10 Best Pizza Restaurants in Sumter

Tony's Pizza Pizza • $
301 N Main St, Sumter

Customers` Favorites

Large Pepperoni Cheese Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza by the Slice
Burnt Steak and Mushroom
Large Cheese Pizza
Slice Pizza
Tony

“I had driven past this place a few times in the past and finally decided to try their pizza as I prefer to support small businesses when I can. No problems ordering over the phone and it was ready within the 20 minute timeframe given. I would say that the pizza was “fine”, but not “very good”. Usually, when you eat a “good” pizza there is something that really stands out such as the crust, sauce, etc., but the best way to describe this pizza is unremarkable. In fact, the crust had absolutely no flavor and was plain in every sense of the word (even chain pizza places flavor their crust). Also, there was very minimal sauce on the entire pizza, so I can’t even say if that was good or not. Overall, very disappointed and won’t drive out of the way again to order here.“

4.1 Good54 Reviews
Sambino's Pizza Pizza • $$
1305 Peach Orchard Rd, Sumter

Customers` Favorites

Shrimp Scampi Baked
A Greek Salad
Baked Ziti
Lasagna
Calzone
Wings

“The only reason why this is a 4 star is because every time I try calling them to order food, they never pick up, and if they do they put you on hold and then they hand up.Otherwise food is amazing, pizza and calzones are our favorites. Specially those Garlic Rolls ?“

4.3 Superb34 Reviews
DE Mara's Italian Restaurant Italian • $
2070 Peach Orchard Rd, Sumter

Customers` Favorites

Meat Lovers Pizza with Extra Cheese
Chicken Carbonara
Amici Cabonara
Cheese Cake
Side Salad
Meat Pizza

“I've had the pasta, hot subs, and their pizza. They are all delicious! They also have the best desserts. After trying the meat lovers pizza, my husband doesn't want pizza from anywhere else. They DO NOT skimp on the amount of toppings. My teenage granddaughter was amazed at how good the pizza is. I now visit 1-3 times a week. It's that good.“

4 Good52 Reviews
Tony's Place Fast Food • $
1870 US-15, Sumter

Customers` Favorites

Steak & Cheese Sub with Fries
Tony's Special Sub
Chicken and Fries
Tony's Big Burger
Pepper Steak Sub
Mushroom Steak
French Fries
Chef Salad
blt Sub
Pizza

“I've been looking for a good pizza place since I moved here a year ago. This for me, has been the closest. I've eaten here 3 times in two weeks. The pizza is excellent, the dough could use a dash more salt. I love a good cheese steak and even their pepper steak is good. If I could suggest, when the meat is just starting to cook, salt, pepper and some oregano would elevate this sub. Either way, I'll be back soon thank you!“

4.1 Good39 Reviews
Georgio's II Famous Pizza Pizza • $
344 Pinewood Rd, Sumter

Customers` Favorites

Pizza Missing the Extra Sauce
Pepperoni and Hamburger Pizza
Geogios Special Sub
Small Bread Basket
Georgio's Special
Meat Lovers Pizza
Chicken Parmesan
Pepperoni Pizza
Meatball Sub
Toasted Sub

“Delicious food, great food off the menu, but we usually get the lunch buffet, and everything is very good! Pizzas, casseroles, pasta selections, baked chicken, fantastic salad bar! Highly recommended! Cheerful and attentive staff, and fine food prep staff, wonderful owner!“

3.8 Good44 Reviews
Little Caesars Pizza Pizza • $
810 Broad St, Sumter

Customers` Favorites

5 Dollar Pepperoni Pizza at Little Ceaser's
Wings and Sauce
Cheese Pizza
Breadsticks
Cookies

“I loved the fact that Little "Caesars Pizza .. Partner with Libety Stem School to do a fundraiser to help the school. I order the combo to support my grandchild TJTravis Washington! The fundraiser is still on till the 16 of March. So if anyone would like to support Liberty SchoolThe Pizza and Wings and cheese bread ..was just awesome. And the staff was really nice and polite! And Little Ceasars made the link very easy for person to use even if you are a Senior Citizen like myself! Lol ?Parking: They parking is very limited. Beside for the parking everything else was on point.“

3.8 Good41 Reviews
Pizza Lane Pizza • $
460 Broad St, Sumter

Customers` Favorites

Bacon & Cheddar Pizza with Alfredo Sauce
Large Thin Crust Supreme Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
French Fries
Taco Pizza

“What a great experience! We loved the food! And we asked for a desert pizza but my daughter was losing her mind, she needed a nap. So we had to leave before it was put out. The lady had just finished it for us and boxed it up for us to take home.It was a fantastic pizza by the way!Love love it here!“

3.8 Good40 Reviews
Pizza Hut Pizza Delivery • $
1268 Peach Orchard Rd, Sumter

Customers` Favorites

Oven-Baked Chicken Alfredo Pasta
Triple Chocolate Brownie
Breaded Boneless Wings
Pepperoni Lovers Pizza
Hawaiian Chicken Pizza
Cinnabon Mini Rolls
Traditional Wings
Meat Lovers Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
Cheese Sticks

“There was an accident in front of the store which delayed the delivery however they called multiple times to keep me in the loop about the delays and even remade the order due to the wait. Food was great and they're gonna be my go to now in the “

3.6 Good128 Reviews
Papa Johns Pizza Pizza • $
435 N Guignard Dr, Sumter

Customers` Favorites

The Meats Pizza Takeout: Yes
Double Chocolate Chip Brownie
Sausage and Cheese
Tropical Luau Pizza
The Works Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
Xtra Large Pizza
New York Pizza
Garlic Knots
Cheese Pizza

“This place has always been a good experience for me. The staff greets you when you enter the store and the interactions are always positive. The pizza tracker or sms message service is accurate so when you get to the store your order is ready. I would recommend this Pappa Johns to anyone who wants good service and a good meal for a good price.“

3.7 Good37 Reviews
Chuck E. Cheese Pizza • $$
1121 Broad St, Sumter

Customers` Favorites

Large Build Your Own
Chuck E Cheese Meal
Small Dippin Dots
Pepperoni Pizza
App Sampler

“I just love the service here. The Employees helpful, The food is amazing. Also thanks for keeping the Chuck E Cheese Animatronic. -Na'KirP.S: If your planning on removing the Chuck E Cheese Animatronic, get in touch with me and i will give it a good home.“

3.8 Good25 Reviews
Loading...
map Map