13 Best Pizza Restaurants in West Allis

Capri di Nuovo Italian • $$
8340 Beloit Rd, West Allis

Customers` Favorites

Won Ton Mozzarella Stix
Spaghetti Alla Carbonara
Lasagna Garlic Bread
Appetizer Sampler
Mozzarella Sticks
Baked Mostaccioli
Stuffed Mushrooms
Chicken Parmesan
Classic Lasagna
Chicken Alfredo

“The tables are very small, barely enough room for three people when one table is supposed to seat four. Originally we were taken to one table for a party of five, it's simple math. If a table designed for four can barely fit three, then how will it work for five? I suspect the guy was lazy and just didn't want to move two tables together. Fortunately he wasn't our server. Our server was sweet and attentive.We always order the pizza, however, this time we all decided to try their pastas and we were not disappointed. Of the five of us we had salad, pesto chicken pasta, mostachioli pasta, lasagna, and alfredo. Not a single one of us had anything negative to say. I had the Alfredo without any additions. It was very creamy, I tend to add salt and pepper but this time I didn't have to. Every bite was bursting with flavor. Each normal size pasta dish comes with a whole garlic bread, and the small pasta dish comes with a half. The garlic bread was perfectly crisp, however, it could use more garlic and butter. I added parmesan cheese to compensate.Wheelchair accessibility: There is only one handicapped parking spot, but it is literally two feet from the door.“

4.5 Superb104 Reviews
Nico’s Pizza Burgers • $
9638 W National Ave, West Allis

Customers` Favorites

Pepperoni Pizza
Sausage Pizza
French Fries
Truffle Fries
Garlic Bread

“We were told about Nico’s by a neighbor so we gave this place a try. We were very pleased, our waitress was great, checked on us 4-5 times making sure everything was alright. The restaurant looks to have been remodeled and was very clean, and the pizza was loaded with toppings. A thin crust, crispy, sauce a bit in the sweet side, nice spice, fresh onions, large pepperoni, was very delicious and surely will be back.“

4.5 Superb103 Reviews
Happy Tap Bar • $
6801 Beloit Rd, West Allis

Customers` Favorites

Large Pretzel with Cheese
Italian Bomber and Chips
Garlic Bread & 16 Pizza
Cheese Garlic Bread
Meatball and Chips
Meatball Sandwich
Pizza Obviously

“Nice neighborhood bar on a corners of Beloit, Lincoln & 68th Sts. Five slots, darts and an AMI jukebox. You can shake dice while you're waiting for your food too.If you order the garlic bread, you get eight 2"x3" pieces with some pizza sauce on the side. Good. They have 12" and 16" crusts to choose from. All the toppings are extra, no meat or vegetarian specials to choose from. I got a 16" sausage, mushroom, onion and green pepper. The thin was crust crisp and the cheese, gooey. Very good. Next time I'll ask for more oregano and maybe black olives.$20 for a 16"(large)cheese, toppings on a large are $2 each. I will return. 11/21/2023“

4.3 Superb166 Reviews
Flour Girl & Flame Pizza • $$
8121 W National Ave, West Allis

Customers` Favorites

Hot Honey Buffalo Chicken Wings
Cheesy Garlic Focaccia Strips
Detroit Style Wisco Margherita
Thicc bb Cakes Brownie Serves
Wood-Fired Focaccia Strips
Detroit Style the Forager
Winter Harvest Kale Caesar
Chicken Tenders Dinner
Parmesan Garlic Wings
Egg Carton Arancini

“What a cute little shop. VERY homey, farmhouse style decor. They have one table that seats eight which they call their "Community Table," and the rest seat 2-4 people. If there is a wait for a table, they have a cozy couch area for comfort. They've really created a wonderful atmosphere.The service was outstanding. The young lady providing our service was so friendly and kind. They've cultivated such a warm ambiance that even when there was a glitch, all was right with the world. Being my usual brainless self, I have forgotten her name. I really need to start WRITING them down. I get so involved with the food that other details get pushed aside. Shame on me.Speaking of the food. SO delicious. Wednesday is their Detroit style night and the people who ordered pizza loved it. One ordered the Baddie, and two split the War & Pineapple. They are large and like me, the one who ordered her own, loves leftovers. I didn't go with pizza. I dined on two appetizers instead. The Loaded Focaccia Sticks, and the Bourbon BBQ Wings. The sticks are just amazing. They are LOADED with pepperoni. Little ones, but LOADED. They come with marinara for dipping but no need for it. The flavor is so good that I found the marinara actually detracted from the wonderful flavors already included. The wings a really meaty. No baby chickens used for these. The sauce has a little kick, but not too much. I like bleu cheese as a dipper with BBQ wings, but they only have ranch. Hang on. They have several different types of ranch - even have a flight so you can try multiples. I opted for the peppercorn and it was just a fabulous combination with the bourbon BBQ wing sauce. I only ate half of each item and brought the rest home, along with dessert: BB Cakes Brownie with a scoop of Mint Chip. Very rich. Had a few bites before bed.Can't wait to do this again for dinner tonight!Vegetarian options: They have several vegetarian options available.Parking: At 5:45pm I got the space directly out front. Our last person to arrive at 6:05pm was parked directly across the street.Kid-friendliness: I think this would be a great place for introducing kids to a more gourmet style pizza with a build your own option to include those ingredients they prefer.Wheelchair accessibility: I did not see wheelchair access as the main entrance is a set of stairs. It is located in an older build that has been remodeled for the restaurant. Now that doesn't mean they don't have another entrance that I just wasn't paying attention to. A simple phone call should answer that question for you.“

4.4 Superb89 Reviews
Paulie's Pub & Eatery Pizza • $$
8031 W Greenfield Ave, West Allis

Customers` Favorites

Italian Beef Deluxe Sandwich
Side of Potato Pancakes
Philly Cheese Steak
Mozzarella Sticks
Barnyard Burger
Home Made Chips
Western Burger
Mushroom Swiss
Chicken Wings
Nacho Supreme

“You won't be disappointed in the food, its really good. I just can't get over the beer prices.. 10 dollars for a beer is insane. 7-10 dollars for craft/local beer.. shooo. The food is worth checking out though. ??? Get the Half-Chicken if you want something fried and fantastic.“

4.3 Superb110 Reviews
Nice Sandwich Sandwich Shop • $
2705 S 108th St, West Allis

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Sandwich
BBQ Brisket
Muffuletta
Sandwiches
Beef Au Jus
Chips

“Wow! Had the ham and turkey and was remarkable. I ordered a large and after the order was in they happened to be out of the large bread, so they brought out 2 regular sandwiches (other sandwich not shown in my photo) without even asking. Please support this locally owned business. Real food.. real good. Good vibe too!“

4.4 Superb72 Reviews
Amelia's Pizzeria Pizza Takeaway •
5919 W Burnham St, West Allis

Customers` Favorites

Garlic Bread with Cheese
Pizza 16 Large Za
Pepperoni Pizza
Noah's Special
Sausage Pizza
Pizza Logs 3
Meat Lovers
The Smo

“This building has held several different mediocre pizza suppliers over the past 10 years, I was apprehensive to try the latest version. I was pleasantly surprised with the quality of the current pizza. The pizza is huge and tastes great, garlic bread is too. Our order was a bit pricey, but it was worth it. We will be back for more. Thanks for bringing a decent pizza to the neighborhood.“

4.6 Superb31 Reviews
Alphonso's | The Original Pizzeria Pizza • $
9130 W Greenfield Ave, West Allis

Customers` Favorites

Cracker Crust Pizza Sausage and Peppers Hero
World Famous Lightning Rod Mozzarella Stick
Lighting Rod Mozzarella Sticks
Thin Crust Pizza
Stuffed Pizza
Super Bee
Dillorean

“Ordered a pickup here last Saturday (3/2/24) while we were visiting some friends in the area and were so satisfied! We had the Dillorean, a Sausage Pizza and a build your own plus a lighting rod; all was delicious!! The cracker crust is so crispy, the toppings were fresh and the order was hot!“

4.2 Good82 Reviews
Fazoli's Italian • $
10833 W Greenfield Ave, West Allis

Customers` Favorites

The Cheesecake Factory Bakery Triple Chocolate Cheesecake
Cinnamon Swirl Breadstick Bites
Cheese Tortellini Alfredo Sauce
Cheesy Double-Stack Lasagna
Spaghetti with Meat Sauce
Cheese Pizza Double Slice
Chicken Broccoli Alfredo
Fettuccine with Alfredo
Spaghetti with Meatballs
House Side Salad

“The food IS tasty, well made and well seasoned, but the portions are wayyyy too small for the price unfortunately. It is good if you have the money to spend, but if you're looking for quantity go elsewhere. Fazoli's breadsticks are amazing tho for real.“

4.2 Good78 Reviews
Pepi's Pizza Pizza • $$
1329 S 70th St, West Allis

Customers` Favorites

Cheese Garlic Bread
Pepperoni Pizza
Cheese Pizza
Jumbo Shrimp
Sausage And
Wings

“Dave Portnoy come on done to Pepi's. It's an incredible pie! The crust is crisp, the undercarriage is firm with a bit of a char. The cheese is most delicious. I would like to consider myself a pizza aficionado. It probably stemmed from the fact that my mother ate nothing but pizza while pregnant with me. I'm no Dave, but believe me, we share the same brain waves when it comes to pizza. If you are looking for a great pie, stop by Pepi's and grab one or ten, but, you don't have to take my word for it!“

4.3 Superb50 Reviews
Pizzeria Scotty Pizza • $$
9022 W Oklahoma Ave, West Allis

Customers` Favorites

Stuffed Pizza with Pepperoni Mushrooms Green Pepper and Onion
Deep Fried Garlic Bread Sticks
Chicago Pan Cheese Pizza
Italian Beef Sandwich
Stuffed Cheese Pizza
Mozzarella Sticks
Breaded Mushrooms
Thin Crust Pizza
Chicken Wings

“Been going here for years... Not sure how I've never reviewed them.. weird... Anyway, pretty much my favorite pizza in the Metro area (They have the accolades to prove it)...Pizza this good takes time to make though, so be ready for a Wait when you call it in.. in six years they messed up my order once, just once.. probably a new guy or something, honest mistake... I emailed them about it.. Boom, free credit towards our inevitable next order. You have to love a company that stands by its product... Especially when it's this good... Btw, make sure to save your half off tabs on your boxes.. After 10 pizzas it's half off one... And that can be worth some good cash if you get their largest most loaded pizza ?“

4.1 Good70 Reviews
Mama Mia's Italian • $$
8533 W Greenfield Ave, West Allis

Customers` Favorites

Cheese Sausage and Pepperoni Pizza
Kids Chicken Tenders w Fries
World Famous Garlic Bread
Small Gluten Free Crust
Garlic Bread and Salad
Garlic Cheese Bread
Fettuccine Alfredo
Meatball Sandwich
Fettucini Alfredo
Chicken Parmesan

“Incredible garlic bread, as they seem to be known for. Definitely had a wow factor for the size alone, which is expanded upon by the intense garlic flavor.Mozzarella sticks are huge and breaded with garlic bread crumbles (ends of the loaf). DeliciousMy wife had the lasagna, which was everything you want...cheesy, saucy, meaty and tasty. I had the Chicken Parm over Spaghetti, which was more of the same.On top of this, we left with an entire extra entree (lasagna plus garlic bread), leftovers for at least 2 more meals, extra appetizer we didn't finish, and all for under $70 including tip.Kind of sad we didn't find this gem earlier, but I have a super high standard for Italian so I'm hesitant to try new places. Luckily, now I don't have to.“

4 Good101 Reviews
Everyone's Ice Cream Pizza •
8125 W National Ave, West Allis

“I like this place a lot. I usually get the door county cherry chocolate chip ice cream and the employees are very nice. I love that they have free lactaid for those who need it, I can actually bring my lactose intolerant friends here! They also have some good vegan options.“

4.6 Superb14 Reviews
Loading...
map Map