18 Best American Restaurants in Middleton

Game Time Sports Bar & Grill Sports Bar • $
6862 Co Rd K, Middleton

Customers` Favorites

Bacon Cheeseburger with Fries
Chicken Drummies
Mushroom & Swiss
Chicken Tenders
Monster Burger
Fish and Chips

“A buddy and I were passing through while headed to a Twins-Cubs game in MSP via Wisconsin Dells. We had wanted to eat in Madison around the college but it was graduation weekend and everything was booked and had huge waits. So we ended up here. I am so glad we did! My buddy had the fish fry and I had a burger. He said the fish was outstanding and my burger was on the best I have had in years. I wish this place was closer to home!“

5 Superb27 Reviews
The Village Green Bar • $
7508 Hubbard Ave, Middleton

Customers` Favorites

Baked Cod with Little Reds
Bacon Blue Cheese Burger
Wisconsin Cheese Curds
Bacon Cheeseburger
Fried Green Beans
Sweet Potato Fries
Hamburger

“It would be hard to find a more authentic Wisconsin experience without driving deep into the state. Owner is a very nice guy, veteran, has worked there for years and took it over from the previous owner and has kept the history going. A friendly warm place.“

4.6 Superb57 Reviews
Cooper’s Hawk Winery & Restaurant- Middleton American • $$$
1611 Deming Way, Middleton

Customers` Favorites

Pan-Seared Mahi Mahi in a Coconut Sauce
Italian Sausage & Whipped Burrata
Soy Ginger Glazed Atlantic Salmon
Wasabi-Buttered Mashed Potatoes
Pretzel-Crusted Pork Chops
Crispy Brussels Sprouts
Pan-Roasted Mahi Mahi
Chicken Potstickers
Barrel Reserve
Drunken Shrimp

“I got my first chance to eat at Coopers Monday night. Sat at the bar with a friend and had great service from Kelsey B.! One thing that I don’t do is drink tap water…. and finally a nice restaurant carry’s Acqua Panna served in a wine class with a lemon!!!! Love it!! Both our steaks were cooked perfectly!! Then to top it off, the Manager named Ross stops over and surprised us with a slice of Carrot Cake!!! My man! ?. The ambience was perfect, not too much light and not too dim. ??“

4.4 Superb85 Reviews
Mid Town Pub Pubs • $
2405 Allen Blvd, Middleton

Customers` Favorites

Veggie Burger & Sweet Potato Fries
Blackened Fish Tacos
Prime Rib Sandwich
Walleye Sandwich
Waffle Fries
Cheese Curds
Beer Drinker
Onion Rings
Patty Melt
Taco Salad

“Food was good, service was excellent, staff were beautiful and friendly. Would definitely recommend and I will be back.Vegetarian options: They have good vegetarian options, I can definitely recommend their Stuffed Grilled 4 Cheese sandwich and their fries are really good (both regular potato and sweet potato varieties)Parking: Parking is right in front and even when busy, they seem to have enough (although if they ever have a big crowd that all drove separately for some reason, I suppose could get full)“

4.4 Superb75 Reviews
Hubbard Avenue Diner Diner • $
7445 Hubbard Ave, Middleton

Customers` Favorites

Family Style Meal Meatloaf of the Gods with Vegetables Potato Rolls and Choice of Potato
Root Beer Float with Two Scoops of Vanilla Ice Cream
Peanut Butter Chocolate Silk Pie
Eggs Benedict with Avocado
Traditional French Toast
Buttermilk Pancakes
Huevos Rancheros
Chicken Pot Pie
Slices of Pie
Eggs Benedict

“I had there pancakes and breakfast scramble then bought some pie slices. Pancakes were great the breakfast scramble was good I do believe they always change it up but you can get whatever you liked from my understanding. The pies well be careful after you have one you just might want a whole pie to your self or 2 or more lol. You definitely can't go wrong I'm looking forward to go back for the 3rd time since I've been out here for work.“

4.3 Superb125 Reviews
Craftsman Table & Tap American • $$
6712 Frank Lloyd Wright Ave, Middleton

Customers` Favorites

Carr Valley Cheese Curds
Fantastic Cheese Curds
Fried Chicken Sandwich
Grilled Salmon Salad
Sweet Potato Fries
Craftsman Burger
Chocolate Mousse
Fish and Chips
Fish Fry
Quiche

“Can be a little pricey but our family enjoys the food. If there is one thing to change, I would love for the default side (a boatload of house made chips) to be replaced with a handful of fries. The chips do not hit the spot and there are way too many of them, while the fries are delicious. 5-6 waffle fries instead of a mountain of blah chips, with the upcharge for extra fries, would make for a better meal, less waste, and hopefully neutral costs for the restaurant.Staff has always been warm and welcoming, and we will be back many more times (I'm sure).“

4.3 Superb90 Reviews
The Free House Pub Pubs • $$
1902 Parmenter St, Middleton

Customers` Favorites

Ghost Pepper Cheese Curds
Homemade Jalapeno Poppers
Wisconsin Cheese Curds
Homemade Clam Chowder
Prime Rib Sandwich
Reuben Sandwich
Fish Fry
Salads
Nachos

“Free house made a very tasty smash burger/ hamburger for me today…it was really good! It took really really long for them to take our order and cook my burger though…like 20 minutes to order and 20 minutes to cook. It was very tasty though!“

4.3 Superb73 Reviews
C's Restaurant & Bakery American • $
2550 Allen Blvd, Middleton

Customers` Favorites

2x4 Pancakes Sausage Links Bacon Scrambled Eggs and a Side of American Fries
Eggs Hash Browns Wheat Toast and Bacon
C's Homemade Buttermilk Pancakes
Homemade Cinnamon Roll Sandwich
Cinnamon Swirl Pancakes
Cinnamon Roll Waffle
Florentine Benedict
Southwest Skillet
Sausage Gravy

“I moved to this area about a year ago and have finally experienced this wonderful little local gem! It is a breakfast spot only and it is always packed! They close at 1 PM everyday. I have been wanting to go in there but never am I there early enough to get a table without waiting even though i'm sure it is worth the wait!I have had take out their 4 or 5 times now and it is so delicious-- just like home cooking!I don't think you can go wrong with anything there. I've had their omelets, I've had their breakfast sandwiches I've had their skillets and those pecan rolls are to die for! They have quite the bakery and I'm afraid to try to sample everything so for now i'm sticking with the pecan rolls!If any management or ownership are reading this, I would like to make one suggestion as far as an item I'd love to see you add in terms of bakery items. I'm sure would be a hit- Instead of strawberry rhubarb, try raspberry and rhubarb! I'm actually surprised at how many places don't have it on their menu and always have the strawberry. I promise you, you'll be pleasantly surprised with the raspberry and rhubarb combination. Strawberry, I've always feel overpowers the rhubarb whereas the raspberry compliments the rhubarb nicely! Just need a little added sugar to tone down the tartness.I used to go to the diner in Verona, which I think is as good although they don't have the bakery. But now this is so much closer. So for the most part, I'll be enjoying my breakfasts here at C's!Thank you so much forThe awesome service in the great food!“

4.3 Superb66 Reviews
Nitty Gritty-Middleton American • $
1021 N Gammon Rd, Middleton

Customers` Favorites

Crispy White Cheddar Cheese Curds
Corned Beef and Cabbage
Impossible Gritty Burger
Roasted Garlic Burger
Farmers Market Burger
Spinach Artichoke Dip
Soft Pretzel Sticks
Birthday Sunday
Sunrise Burger
Gritty Sauce

“Great food, great atmosphere. Fair prices and easy to access/find location. Only complaint I'd say was the service was not good. Our server took a long time to greet the table, get our drinks, and then once food arrived, we didn't see her unless we flagged her down. We needed silverware and napkins - so to have to go find her because she didn't stop by after the food was delivered was annoying. Also, once we were done and wanting to go, we stopped her on her way by asking her for the check. She said sure, and we still waited 11 minutes for the check. I realize she prob had a bigger table or party which was a priority, but maybe they shouldn't seat people in her section/turn in rotation? I'd still recommend though as the food is really good...and roll the dice you have a more experienced / attentive server“

4.2 Good84 Reviews
Culver’s American • $
2906 Parmenter St, Middleton

Customers` Favorites

Butter Burger and Mashed Potatoes and Gravy
Chocolate Frozen Custard with Reese
Double Deluxe Butterburger
Cheese Curds and Concrete
Butter Burger with Cheese
Frozen Custard with Oreo
Grilled Cheese Sandwich
Double Butter Burger
Chocolate Custard
Turtle Sundae

“The staff here is always friendly and fast! They have delicious food and various types of seating options. Online ordering to your table is smooth and easily lets you explore the options. Their sound reduction is also great so you can easily hear people at your table without having to talk over your neighbors!“

4.2 Good65 Reviews
1847 at the Stamm House American • $$
6625 Century Ave, Middleton

Customers` Favorites

French Onion Soup
Pesto Pappardelle
Chicken Parmesan
Beef Stroganoff
Chicken Alfredo
Chicken Marsala
Fish and Chips
Chocolate Cake
Cheese Curds
Farm Burger

“We celebrated some birthdays at 1847 last night. My wife turning 70 as the latest. A unique experience and great ambiance to say the least. The service and the food were par excelente. Our waitress Aliza was so warm and friendly. Hope to dine there again!“

4.1 Good77 Reviews
Monk's Bar & Grill American • $
8313 Murphy Dr, Middleton

Customers` Favorites

Monk's Chicken Tenders Basket
Sweet Chili Cauliflower Bites
Club Sandwich with Fries
Santa Fe Chicken Salad
Sweet Potato Fries
Deep Fried Pickles
Impossible Burger
Brisket Sandwich
Truffle Fries
Chicken Wrap

“Giving it 5 stars because even tho the food isn't the best in Madison, it is pretty damn good even if it's just bar food. Service was great too, quick and always had a full drink, which is always appreciated. We went for March Madness games and were not disappointed as they have plenty of TVs to watch the games, including some in the dining room I'd you want to more family friendly environment to eat and watch the games.“

4 Good76 Reviews
Longtable Beer Cafe Bar • $$
7545 Hubbard Ave, Middleton

Customers` Favorites

Pulled Pork Burger with Coleslaw
Large Charcuterie Board
Soft Hot Pretzel V
Beer Cheese Soup
Grilled Cheese
Cheese Curds V
Fish and Chips
BBQ Platter
Brisket

“We decided to try this Cafe out on an incredibly busy night! The food was excellent and the service was extraordinary! The manager waited on us because they were so busy! He stopped by twice to ask if we needed anything! Will definitely be back. I love the ambience!“

4 Good64 Reviews
Paul's Neighborhood Bar Bar & Grill • $
2401 Parmenter St, Middleton

Customers` Favorites

Fried Cod Fish
Friday Fish Fry
Baked Cod Fish
Chicken Basket
Fried Perch
Mini Tacos
Salad Bar

“This was a new place for us and we liked the Friday Fish Fry. It was very good and the options were endless. We had takeout and ordering was so easy. The meal was ready on time. The parking lot was full, but I was able to street park a block away. We will be back.“

4 Good60 Reviews
Bristled Boar Saloon & Grill Bar & Grill • $
2611 Branch St, Middleton

Customers` Favorites

Mushroom Swiss Burger and Fries
Bare Foot Merlot
Cheese Curds
Blatz

“Bartenders were really busy but still very attentive. All of our food choices were really good. We ordered chicken nachos, jalapeno poppers, Reuben bites and chicken wings.Bathrooms were clean and temperature of the bar was nice and warm on a day that was below zero outside.“

4 Good35 Reviews
Middleton Sport Bowl American • $
6815 University Ave, Middleton

“If you go in with appropriate expectations you’ll be set! Very rural/up north small town feel. Good beer selection of local places. Staff is efficient and helpful.Food was your average bar food. Found the onion rings a bit under fried, and walleye sandwich slightly in the bland side. The crisped bread it was served on had more flavor.Myope spot to go bowl.“

3.9 Good36 Reviews
World of Beer Gastropubs • $
8225 Greenway Blvd Ste. 140, Middleton

Customers` Favorites

Great Lakes Brewery Edmund Fitzgerald Porter
Beer Cheese Nachos Beer - Infused
German Pretzel with Beer Cheese
Garlic Breaded Cheese Curds
Belgian Beer Waffles Beer
Black & Blue Flatbread
Black & Bleu Flatbread
Fried Shrimp
Street Tacos
Tater Tots

“I did not expect this. Great food, great atmosphere for watching sports, great beer selection at reasonable prices! Many beers on tap are priced $5 to $6.50! I went in and ordered the ribeye beef dip ($14.25) and it was absolutely delicious! No noticeable gristle or fat. For an extra dollar I upgraded to sweet potato fries which were good, just not crispy. I saw the potato tots and they looked great as a regular free side that I will pick next time.“

3.8 Good47 Reviews
Dickey's Barbecue Pit Barbecue • $
8225 Greenway Blvd Ste 200, Middleton

Customers` Favorites

Potato Casserole
Barbecue Beans
Beef Brisket
Pulled Pork
Fried Okra
Meat Plate
Sausage
Wings

“I got the giant loaded potato with brisket. I had Dickies in Dallas once before and was so excited to see this place next to my hotel. I walked over ordered and ate in the restaurant…it was just as delicious as I remembered!! Ordering is easy just look at the board and pick your item, then customize as you like. I added extra brisket to my potato and I’m so glad I did. Did I mention it’s delicious?! The two gentlemen working behind the counter were friendly and the dining area was clean. While I was there a young lady w/2 small children came in. The cashier went above and beyond by helping her carry the meals to the table. I highly recommend this place. It’s hard to get really good food that will fill you up for a decent price but at $10-$20 for just about everything on the menu you get your money’s worth here!“

3.8 Good57 Reviews
Loading...
map Map