9 Best Mexican Restaurants in West Allis

Restaurantji's West Allis Mexican restaurant picks are here.

Su Plus Two Fusion Cuisine Coffee & Tea • $
7335 W Greenfield Ave, West Allis

Customers` Favorites

Mediterranean Egg White Sandwich
Mediterranean Chicken Wrap
Build Your Own Omelette
Chipotle Chicken Wrap
Bang Bang Thai Wrap
Breakfast Burrito
Gem of Thai Salad
Classic Crepe
Fish Tacos
Iced Latte

“New owners still getting their feet grounded. Sort of an unusual place. Mexican and Thai food. Talked with the owner, a very nice guy. They are still experimenting with the menu choices, based on the customer preferences. We would dine again.“

4.9 Superb75 Reviews
Antigua Latin Inspired Kitchen Mexican • $$
6207 W National Ave, West Allis

Customers` Favorites

Sun Dried Tomato and Roasted Pumpkin Seed Guacamole
Chicken Mole with Plantains and Rice
Enchiladas Yucatecas
Bacon Wrapped Shrimp
Paella Valenciana
Encocao De Camaron
Cauliflower Tacos
Cochinita Pibil
Fried Plantains
Tequila Chicken

“Antigua Latin Inspired Kitchen in West Allis is a culinary gem offering exceptional food, cocktails, and service. From savory empanadas to tender carne asada, each dish celebrates Latin flavors with finesse. The cocktails, expertly crafted, add a delightful touch to the experience. The staff's warm hospitality makes every visit memorable. For a taste of Latin America in West Allis, Antigua is the place to be.“

4.7 Superb57 Reviews
The Spicy Taco Mexican • $
10535 W Greenfield Ave, West Allis

Customers` Favorites

Loaded Fries or Spicy Loaded Fries
Spicy Fried Chicken Sandwich
Taco or Spicy Taco Dinner
Jarritos Pineapple
Chimichanga Dinner
Jarritos Mandarin
Spiced Up Taco
Pastor Rolls
Enchiladas
Nachos

“First time trying this place it's a small dining area and parking can be a bit of an issue since they're in a gas station parking lot, that is rather small. The food was fabulous. I had the taco dinner which on Tuesday was $17 for three tacos, a side of beans and rice as well as a free drink. The tacos I had were two ground beef, and one shredded pork they were very tasty. Really loved the seasoning on the shredded pork. The beans with the, cheese on top were fabulous. Mexican rice was cooked just right would definitely go back. The server was very attentive. They were just a little stingy on the ice for the ice water I requested for some reason other than that everything else was fantastic.“

4.6 Superb39 Reviews
Tacos El Pastorcito Mixe Mexican • $
W Burnham St, West Allis

Customers` Favorites

Regular Nachos
Tacos Dinner

“They knew two than three. The al pastor tacos did not have much flavor. But they were $1 on Tuesdays.The tacos were ok. They didn't really have much flavor, ordered the Al pastor tacos since they were $1 a taco on Tuesday. Good filler though.“

4.6 Superb32 Reviews
Antigua Catering & Events Mexican •
6207 W National Ave, West Allis

“I wish we could give 6 stars. If you're looking for catering for a wedding, Antigua is THE place to go. My now-husband and I were easy-going about almost all of our wedding decisions, but our number 1 priorities were our venue and food. We did not want the standard dishes offered at most weddings, we wanted something that stood out and represented our love for delicious food. We saw the many awards Antigua has earned when we went for our initial tasting and, after having tried their food and hired them for our wedding, we're baffled as to how they don't have many, many more. Citlali, the owner, has won our hearts and anyone thinking about getting married in the Milwaukee area MUST check Antigua out. She made everything so simple for us, and was present on our wedding day to make sure everything ran smoothly. The staff running food and clearing plates were superb for everything from appetizers to helping to set up the dessert station. Every single person at my wedding that I spoke to after dinner raved about the food. Run, don't walk, to Antigua and hope that they aren't already booked for your wedding day.“

4.5 Superb32 Reviews
JC King’s Tortas (West Allis) Mexican •
6200 W Burnham St, West Allis

Customers` Favorites

Torta Cubana
Plantains W
Tacos

“Came here on the recommendation of a friend for our restaurant review. I had never heard of this place or their food trucks before so I was excited to give it a try. While the inside was empty, the service was stellar and I feel they probably do a lot more carry out business than sit down inside. I got the Cubano sandwich, regular sized and it was so tasty. The bread was crispy yet soft and the ingredients, especially the Mexican sausage, was fantastic! I also tried a few tacos that had good flavor but for me a little dry so I had to hit it with the salsa they provided and whoa!! It brought a nice kick of heat to it that really elevated the taco for me. I would absolutely suggest that if you in the mood for a torta, you check out JC King's!“

4.4 Superb33 Reviews
Chilango Express LLC Mexican • $
7030 W Lincoln Ave, West Allis

Customers` Favorites

Chile Relleno with Mole Sauce and a Tostada
Lengua Beef Tongue Taco
Consome Con Carne
Carne Asada Taco
Chilango Dinner
Enchilada Dinner
Refried Beans
Chips & Salsa
Huarache
Burrito

“Chilango Express has a streamlined menu of freshly prepared offerings. For point of comparison, expect it to be less greasy and more garlicky than the competition. If you want something different then order the consomme de borrego, the lamb soup, which has chickpeas, cilantro and carrots in it. I will come away from this place dreaming about their corn tortillas which are fluffy and soft, yet grilled. Clearly home made. The dining room is sunny and colorful-- the prices, friendly.“

4.2 Good69 Reviews
La Costeña Cafe / Mexican Restaurant Mexican • $
5823 W Burnham St, West Allis

Customers` Favorites

Enchiladas Suizas Verde O Roja
Milanesa Con Papas
Quesadilla Dinner
Breakfast Burrito
Nachos Supreme
Tlayuda

“We stopped in while passing just to try something new. 11:20am we ordered breakfast. I ordered the Breakfast Burrito no onion and add bacon. It wasn’t the best ever but was very good! Wife ordered La Costena Omelette no Onion which was also Very good! We will come back and try other items.Ask for the Salsa Verde“

4.2 Good23 Reviews
Taqueria El Toro Mexican • $
8322 W Lincoln Ave, West Allis

Customers` Favorites

Tacos De Carne Asada
Tacos- Mexican Style
With Choice of Meat
Quesadilla Dinner
Charola de Tacos
Chorizo Mexican
Tostada Dinner
Burrito Dinner
Taco Dinner
Tostada

“Carry out/walk-up window service only. Very good food. A little slow on service, but very friendly staff. I had one of the best chicken burritos I've ever had. And also the mango habanero chicken wings 6(sm) or 10(LG) per order. Blows B-Dubs away! They were excellent! Well worth the wait.“

4 Good89 Reviews
Loading...
map Map