner area if you are looking for something after dinner, or in general.Dietary restrictions: My girlfriend has a mold allergy, and they were perfect with accommodating it so she could get the dishes she wanted.“

3.8 Good66 Reviews
John's Pizza Shop Pizza • $
247 Pauline Dr, York

Customers` Favorites

Meatball Mushroom Pizza
Cheese Pizza Slice
French Fries
Wings

“This place is a great lunch spot in a place with a ton of fast food options. The food is so fresh, always. They have a half sub and fries for $6.50 or something like that at lunchtime and it's a heck of a deal. I've eaten several of their subs, right now I'm enjoying a top tier Italian sub and it's outstanding. The customer service on the phone is wonderful and the gentleman who answers speaks so clearly and kindly without making you feel like he's being slow with you. Just an all around great lunch spot!“

3.8 Good39 Reviews
PR's Bar-N-Grill Bar & Grill • $
2350 N George St, York

Customers` Favorites

PR's Special Pizza
Pizza Burger

“This is one of those great little hole-in-the-wall bars that makes York a great place it is a little small bar that's always there and always open the staff is awesome and the owner is a great guy this is one of those places that's a rare gem good cheap beers great pool tables good place to just kick back and have a good time!“

3.8 Good31 Reviews
Parma Pizza and Grill Pizza • $
1041 Haines Rd, York

Customers` Favorites

Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Pizza by the Slice
Pepperoni Pizza
Chicken Tenders
Cheesesteak

“This place was really good. The pizza and service was good. However, the lasting impression that I came away with was the quality of the workers and staff there. They weren't overly bubbly but they seemed happy to be there and happy to serve us.“

3.7 Good43 Reviews
Pizza Boli's Pizza • $
240 S George St, York

Customers` Favorites

Mixed Fried Chicken
Chicken Wings
Whole Wings
Fries
Pizza
Fish
Gyro

“This is an amazing little place that is quick, efficient, open late, reasonably priced, has good customer service and even better food. The pizza is always hot, fresh, and absolutely delicious.The philly cheese steak fries are out of this world. The food selection is great. I definitely recommend it.“

3.5 Good38 Reviews
Loading...
map Map