10 Best Pizza Restaurants in New Paltz

“Wow!! As we were waiting to be seated, two different people stopped at the pizza oven on their way out of the restaurant to compliment the chefs. One turned to us and said we're in for a treat, and the other described their meal as "so special and yummy." They were both 100% correct.The pizza was delicious!! We ordered the regular pie, didn't add any extra toppings, and it was incredible. Simple ingredients and so so tasty.The other dishes we ordered were great as well. Highly recommend getting the antipasto if you want an appetizer!! It was piled high with sliced meats and three different kinds of cheeses, all on a bed of arugula and seasoned tomato slices, PLUS a rice ball! Amazing value for the price (the picture I included was taken after I had already eaten some meat). And if you want dessert I highly recommend the housemade lemon pie, it was the perfect way to end the meal. Not too sweet and not too sour.“

“Food was insanely delicious but everyone (including , and I would say, notably, the clientele) was hauntingly unfriendly.Still would return for the pizza. Truly delectable. Sparkling apple cider was lovely too and the donuts were the best id had all year.Parking: Massive lotKid-friendliness: Tons of kids (and dogs!)Wheelchair accessibility: Relatively flat but uneven and sometimes mucky ground. Would not recommend for self wheeling unless supremely strong! ?“

“The food here is amazing! This is not just a pizza place. I had the Sir Duke sandwich and it was so good...and not on an average boring roll. My daughter's LOVE the pizza and they have a drive through window! I always ask for a slice of the stuffed meat pie. You should go inside because you will see a bunch of things not on the menu and they are delicious too!“

“We ordered a large sausage & pepper pizza and it was DELICIOUS!! VERY fresh. The sauce tasted homemade, sweet sausage slices and tender, crisp green peppers with a crunchy but not over baked crust. BEST pizza we’ve had in a long, long time! Arrived really quickly and was still quite hot. We highly recommend RINO’S!!“

“This place is open late, isn’t expensive, and is absolutely delicious. The staff is friendly, there’s a bunch of space to sit, and they completed our pick up order in 10 minutes. I have NEVER called a pizza place and been told the wait was only 10 minutes. For sure is one of the top places in new paltz for pizza. They even let you get single garlic knots, and don’t make you order them in sets, which is dope. My only complaint is that the garlic knots are literally just little rolls covered in raw garlic- im talking COVERED in raw garlic. As a garlic lover, it was even too much for me. Did I eat them all? Yes. But only after I scraped it off.“

“My friends and I visited Brooklyn Cider House on a snowy Saturday, which was lovely because we were the only ones there upon arriving. The indoor area has a good amount of seating to accommodate visitors, and there's also items for sale lining the walls including snacks, drinks, etc. We all opted for flights, but their machine had an issue processing card payments likely due to the snowstorm. We were still able to place orders and pay later on once the issue was resolved. The dry flight was okay, the sweet flight was a little better. I wanted to order a particular one on tap, but it seemed they had a very minimal selection available for those. It would be nice if there were more tap options, as that form is always the best for ciders. It's worth stopping in if you're planning on hanging around New Paltz, but I wouldn't make an entire trip there for the cidery.“

“Not only are they the best pizza in town, but they're also the classiest guys. They were able to help us out in a pinch when my payment wasn't going through and let us come back to pay it the next day. They're real stand-up folks and people like them keep the world turning. They've earned my loyalty.“

“Always the best pizza in New Paltz but also great burgers, amazing Italian dishes, tasty desserts. LaBella is great for family dinner or date night.Dietary restrictions: Delicious gluten free pizzaParking: Handicapped spaces and curb cuts for access“

“As a first timer, I definitely wouldn't call it the "best" pizza, but I'd give it a respectable 7.5/10I got the margarita pizza. The pizza was cooked well, the crust was nicely done and the toppings were nice. I did wish there was more cheese on it though, I'm used to a much thicker layer of cheeseThe soft drink offerings kind of sucked though. It's a small selection, and the Pepsi was broken at the timeOverall it was very good, but maybe just not the best“

“Have had excellent pizza here in past. Garlic knots aa good as you can get. But a real pleasant surprise was i asked if they have any sauce they sell. I took out an order of bolognese sauce. Home made and Incredibly delicious! Love the Sicilian and grandma slices. (And the beautiful owner should be in movies).“