15 Best Pizza Restaurants in Sheboygan

Uptown Slice Pizza •
1116 Michigan Ave, Sheboygan

Customers` Favorites

Apple Bacon Gorgonzola House White Pie
Chicken and Hot Peppers House Red Pie
Sausage Giardiniera House Red Pie
Uptown Margherita House Red Pie
Market Garden House White Pie
Uptown Funk House White Pie
Gio's Meat House Red Pie
Pizza by the Slice
Build Your Own Pie
JJ’S White Pie

“This place is AMAZING. I tried one of every slice with my sorority sister, they had a deal going on that you get a 5$ wine or beer with it which we most certainly took advantage of. I tried some flavors I would have normally not tried and I was AMAZED! Great staff and great location. Will definitely be back!“

4.9 Superb122 Reviews
Parker John's BBQ & Pizza Barbecue • $
705 Riverfront Dr, Sheboygan

Customers` Favorites

Endless Wings on Wednesdays Teriyaki
Smokehouse Combo Sandwich
Buffalo Chicken Salad
Haystack Onion Rings
Carolina BBQ Sandwich
St Louis Style Ribs
Pulled Pork Tacos
Smokehouse Salad
Pork and Brisket
Thin Crust Pizza

“Great to be eating outside by the river. Food option is great. Love that they have their own sauce for customers to try, tho majority is not that good but to eschew own. The wraps are amazing. Yea, for a BBQ place, they have wraps that I think are better than their BBQ plates. Would I eat here again? Yes.“

4.4 Superb114 Reviews
Luigi's Italian Restaurant Italian • $
2910 Kohler Memorial Dr, Sheboygan

Customers` Favorites

Meat Lovers Chicago Stuffed Pizza
Bruschetta with Tomato and Basil
Chicago Style Stuffed Pizza
Garlic Cheese Bread
Spaghetti Carbonara
Fettuccine Alfredo
Mozzarella Sticks
Chicken Parmesan
Chicken Marsala
Tiramisu

“Was our first time but definitely not our last! The food was amazing! We ordered 2 appetizers, 2 entrées with added meat and veggies and 2 desserts. Our waitress and the staff were helpful and very friendly. One of the best Italian restaurants I've ever been to..“

4.6 Superb54 Reviews
Il Ritrovo Italian • $$
515 S 8th St, Sheboygan

Customers` Favorites

Margherita Pizza Now That's What You Call Italian Pizza MA MA Miyaaaàa
Gnocchi Sorrentina Special
Fried Calamari Fra Diavolo
Calabrese Con Miele
Housemade Tiramisu
Fonduta Al Forno
Wonderful Pizza
Bread and Oil
Caprese Salad
Bianca Pizza

“Il Ritrovo has the best pizza I have ever had outside of actually being in Italy. You can taste their commitment to quality products with every bite. Whenever visiting family in the area stopping here is an amazing treat, and if we are unable to make the trip a disappointment for us . Beyond the authentic style pizzas the general menu items are also great, and have something for everyone in your party. Constantly dreaming of my next mouthwatering visit.“

4.4 Superb90 Reviews
Harry’s Prohibition Bistro Fine Dining • $$
668 S Pier Dr, Sheboygan

Customers` Favorites

Margherita D O C Pizza
Chicken and Gnocchi
Marsala Beef Pizza
Margherita Pizza
Prosciutto Pizza
Sausage Pizza
Beef Marsala
Tiramisu

“This place is amazing!! Every time we come in from out of town we always stop at Harry’s Prohibition Bistro at LEAST once!The food is delicious, the wine is amazing, and the servers are always so friendly and accommodating. Some members in our family have gluten allergies and they always help us with our restrictions.Would honestly rate it more than 5 stars if I could“

4.4 Superb60 Reviews
Frank's Place Bar • $
3023 N 15th St, Sheboygan

Customers` Favorites

Garlic Bread Cheese Garlic Bread
Cheese Pizza

“Frank's is a nice little bar and pizza place if you ask me! The building is well maintained, pretty on the outside and very clean and roomy on the inside and sports a very friendly warm atmosphere! The service was great on all ends; polite, quick and attentive! The food I got was good! The cheese garlic bread was tasty as was the scarface cheese pizza I got! Be warned this is a thin crust pizza place, and the side dishes are DEFINITELY lacking but other than that? No complaints, Frank's is indeed, pun somewhat intended, a good place!Pictures are of the inside and outside of the building and food I got!“

4.6 Superb31 Reviews
Pop's Burger & Pizza House American • $
920 Michigan Ave, Sheboygan

Customers` Favorites

Deep Dish Supreme Pizza
Classic Cheeseburger
Ranch Chicken Wrap
Meat Lovers Pizza
Cheese Curds
Italian Beef
Voodoo Shrimp
Steak Nachos
Onion Rings
Wings

“We had pizza it was good. Service was not that good. Waitress/bad tender stopped at our table only 1 time. We had to go to the bar to order, pay and ask for to-go boxes.I thought it was wierd that the main entrance door opened over the stairs.“

4.3 Superb60 Reviews
Faye's Pizza Pizza • $
1821 Calumet Dr, Sheboygan

Customers` Favorites

Faye’S House Deluxe Pizza
Thin Create Your Own Pizza
Cheese and Sausage Pizza
Meat Lovers Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
Garlic Bread
Cheese Pizza
Cajun Pizza
Great Pizza
Taco Pizza

“We hadn't been here in years. The pizza was amazing - had the taco pizza. The cheesey garlic bread was some of the best we've ever had! We'll be back to sample the rest of the menu!Wheelchair accessibility: Easy entry, one floor, plenty of room to maneuver a wheelchair or walker. There is a tiny lip of sidewalk that should be manageable. Parking lot is small, but flat.“

4.1 Good68 Reviews
Peabody's Pizza Company Pizza • $
1123 N 8th St, Sheboygan

Customers` Favorites

Seafood Alfredo
Taco Pizza
blt Pizza
Toppings
Supreme
Nachos

“First, I'm from New England where real pizza is made. So, cheese heads, pay attention!This is probably one of the best and closest thing to east coast pizza I've ever had in Wisconsin. This mini pizza was delicious, and a perfect size for a husky guy like me on a diet (after I already ate some chicken fried rice from the farmer's market... honestly I just wanted pizza).Excellent sauce to cheese to crust ratio.Caution: the "spicy" sausage isn't spicey by east coast standards, so i was both let down and happy that I wouldn't be coughing and trying to clear my throat going back to work. There wasnt any cheddar cheese (pizza should never come with cheddar... so they know something!), and I don't understand why green peppers are so popular instead of red peppers. Oh well.This Peobody's special was packed with flavor, cooked fast (12 minutes when I was told 15), and very affordable. I'd give it 4 stars, but the guy was friendly and this is Wisconsin, so it gets 5.But my taste buds are now salivating for the reviews of their taco pizza. I'll be back!“

4.4 Superb22 Reviews
Toppers Pizza Pizza • $
1102 N 8th St, Sheboygan

Customers` Favorites

Mushy Barbeque Boneless Wings
Buffalo Chicken Topper Pizza
Smoky BBQ Chicken Pizza
Vegan Salsa and Chips
Original Topperstix
Walking Taco Pizza
Boneless Hot Wings
Mac N Cheese Pizza
Cheesy Goodness
Parmesan Garlic

“We had a friendly greeting and great service from Arizona when we arrived. She was very patient with us because it was our first time at Toppers.We enjoyed a medium thin crust pepperoni and black olive pizza and a half pound of boneless chicken wings with BBQ sauce on the side (special price of $7.99 each) and 2 20 oz. sodas.Everything was delicious (especially considering the price). We will definitely be returning again soon!!Thank you Arizona and Blake for the wonderful dinner and service!!“

4 Good65 Reviews
Time And A Half Bar • $
2518 N 15th St, Sheboygan

“Recently discovered this terrific neighborhood bar and restaurant. The owner (Dayton) is a very friendly guy and experienced chef. His premium pub style fare is delish and exceptionally well priced. Excellent craft beer selection, drink specials every night, brisket nachos etc during Packer games, the bartenders (Gail and Lisa) are fun, enthusiastic, and talented cooks. It's become a new favorite spot in town for my gal and myself. Plenty of pool / darts / games etc for additional entertainment. Pro Tip: Try the Double Time burger with curry mayo and ghost pepper cheese on a pretzel bun. It can't be beat!“

4.6 Superb9 Reviews
Theo's Pizza & Catering Pizza • $
3329 S Business Dr, Sheboygan

Customers` Favorites

No Silverware Required
Mushroom and Sausage
All Meat Pizza
Marinara Sauce
Stuffed Bread
Supreme Pizza
Breadsticks

“We love the pizza here. There are several crust options, and with the variety of toppings, combinations are pretty much endless. We use the online ordering function, and that has eliminated some problems we had in the past with ordering… good help can be hard to find. But all in all, the pizzas are good and service is much improved.“

4 Good45 Reviews
Marco's Pizza Pizza • $
2610 Calumet Dr, Sheboygan

Customers` Favorites

Pepperoni Magnifico
Hawaiian Chicken
Build Your Own
Cheese Bread
Chicken Wings
Deluxe
Greek

“Every. Single. Week. We do a Friday family pizza night with our boys and this Marco's is our go-to! We definitely take advantage of their promo codes/online/carry-out deals...for the price of a frozen pizza now a days or 2....we can get a delicious/fresh made Marco's pizza or 2 and cheesy bread or dessert that our whole family enjoys. The staff is always super friendly (even when they are swamped and super busy!) Seating available at this location. Tips aren't expected, but appreciated and I always leave them something--that crew deserves itTheir wings are good too and better priced than just about anywhere else right now--pizza and wings also great for football sundays!“

4 Good28 Reviews
4th Street Tap Bar • $$
520 N 4th St, Sheboygan

“I came in for a set of darts after calling. I called one bar, which directed me to this one. I found a cozy little nock and a friendly environment with the guy at the bar being very helpful and informative. I'll stop by to shoot some darts soon!“

4 Good19 Reviews
Rocky Rococo Pizza and Pasta Pizza • $
3740 S Taylor Dr, Sheboygan

Customers` Favorites

Super Slice of the Day
Slice of Pepperoni
Damn Great Pizza
The Motherlode
Sausage Pizza
Pizza Slice
Of Pizza

“Stopped here for a quick dinner and was very pleased. The food was served quickly and was hot and delicious. Ordered a regular slice of the sausage pizza and breadsticks, both were great. The employees were all very friendly and the restaurant was spotless. Will definitely stop here again.“

3.7 Good44 Reviews
Loading...
map Map