Hands down THE best cakes! Tastes delicious. Artwork is beautiful. Price is very fair!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Birthday Cake
Billy B.
Great food and service. Love the muffins, cookies and also the take and bake casseroles.
Laura Volpicelli-Daley
I had to order breakfast for Mountain Brook Junior High Band. I unfortunately waited until the last minute. I went to a couple of other places that made doughnuts and they scoffed when I asked for the order. I then went to Magic Muffins- they were SO accommodating. They placed the order and will have it ready for me early tomorrow morning so I can bring it to the school. It has been so long since any business was this nice and helpful to me! I can't recommend them enough (I also LOVE their banana nut muffins!)
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Banana Nut Muffins
E5801
Wedding cake for my son & daughter-in-law's wedding was lovely and delicious! The ordering process was easy, and the cake came out exactly how the bride wanted it. We love everything from Magic Muffins!
Laurie R.
Best muffins and muffin tops anywhere. I highly recommend! The sandwiches are good too
Mary F.
We ordered my daughters wedding cake and groomsmen cake from Magic Muffins.Hers was Strawberry and his was Oreo/Cookie Cake. it was the first time I was at a wedding where guests were eating cake. Both were really good and I definitely would recommend.
Peyton Evans
A friend brought a Magic Muffin quiche to MahJong. Truly, a hot smooth tasty delight with a buttery crisp crust. My now go to again place for meals and other treats.Thank you Magic Muffin. You are always the best.
Bella L.
Quaint place. Good muffins. However, it would be nice if the man behind counter on a Saturday morning would be a little more friendly instead of acting annoyed that you hesitate 5 seconds in deciding what you will order. He needs to relax a bit. The customers are why you are there... Right?
Ceandra “Cece” Hill
Worst cake I have ever had. Ordered for my mom’s retirement party. The cake was not moist and was a spongy type cake. Publix is way better. Will go with what I know next time. Only sent here because someone referred them. Not again!!
Braden H.
Everything I've gotten from here is amazing. Their muffin tops, breakfast pastries, deserts, cookies, you name it. The fastest service I've ever had. It also has a great feeling of a local bakery. I hope this place never leaves cahaba heights!
Every time I've gone they have been the best there sugar cooks are very good along with their muffin. The only con was There was one time the muffin I got had walnuts and didn't know due to no signs stating may contain nuts even on the muffin card, and I'm highly allergic to walnuts. They also keep nut muffins in the same case so bewarnd if you have a nut allergy this is not the place for you. But I thankfully can still have other muffins they have my fav two are pumpkin spice and the lemon poppy seed. They also had a chocolate croissant the other day and when I eat it I heated it up for 15 secs it was to die fooor.
Matthew Conde
Wow! What a tasty cake! This was a custom cake we had done by Magic Muffins. We ordered the Italian Cream cake. The cake was dense, rich and moist after cutting into it the next day. We really appreciate the customer service that came with the cake as well! Reasonably priced for the quality you receive!
Caroline C
Magic muffins baked a bridal cake and a groom's cake for our wedding, and they were beautiful and delicious! Especially the chocolate peanut butter groomscake. Thanks!
Amanda McGrady
I hired them to do my wedding cake, and WOW! It was so delicious! They were easy to work with and we had no issues changing our idea the week of.
Sarah Huckabay
Magic Muffins created my bridal cake and groom’s desserts for my wedding and both were phenomenal. The cheesecake bites with golf ball truffles were perfect for my golf pro husband. Our almond flavored cake was beautiful, delicious, and moist. We received many compliments on both. The staff were easy to work with and the pricing was very reasonable. I’ll definitely use Magic Muffins for celebrations for many years to come!
Hands down THE best cakes! Tastes delicious. Artwork is beautiful. Price is very fair!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Birthday Cake
Great food and service. Love the muffins, cookies and also the take and bake casseroles.
I had to order breakfast for Mountain Brook Junior High Band. I unfortunately waited until the last minute. I went to a couple of other places that made doughnuts and they scoffed when I asked for the order. I then went to Magic Muffins- they were SO accommodating. They placed the order and will have it ready for me early tomorrow morning so I can bring it to the school. It has been so long since any business was this nice and helpful to me! I can't recommend them enough (I also LOVE their banana nut muffins!)
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Banana Nut Muffins
Wedding cake for my son & daughter-in-law's wedding was lovely and delicious! The ordering process was easy, and the cake came out exactly how the bride wanted it. We love everything from Magic Muffins!
Best muffins and muffin tops anywhere. I highly recommend! The sandwiches are good too
We ordered my daughters wedding cake and groomsmen cake from Magic Muffins.Hers was Strawberry and his was Oreo/Cookie Cake. it was the first time I was at a wedding where guests were eating cake. Both were really good and I definitely would recommend.
A friend brought a Magic Muffin quiche to MahJong. Truly, a hot smooth tasty delight with a buttery crisp crust. My now go to again place for meals and other treats.Thank you Magic Muffin. You are always the best.
Quaint place. Good muffins. However, it would be nice if the man behind counter on a Saturday morning would be a little more friendly instead of acting annoyed that you hesitate 5 seconds in deciding what you will order. He needs to relax a bit. The customers are why you are there... Right?
Worst cake I have ever had. Ordered for my mom’s retirement party. The cake was not moist and was a spongy type cake. Publix is way better. Will go with what I know next time. Only sent here because someone referred them. Not again!!
Everything I've gotten from here is amazing. Their muffin tops, breakfast pastries, deserts, cookies, you name it. The fastest service I've ever had. It also has a great feeling of a local bakery. I hope this place never leaves cahaba heights!
Restaurantji Recommends
Every time I've gone they have been the best there sugar cooks are very good along with their muffin. The only con was There was one time the muffin I got had walnuts and didn't know due to no signs stating may contain nuts even on the muffin card, and I'm highly allergic to walnuts. They also keep nut muffins in the same case so bewarnd if you have a nut allergy this is not the place for you. But I thankfully can still have other muffins they have my fav two are pumpkin spice and the lemon poppy seed. They also had a chocolate croissant the other day and when I eat it I heated it up for 15 secs it was to die fooor.
Wow! What a tasty cake! This was a custom cake we had done by Magic Muffins. We ordered the Italian Cream cake. The cake was dense, rich and moist after cutting into it the next day. We really appreciate the customer service that came with the cake as well! Reasonably priced for the quality you receive!
Magic muffins baked a bridal cake and a groom's cake for our wedding, and they were beautiful and delicious! Especially the chocolate peanut butter groomscake. Thanks!
I hired them to do my wedding cake, and WOW! It was so delicious! They were easy to work with and we had no issues changing our idea the week of.
Magic Muffins created my bridal cake and groom’s desserts for my wedding and both were phenomenal. The cheesecake bites with golf ball truffles were perfect for my golf pro husband. Our almond flavored cake was beautiful, delicious, and moist. We received many compliments on both. The staff were easy to work with and the pricing was very reasonable. I’ll definitely use Magic Muffins for celebrations for many years to come!