Brothers Pizza

3605 Plank Rd, Fredericksburg
(540) 548-0400

Recent Reviews

Tom Kibler

The best!! Garlic knots off the chain, Pizza the best, hippie rolls to die for


Best pizza in the Burg, seriously. This is very close to NYC pizza in style and everyone who knows pizza knows that NYC pizza is the best. Really really good crust with a great chewy texture. Really nice flavor to their sauce. Will always be our go-to when we need a pie.

Daryl L

This is great pizza! Makes me feel like I'm back in New York :)

Sarah S.

A-mazing NY pizza! Crust is thin, just enough crisp, excellent flavor. Topping are plentiful & fresh, perfect amount of cheese. Salads are fresh made to order & their homemade balsamic dressing is crisp & a wonderful compliment to veggies. Some seating indoors & outdoors, very safe area, plenty of parking in shopping center. The family-owned biz shows lots of love with their caring, thoughtful & patient service. You need this pizza!

David Wheeler

If you want authentic NY style pizza this is the place for you. They have excellent sausage rolls and the steak/cheese subs are great as well. My family has been a loyal customer for well over 20 years, on average at least 2-3 times a month. Never once have we been displeased/dissatisfied with the service or product.

Tikesha Williams

Customer service was on point. Pizza was delicious...Nyc style. Crust was like I like it. Restaurant was really clean. Will dine here again.

Bellamy V.

We went here on 6/27/2021 for my younger brother's birthday. He recently passed away in February. His favorite food was pizza especially New York Style pizza. After asking everyone in my food groups for suggestions Brother's was the clear winner. Honoring my little brother with Brother's Pizza just felt right. Really amazing. Perfectly greasy, thin crust New York style pizza. I know he would have loved it. We also got the spicy sausage roll aka the hippy roll and it was really good too. The people inside were so very kind. We will definitely be back. *cash or check only*

Tosha Warren

The chef salad is to absolutely die for! Frank's wife makes them and she is the best. Frank makes the pizzas and I they are just amazing! Best little pizza joint around. They only take cash or check. Just go there you won't be disappointed.

Jenaya M

Moving to VA from NJ I haven’t had good pizza until I found this place! Their pizza reminds me of home, it’s delicious! Best pizza around hands down.

Cameron Folkins

If you want quantity pizza and the biggest pizzas go to bennys in downtown fredericksburg. If you want quality pizza with better taste, this is the best pizza I had around town. Closest to new york pizza. Unless your from new york this pizza would be tough to beat. Always delicious and well made! I give it five stars.


I'm a new Yorker who came to the area to be disappointed by local pizza. This place reminds me of real NYC style pizza, clearly the workers have NYC roots and it's family owned. Only down side Is there's no delivery, not on delivery apps and do not take credit or debit cards with no ATM inside..

Rodney A.

Always great pizza at a fair price. Every time we make the trip to Fredericksburg, the wife tells me to stop. Don't forget a Sausage roll , they're great.

Michael Connell

Being from Long Island it's hard to find NY pizza anywhere south of Jersey that isnt complete trash. They have good pizza and good service. It would be good even in the North East.

Jered Smith

I couldn't ask for better service. The owners are great people. The staff is friendly and the food is absolutely ? spot on. If you like New York style food, Brothers has it! I'm from Boston and nothing even come close the to their EAST COAST style comfort foods.I want to give a huge shout to Brothers steak & cheese sub. They don't have anything on their menu that I don't like. I'm one picky guy too.Thank you guys....


It's just the best pizza you're going to get in Fredericksburg. It beats out Bennys for sure. Benny's has some large slices and is delicious but it just isn't the same. Brother's has THE BEST Barbeque Chicken Pizza without a doubt. You won't regret the choice. You have to try it.

Load More