“After living in South Dakota for 20 years...where no one can make a decent pizza...I have been trying for the last couple of years to recover from "pizza deprivation." I think that last night's visit to Sugar River Pizza in Sun Prairie just about finished the job! My husband, son, and I went there 7ish. There were a lot of cars in the lot, but the restaurant is huge, so we got a table immediately. The hostess warned us that their chip readers were down, and we'd have to pay cash. We figured out that between the three of us, we had over a hundred dollars and hoped that would be enough or one of us would have to scoot over to the bank ATM when the check came. We ordered the wheat breadsticks for an appetizer, one Moscow Mule, on special for $5, two glasses of St. Michele Rieslings, and a large Amazon pizza, thin crust. Everything came to our table quickly, but as it turned out, we would have waited forever for that pizza! It was outstanding! The crust was perfect, the toppings were fresh, just the right amount of sauce and cheese. We ate all but two slices and took those home along with an order of their warm dessert beignets. Total bill, before tip, less than $70!!Please do yourself a favor and go to Sugar River Pizza ASAP. You will not regret it!“
“This place cannot get enough stars!!! I started coming here when I was a little girl. My dad worked for the city of sun prairie and he would either stop on his way home on Friday’s to pick it up, or we would go pick it up together after he got home from work every Friday until I got older. I moved out of state when I turned 18 and have lived various places since and have been in search of a pizza that even moderately compares. No luck in 5 other states and many of pizza places later. I bragged about this place, I told stories about this place, I have core memories attached to this pizza. I’m now 28 and have moved back home as of a few months ago, and my father passed away almost 2 years ago. Since I’ve returned, I’ve had the pleasure of carrying out my dad and I’s tradition of pizza Fridays and it not only brings me the utmost joy, but it connects me with him and helps heal that part of me. The little kid in me smiles every time I take that first bite and as if the pizza could be any more tasty, the meaning behind it makes it all the more delicious!!!! Anna and her family have always been so kind to me and my father, and I love seeing Jeff in there still churning out the tastiest pizza pies! The staff is so friendly and they all know how much this pizza means to me and how I look forward to Friday all week long just for Anna’s! No other pizza in the area compares and I say that confidently!!! I promise you that! The homemade sauce is divinely sweet and the homemade sausage is seasoned to perfection ?? Any toppings are great on Anna’s pizza, but my personal recommendation is to keep it simple so you can enjoy the complexity of flavors from the homemade crust, sauce, and sausage (if you enjoy) and how they sing together in perfect harmony on your tastebuds!! Thankful to have this place!!!“
“Have not been there yet, however after reading reviews, and looking at the menu i plan on remedying that soon! I have been trying to eat one meal a day to lose weight, but after looking at menu, photos of the food servered, and customers reviews, and video by the owner, I am ready to go soon. It is a little out of the way for me, looks like it will be worth the trip!“
“Best pizza in the entire Madison area. The online ordering for pickup is a breeze. We've not done delivery bc we live too far away but it's worth the drive. When ordering online it tells how long for pickup, and that time estimate is always spot-on. The food is always consistent too, so there's never a bad experience.“
“This is definitely my favorite pizza place once me and my friend found a pizza that look like there was a heart on it and the pizza is the best I love the pesto you can get on it!Vegetarian options: There are a lot of veggies you can get that are vegetarian the pesto sauce you can get is very good for vegans and people who can't have milk there is vegan cheese pizza hiley recommended!“
“Despite the previous harsh reviews, this place seemed great to me! This place has a good variety of pizzas that you can choose and if you don't see a pizza that catches your eye, you can place an order for free. There are lots of sides to choose from such as: mashed potatoes, gravy, stuffing, pasta, salad, and plenty of desserts. This place also has an arcade in the back so you can easily entertain kids while you eat. This place is clean, moderately priced and has great customer service. Great place to take a family.“
“Rocky Rococo is a special Midwest treat for us. I have been to many different Rocky Rococo franchises through the years, and the Sun Prairie one is really one of the best, if not the best, Ibhave ever visited. Puntual, accurate, and they provide a great service. We love the Perfect with pepperoni, and the motherload crust is delicious. A real special pizza.“
“the only reason it isn't overall 5 stars is because they switched from Pepsi products to Coke products, their selection for cans, bottles and 2 liters are very limited now. my family always complains about no mtn dew. if this has to do with corporate, please fix it i bet their sales decreased bc of the sudden swtich. the service is amazing though! all staff seem to work very hard and as quickly as they can. best pizza place in sun prairie by far“
“What a great business with a great group of Employees! I was on my way to get food for my employees/coworkers today when my truck was totalled by an inattentive driver. I called to let them know i wouldn’t be able to make it to get the food that I had ordered ahead. They were so caring, firstly asking if i was ok, then offering to deliver the food for me so my guys could eat lunch. They have earned my business and my respect! Can’t thank Everyone Enough! I wish i could give more than 5 stars!“
“I ordered on line and didn’t get the confirmation email. I called the store and they had the order as pick up the person answering my was quick to be able to change my order. I was not able to get a confirmation for delivery time… but short after what would have been pick up, my delivery driver was here! I was not expecting so soon but he was so friendly and wanted to be sure I had my food! Every single order from Sal’s… all the staff are so wonderful! Amazing kindness!“