15 Best American Restaurants in Sun Prairie

Salvatore's Tomato Pies Pizza • $
121 E Main St, Sun Prairie

Customers` Favorites

Fat Uncle Tony’S Pie
Classic Cheeseburger
Fat Uncle Tony Pizza
Farmer John's Pizza
The Woodsman Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
Caesar Salad
Gluten Free
Kids Pizza
Tomato Pie

“I ordered on line and didn’t get the confirmation email. I called the store and they had the order as pick up the person answering my was quick to be able to change my order. I was not able to get a confirmation for delivery time… but short after what would have been pick up, my delivery driver was here! I was not expecting so soon but he was so friendly and wanted to be sure I had my food! Every single order from Sal’s… all the staff are so wonderful! Amazing kindness!“

4.4 Superb105 Reviews
Buck & Honey's - Sun Prairie American • $$
804 Liberty Blvd, Sun Prairie

Customers` Favorites

Firecracker Shrimp Pizza
Flourless Chocolate Cake
Stuffed Chicken Breast
Garlic Mashed Potatoes
Bacon Wrapped Dates
Cedar Plank Salmon
Brussels Sprouts
Steak Gorgonzola
Thin Crust Pizza
BBQ Pulled Pork

“The first time I’ve ever been there. I didn’t try everything on the menu so I’m just saying what I ordered today wasn’t the best. My all time favorite was the bartender Ms Michelle who was extremely nice ,friendly, and fast. I’m coming back to try something else on the menu but I hope to see the amazing Michelle in action she makes the best strawberry dessert drink ever.“

4.4 Superb258 Reviews
Full Mile Beer Company & Kitchen Brewpubs • $
132 Market St Suite #100, Sun Prairie

Customers` Favorites

Hand Battered Cheese Curds
Spicy Chicken Sandwich
Smoked Salmon Bagel
Pulled Pork Nachos
Flame Throwa Pizza
Full Mile Burger
Friday Fish Fry
Flight of Beer
Fried Pickles
Cheeseburger

“One of my favorite restaurants in Sun Prairie!! The beer selection is amazing…their pretzel is AWESOME. It’s whole grain and served with beer cheese dip. The dip is made fresh you can tell. And they keep refreshing their menu so I love to go back and try different things. There’s always a few great veggie options…I’m vegetarian.Vegetarian options: Get the pretzel!! You won’t regret it. ?Parking: Parking nearby“

4.4 Superb85 Reviews
Daly's Bar & Grill Bar & Grill • $
1086 Emerald Terrace Suite A, Sun Prairie

Customers` Favorites

Italian Sausage Sandwich
Southwest Burger
Friday Fish Fry
Fried Pickles
Cheese Curds
Quesadilla
Hamburger

“Have not been there yet, however after reading reviews, and looking at the menu i plan on remedying that soon! I have been trying to eat one meal a day to lose weight, but after looking at menu, photos of the food servered, and customers reviews, and video by the owner, I am ready to go soon. It is a little out of the way for me, looks like it will be worth the trip!“

4.3 Superb67 Reviews
Gus's Diner American • $
630 N Westmount Dr, Sun Prairie

Customers` Favorites

Steak with Eggs and Home Fries
Wisconsin Cheese Curd Burger
Country Fried Steak & Eggs
Homestyle French Toast
Chicken Dumpling Soup
Buttermilk Pancakes
Blueberry Shake
Mashed Potatoes
Two Egg Omelet
Scrambled Eggs

“The service was awesome - very inviting and friendly atmosphere. Kind of outdated, but it adds to its dinner charm. The food was really good with plenty of options to choose from. The salad bar is well-priced and has an abundance of options to create a great salad. I'll definitely go back.“

4.2 Good131 Reviews
Chicken Licks Bar & Grill • $
5508 County Hwy N #3, Sun Prairie

Customers` Favorites

Mac and Cheese Bites Shrimp & Chicken Wings Dryrub
Buffalo Wings with Sexy Spicy Level 2
Lemon Pepper Dry Rub Wings
Chicken Wings with Fries
Deep Fried Mushrooms
Jalapeno Poppers
Crispy Chicken
Dipping Sauce
Waffle Fries
Cheese Curds

“Probably the best buffalo wings you can get in the mid west. This is not a large establishment, you might have to eat at the bar or take your food to go but trust me coming here for an order of their original wings is worth it. They the original wings down with a dry rub of their making and then douse them in their home made buffalo sauce so I hope you are okay with a messy meal. This is also a legitimate dive bar, and take orders at the bar so do not expect some fancy table service. So 10/10 recommend you try these wings, you will not regret the experience.Kid-friendliness: Dive bar, not meant for kids.“

4.2 Good93 Reviews
Pitstop Pub LLC Bar • $$
116 E Main St #2223, Sun Prairie

“I saw so many positive reviews about Mr. Jackson Robert and I must confess that surely is a skilled professional trader and the best among all as his clients all said, he managed my account after I Invested $1000 and got a successful withdrawal of $15,200 within few days of my investment, up-till now am still so shocked and surprised "It always seems impossible until it’s done with Mr. Jackson Robert your hard-earned money is 100% secured/Safe trust me you have nothing to lose or to be scared of at all, You can contact him via“

4.8 Superb12 Reviews
Sir Hobo’s American • $
710 W Main St, Sun Prairie

Customers` Favorites

Ham and Cheese Omelette Smothered Hash Browns w Onions Wisconsin Cheese
Florentine Eggs Benedict
Chocolate Chip Pancakes
Stuffed French Toast
Biscuits and Gravy
French Dip Sandwich
Sausage and Eggs
Sir Hobo Skillet
House Special
Plain Crepes

“It's not what it used to be but it's ok. Not a whole lot of choices on the menu but they do their menu well.Vegetarian options: Omelettes, French toast, pancakes. I think there are a good amount of vegetarian options. Not a good place for vegans though.“

4.2 Good53 Reviews
Varsity Bar & Grill American • $
1205 W Main St, Sun Prairie

Customers` Favorites

Grilled Chicken Breast Sandwich
Philly Cheese Steak
Varsity Burger
Cheese Curds
Cheeseburger
Onion Rings

“Fun for trivia and bar food! Service was good, but they were busy, especially during trivia night. She did her best and was grateful at the end of the night. The food was solid for bar food. Overall, I'd come back for a cheap drink, HH, or trivia.“

4.1 Good59 Reviews
Pizza Ranch FunZone Arcade American • $$
682 S Grand Ave, Sun Prairie

“Despite the previous harsh reviews, this place seemed great to me! This place has a good variety of pizzas that you can choose and if you don't see a pizza that catches your eye, you can place an order for free. There are lots of sides to choose from such as: mashed potatoes, gravy, stuffing, pasta, salad, and plenty of desserts. This place also has an arcade in the back so you can easily entertain kids while you eat. This place is clean, moderately priced and has great customer service. Great place to take a family.“

4 Good43 Reviews
The Rock Sports Bar and Grille Sports Bar • $
920 W Main St, Sun Prairie

Customers` Favorites

Philly Cheesesteak with Sweet Potato Fries
Lunch Special with Brussel Sprout Salad
Louisiana Spicy Crispy Chicken Strips
Cowboy Burger and Beer Battered Fries
Pulled Pork Sandwich
Burger and Fries
Chicken Sandwich
Chicken Wings
Cheese Curds
Fried Cod

“I was recently on a first date at The Rock, as this young man said y'all had the best and biggest chicken wings he'd ever had and I knew regardless of if this date was a bust or not - I needed to find out for myself about these wings.Within a few moments of meeting it was obvious we were not aligned or compatible as human beings but to be respectful and to complete my research on these wings I decided to tough it out and go through with the date. It was kinda slower and I didn't want there to be any implication of privacy or romance, so we sat at the bar. Let me tell you, grateful doesn't even begin to describe it.This young man proceeded to spend the remainder of our date spoke of nothing but his day to day work life as if I were someone who was so actively in his life I would have any idea what he was even talking about. Any chance of subject change got rerouted to his topic of choice, even to the point of describing his "humility and lack of ego" like it wasn't his ego that was delivering such a sermon. It was after his third "I'm a really nice guy..." I knew I needed an ally to find reprieve in conversation and found the bartender's name was Allie.What I'd like to describe as me nonchalantly getting her attention and signaling for a wingwoman was more likely an awkward flail and desperate cry for help - and help she DID.The following 48 minutes of this train wreck of a date came with the silver lining of enjoying my perfectly seasoned, massive, garlic parm wings between belly laughs as Allie served this young man his misogynistic beliefs right back to him. The wings were really good and definitely some of the biggest I've ever had, but it was her quick wit, incredible customer service, and all around cutie patootieness that made the experience a great one; I will absolutely be back (and without that loser) because of it.Every bar needs an Allie.<3“

3.9 Good37 Reviews
Monk's Bar & Grill American • $
2832 Prairie Lakes Dr, Sun Prairie

Customers` Favorites

Sweet Chili Cauliflower Bites
Deep Fried Pickles
Sweet Potato Fries
Monster Burger
Boneless Wings
Chicken Wings
Chicken Wrap
Truffle Fries
Deluxe Nachos
Mushroom

“Decent burgers, but overpriced. With a draft beer, you'll be paying well over $20.00 with tax and, of course, tip.Today, 3/22/24, I had the blue cheese burger. I wasn't impressed. The burger had no detectable flavor, and outside of a few blue cheese crumbles, it almost seemed like blue cheese salad dressing w 2 strips of bacon, and I'm guessing flat top grill.But, I will say the smoked chicken wings with Gochujang Sauce were Awesome!! Great flavor, and a little spicy just a tad expensive.The dining partner tonight had the fish sandwich with their homemade chips, which was awesome as well.“

3.8 Good94 Reviews
Country Cafe Italian • $
1030 Emerald Terrace, Sun Prairie

Customers` Favorites

Country Fried Steak Dinner
Over Easy Eggs and Toast
Breakfast Skillet
Cheese Burger
Hamburger
Pancakes
Waffle

“I visited this diner because sir hobos was closed for a family vacation. And I was NOT disappointed.The average crowd here will Definitely make you feel young...The pancakes are immaculate. Honestly best pancakes I've had in a long while. Fluffy but crispy at the sides. Exactly like mom would wake you up with on Saturday mornings.I would say the atmosphere is very ideal for a diner. They are kind enough to print large examples of food you're waiting to receive. The ambiance is a quiet nod to the early 2000's Tuscany kitchen remodel.And I love that they kept the old stainless steel coffee thermos. And they do a great service to the city of sun prairie for all the kindness they show the geriatrics. Dispite some of them being quite nasty to the staff. Wait staff - I see you and the patience you so undeservedly give.I did have to remove a skunk point because there was an onion on my pancake (not very big but I was still disappointed) and the hash browns were mid.Basically grandmas right, visit this place“

3.7 Good47 Reviews
Culver’s American • $
550 Oxford Pl, Sun Prairie

Customers` Favorites

Salted Caramel Chocolate Cake
North Atlantic Cod Filet
Spicy Crispy Chicken
Butterburger Cheese
Crinkle Cut Fries
Chicken Sandwich
Root Beer Float
Cheese Curds
Jumbo Shrimp
Onion Rings

“Ordered 10pc jumbo butterfly shrimp, double ButterBurger with cheese last night. Shrimp was crispy. Burger was just right. Everything was hot and fresh. Great customer service was provided. Probably the best Culver’s I’ve been to. They’re busy, but they keep the line moving as quickly as they can.“

3.5 Good66 Reviews
Pizza Ranch Buffet • $
682 S Grand Ave, Sun Prairie

Customers` Favorites

Chicken and Stuffing with Gravy an Vegetables
Pasta with Marinara Sauce
Mashed Potatoes and Gravy
Soft Serve Ice Cream
Cherry Dessert Pizza
Fried Chicken Bar
Buffet Your Way
Clubhouse Salad
Chicken Pizza
Garlic Cheese

“Not many all you can eat restaurants around. That being said...it's pizza ranch but the fried chicken mashed potatoes and fixin's are the reason I'll come back. Not to mention the salad bar....kind of brought back feelings of nostalgia. 8 out of 10 would recommend.Parking: The place is always fullKid-friendliness: Kids love it. You can tell there are a lot of regulars.Wheelchair accessibility: No stairs and room for wheelchairs to get around.“

3.5 Good75 Reviews
Loading...
map Map