Pauly's Pizzeria & Sub Co.

1624 E Saint Patrick St, Rapid City
(605) 348-7827

Recent Reviews

Ghost

Pauly's has 3 things going for it: 1. It seems to be the only pizzeria that is open after 8 PM; 2. It's staff if really friendly; and 3 It offers outdoor seating. All of that far outweighs the fact that their pizza is nothing special.

Kevin Juergens

Great pizza other online reviews helped us decide on a local pizza place and we are not disappointed!

Alicia Bay

We stumbled upon this place while in town from Michigan. I am a supporter of eating at locally-owned restaurants and WOW, this splace knocked it out of the park. We got the Mac & Cheese and Buffalo Chicken pizzas. Both superb. One of the best crusts I've ever eaten filled with amazingly fresh and generous toppings. Fast and friendly staff. If we are in the Black Hills area again, we will certainly go out of our way to enjoy this establishment. Highly recommend.

Jesus Rodriguez Jr

This pizza was SO GOOD!!! I’m from Texas and I have never eaten pizza this tasty, every single slice was perfection. The guy in the register was super nice, I didn’t get his name but he had glasses and was so kind to us the entire time. Hopefully I can visit sometime again in the future! Try anything and everything, you’ll love it!

Valerie jenson

Food is delicious! They have a decent menu! Staff is super friendly and all have a great sense of humor! They have a wide variety of beer! Really a cool place to go and delicious food!

Toshia T.

There was a very long black hair in my sandwich. One bite and it went straight in the trash. Haven't been back since.

Jennifer Vickers

Pauly's has excellent pizza! The Gary is by far our favorite. If you are looking for a local pizza place, this is the spot.

kannef

This place has amazing pizza that just hits the spot, worth the wait for it to bake. My kids enjoyed the mac & cheese & bacon pizza, and adults enjoyed the chicken alfredo pizza and BBQ chicken pizza. The crust was perfect - not too thick, not too thin, not greasy. Toppings and cheese went close to the edge. The cost of the personal-sized pizzas felt very reasonable, so we were all able to get what we wanted (instead of being forced to share larger pizzas with toppings some didn't want in order to make it cost-effective). We were all super happy and satisfied after this meal, and will remember it as the best pizza we've had in a long time.

Brett Harrowa

Nothing but good things to say. Sandwiches are amazing! Pizza is awesome and the service can't be beat.

Terry G.

I drove into Rapid City from my camping spot in the Black Hills just to hang out and get a pizza. I researched pizza places in Rapid City and landed on Pauly's based on reviews. I was the only customer when I arrived with only 1 other customer before I departed. The guy behind the counter was pleasant and helpful. I ordered a pepperoni pizza with some extras. The pizza was good, I had the craving so at that point Dominoes might have tasted good. There was an ample serving of meat on the pizza but I should have ordered extra sauce because the pie was dry. I like sauce and cheese on my pizza and although the meat was plentiful, it was lacking enough cheese and sauce. That is not a knock on the restaurant because pizza is made differently at different locales. The place was clean, service was good, prices were fair and the pizza was good. I would buy a pie at Pauly's again but I would ask for extra cheese and sauce to satisfy my preferences. Thanks Pauly's you scratched my itch that day.

Jennifer N.

What a fun, delicious joint! We were in town for a week and visited twice - first time with a very large group (40), second time as a family of 4. Consistently great food (pizza, subs, salads) - Very fresh and flavorful. Beer wall unique and fun! Owner and staff genuinely value customers and provide excellent service. Thanks all!!

Susan Stenlund

My friends, Bruce and Carol, told me about this amazing place and talked up the owner. The owner, food, service, and quality were nothing short of my friends' praise!! Awesome experience!!

Curtis Price

Pizza and Reuben salad were great. PB rice crispy treat was missing 4 pieces though. Every time I get these it’s one piece less. Please fix this!

tayler yates

The food was so good! Best food we've eaten since we started traveling. I had a sub and soup and the rest of the family had pizza. Everyone loved it. Super clean restaurant. Saw someone eating a salad that looked great! Definitely recommend!

Jason Karlson

Wanted to eat some where we haven't been so stopped in here. Pizza was amazing, had the macorine and cheese with bacon. I also had the chicken tortilla soup and it was good. Would definitely recommend stopping in.

Load More