Belmar used to be THE bakery to get anything you are craving. The past year or 2 this place has really declined in food quality. This is a fruit pie i got a couple days ago and as you can see there 1 apple slice and barely any filling. The other half looked exactly the same for a total of 2 apple slices in a homemade fruit pie. My husband used to love their eclairs, but the last few times we got some, there is literally only filling in half of the eclair, so i stopped getting those for him and tried a fruit pie just to find the same issue. We won’t be going back to waste money at this bakery until they get bakers who actually care about the quality of product they are selling.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 3
Kasey Barnett
Submitted a form for a custom cake online, was told I would receive an email back in 48 hours, 8 days later and nothing! Was trying to get something in for Valentines before they were booked and now no such luck and good luck getting anything anywhere else at this point. Just don’t use their online forms, fair warning, other than that you’ll get an amazing dessert!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 2
Sarah Faulkner
I want to thank Scarlet, the young lady who answered the phone at the bakery this morning and took my order for a cake. I had to order at the last minute and she was very helpful and kind and let me know upfront that she would do her best to take care of my order, but that limitations were in place due to a full book for the weekend. I am posting this because she wanted to please me as a client but at the same time she operated under the guidelines set forth by her boss. My point? It’s hard to find staff who go to that length instead of just tossing off a client by saying their custom orders were filled. Anyway, besides having the best strawberry cake in Amarillo, Belmar Bakery has staff who seem to genuinely want the best goods leaving their door each day.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kellie Jones
Got a lemon bar They usually are very good but today it was awful.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 1
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Classic Cookies
Maria Blea
My Daughter in law ordered a cake for my granddaughter’s birthday and paid over 100 dollars for it. After cutting into the cake, the icing in between the layers of cake was almost if not about an inch thick. We tried again last month and ordered a cake for my grandson’s birthday, and again disappointed with the thick icing. We would have gladly paid more for more layers of cake if we knew it was going to be more icing than cake. The thing that really disappointed even more was the fact that my grandson’s cake was Jurassic Park and brown and green in color then got the smash cake in white… Seriously??? the person who took the order said it was going to be the same color as the cake then when I mentioned it to the girl, she said they can redo it if wanted to wait 20 minutes which I didn’t have that time, so we ended up with a brown and white cake. I think I’m done with this place. I don’t recommend it at all.., it’s really gone downhill on top it it looking so dirty..
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 2
Nadine Iglesias
Hands down the best bakery I've had in Amarillo. The employees are awesome!! Fantastic service! Everyone was polite pastries were amazing 10/10! I can't wait to come back the next time I'm in Amarillo. Much love from Fort Worth!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Katie
Very disappointed! This used to be my favorite place in the world! As a kid this was such a treat. If mom brought home Belmar we knew something good was happening and we were celebrating. It’s tragic that you have completely lost that special touch that made you Amarillo’s best bakery! You have gone so cheap cutting back on everything to save and cut corners to the point of losing customers you have had for over 40 years! A thumbprint cookie should have icing in the thumbprint! I guess you have two year olds, putting the thumb print! My gosh stop being cheap.!!! it’s icing & it can’t possibly be that expensive and if it is maybe that justifies you charging what you charge! It used to be buy two dozen cookies you get one for free now you get it half price. come on Belmar do better! Consumers are NOT going to put up with this forever! By the way, you have to actually put a thumbprint into the cookie or your icing tends to fall off! Just a tip from someone knew how the old Belmar was!Also, I have memories with my mother find us napoleons. I have tried them several times, and every time I buy them here at Delmar. They are old and not even edible. Please do better. Some of us have been loyal to a fault otherwise I wouldn’t still be coming here. Please care about your customers again!!!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Game Over Gaming Entertainment
I had ordered a cake and planned on picking it up Saturday during normal business hours after I got off work, but unfortunately I had to work late until well past their closing time and Jennifer told me that she could meet me there in 20 minutes, so I could still pick up the cake I had ordered for my fiancé’s birthday party. If I could give them a 20 star rating for service, I would.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Birthday Cake
Mase Mcn
Not enough cherry filling in the pie left with dry mouth and diabetes
Mandi Marufo
When in on Saturday 9-9 to see about gender reveal cake and was told we don’t color cake batter or anything the only thing they could do was write on the cake. Was disappointed I thought bakery’s would do gender reveal cakes Guess wrong. The staff was nice
Belmar bakery made my grandson’s birthday cake and they did such an amazing job!! We loved the design! They nailed it!! ?❤️
Laura Escobedo
Always beautiful and delicious! Never disappointed.
Natascha Manley
Belmar bakery did our wedding cake in 2019, a little while ago but it looked and did taste amazing.We went also in a couple times for their bakery items. Friendly service!
Season Fulton
Best bakery I have found in Amarillo. They have so many classic options and they’re all delicious. I still haven’t been to the cafe for lunch or brunch but look forward to it. I really thought Amarillo just did not have a good bakery until I went to Belmar.
cindy rowley
Belmar provides the most delicious, personalized desserts! Definitely a must for any special occasion!
Belmar used to be THE bakery to get anything you are craving. The past year or 2 this place has really declined in food quality. This is a fruit pie i got a couple days ago and as you can see there 1 apple slice and barely any filling. The other half looked exactly the same for a total of 2 apple slices in a homemade fruit pie. My husband used to love their eclairs, but the last few times we got some, there is literally only filling in half of the eclair, so i stopped getting those for him and tried a fruit pie just to find the same issue. We won’t be going back to waste money at this bakery until they get bakers who actually care about the quality of product they are selling.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 3
Submitted a form for a custom cake online, was told I would receive an email back in 48 hours, 8 days later and nothing! Was trying to get something in for Valentines before they were booked and now no such luck and good luck getting anything anywhere else at this point. Just don’t use their online forms, fair warning, other than that you’ll get an amazing dessert!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 2
I want to thank Scarlet, the young lady who answered the phone at the bakery this morning and took my order for a cake. I had to order at the last minute and she was very helpful and kind and let me know upfront that she would do her best to take care of my order, but that limitations were in place due to a full book for the weekend. I am posting this because she wanted to please me as a client but at the same time she operated under the guidelines set forth by her boss. My point? It’s hard to find staff who go to that length instead of just tossing off a client by saying their custom orders were filled. Anyway, besides having the best strawberry cake in Amarillo, Belmar Bakery has staff who seem to genuinely want the best goods leaving their door each day.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Got a lemon bar They usually are very good but today it was awful.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 1
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Classic Cookies
My Daughter in law ordered a cake for my granddaughter’s birthday and paid over 100 dollars for it. After cutting into the cake, the icing in between the layers of cake was almost if not about an inch thick. We tried again last month and ordered a cake for my grandson’s birthday, and again disappointed with the thick icing. We would have gladly paid more for more layers of cake if we knew it was going to be more icing than cake. The thing that really disappointed even more was the fact that my grandson’s cake was Jurassic Park and brown and green in color then got the smash cake in white… Seriously??? the person who took the order said it was going to be the same color as the cake then when I mentioned it to the girl, she said they can redo it if wanted to wait 20 minutes which I didn’t have that time, so we ended up with a brown and white cake. I think I’m done with this place. I don’t recommend it at all.., it’s really gone downhill on top it it looking so dirty..
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 2
Hands down the best bakery I've had in Amarillo. The employees are awesome!! Fantastic service! Everyone was polite pastries were amazing 10/10! I can't wait to come back the next time I'm in Amarillo. Much love from Fort Worth!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Very disappointed! This used to be my favorite place in the world! As a kid this was such a treat. If mom brought home Belmar we knew something good was happening and we were celebrating. It’s tragic that you have completely lost that special touch that made you Amarillo’s best bakery! You have gone so cheap cutting back on everything to save and cut corners to the point of losing customers you have had for over 40 years! A thumbprint cookie should have icing in the thumbprint! I guess you have two year olds, putting the thumb print! My gosh stop being cheap.!!! it’s icing & it can’t possibly be that expensive and if it is maybe that justifies you charging what you charge! It used to be buy two dozen cookies you get one for free now you get it half price. come on Belmar do better! Consumers are NOT going to put up with this forever! By the way, you have to actually put a thumbprint into the cookie or your icing tends to fall off! Just a tip from someone knew how the old Belmar was!Also, I have memories with my mother find us napoleons. I have tried them several times, and every time I buy them here at Delmar. They are old and not even edible. Please do better. Some of us have been loyal to a fault otherwise I wouldn’t still be coming here. Please care about your customers again!!!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
I had ordered a cake and planned on picking it up Saturday during normal business hours after I got off work, but unfortunately I had to work late until well past their closing time and Jennifer told me that she could meet me there in 20 minutes, so I could still pick up the cake I had ordered for my fiancé’s birthday party. If I could give them a 20 star rating for service, I would.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Birthday Cake
Not enough cherry filling in the pie left with dry mouth and diabetes
When in on Saturday 9-9 to see about gender reveal cake and was told we don’t color cake batter or anything the only thing they could do was write on the cake. Was disappointed I thought bakery’s would do gender reveal cakes Guess wrong. The staff was nice
Restaurantji Recommends
Belmar bakery made my grandson’s birthday cake and they did such an amazing job!! We loved the design! They nailed it!! ?❤️
Always beautiful and delicious! Never disappointed.
Belmar bakery did our wedding cake in 2019, a little while ago but it looked and did taste amazing.We went also in a couple times for their bakery items. Friendly service!
Best bakery I have found in Amarillo. They have so many classic options and they’re all delicious. I still haven’t been to the cafe for lunch or brunch but look forward to it. I really thought Amarillo just did not have a good bakery until I went to Belmar.
Belmar provides the most delicious, personalized desserts! Definitely a must for any special occasion!