“First time there. Arrived 15 minutes before reservation and enjoyed the bar while waiting for our party to fully arrive. Atmosphere is delightful. Bartender was personable, respectful, and funny! On to dinner, the staff was INCREDIBLE. Not a single beat missed on ensuring we had everything needed. Our host noticed both me and another guest are hard of hearing. She didn’t make a scene about it (this happens a lot), was extremely professional, and made sure we understood. Food was delicious. We all had a great time and will definitely be back.“
“I usually do take out at Sammy’s. There’s usually a great number of customers and many do take out, but the dining area is not neglected because many customers take advantage of that, too.The counter staff is always so pleasant, ready to help with orders and peppering in welcoming small talk. The wait time is phenomenal, given the large numbers of customers who are ordering.The food is delicious and well worth the prices charged. I’ve had many menu items but my favorite is their Italian Beef Combo sandwich, which is an Italian beef sausage AND loose Italian beef on an Italian bun, with or without cheese, mushrooms and peppers added.All the sandwiches I’ve had at Sammy’s are filling and I don’t have a complaint about any.“
“The food IS tasty, well made and well seasoned, but the portions are wayyyy too small for the price unfortunately. It is good if you have the money to spend, but if you're looking for quantity go elsewhere. Fazoli's breadsticks are amazing tho for real.“
“This pizza was so good!. When my gentleman friend asked me,"How did you like it?"I said, "If this is pizza, I've never really had pizza!"He also order us dreamy garlic bread, salad with their homemade Italian salad dressing and even order a container of dressing to go.“
“The staff are always busting their butts. They always get the food out quickly and it's been perfect every time. Their attitudes are pleasant and they're always personable. I know it's just a small west allis pizza spot, but I have nothing but praise for the humans that run this joint. All the little things really add up. Give your staff a raise!“
“I went to school across the street from this tiny little restaurant for 9 years, and somehow never made it here. Decades later I came back to 'Stallis, and now I wish I hadn't missed all those years! Amazing deluxe pizza, friendly service, good music on in the background, and the straws are pasta!“