The ice cream and Italian ice here is wonderful. It was very clean and kid friendly. We will be back to try something new.Kid-friendliness: Game and art area for kids.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Italian Ice
Rose Bunger
Must come all ages. So good.Dietary restrictions: The Italian ice (no ice cream layers) is dairy free and very good. Layer up!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Medium Gelati, Green Apple and Black Cherry Italian Ice, Orange Mango Tango, Strawberry Shortcake, Birthday Cake, Oreo, Candy Bar, Small Italian Ice, PB&J, Oreo Cookie Cookie Butter, S'More, Oreo Mud Pie, Italian Ice, Mud Pie, Cake, Strawberry, Frosted Animal Cracker, Sugar Cookie, Caramel Apple, Quart Italian Ice
Shawna L.
A place that seems like it was a secret. Marketing is needed in this small...not to small town. So many cool businesses but you sometimes don't know of them. This one came about my daughter brought home a coupon from school. OMG. A must go to...pleasant clean atmosphere. The stuff they sell...not too sweet..just sheer perfection. And the name made me think all they sold was Italian ice...but..there is alot more. Please check them out TODAY. N leave a review...
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mariah D.
Visiting from out of state and loved it so much we went twice! Kid friendly, lots of flavors to choose from and customize, and the staff is friendly. Bathrooms are clean! I really appreciate when establishments have clean bathrooms. Definitely recommend.Also. Bring one to Alaska. Plz and thx!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Matt Crosslin
We love this place. We live in Florence and I first discovered this treasure of an ice cream shop. I wish we had one in our home town. If you are around this area plz stop by and do your self a favor. Can't beat Jeremiah the bullfrog!
Adri
Just had the franken frog it had froggy frog and chocolate icecream with Oreos crumble it was Soo good!! My bf loves the froggy frog flavor
Melissa Robinson
Jeremiah's has a wide variety of classic Italian Ice flavors as well as seasonal fun flavors. My favorite is to have a Gelato by combining the Ice with the ice cream. The staff is always courteous. They are happy to give free samples. The only reason for not giving 5 stars is that I feel $9 for 2 small Gelatos is a bit much.
Karen Krakus
Oh my goodness! The best ice cream I have ever tasted
Aliyah
It was AMAZING!!! I loved the Sugar Cookie one! And once I ordered I got my treat quick!
Neil Phillips
Delicious selection of Italian Ice and Gelato. Cotton Candy, salted Caramel, and Orange are all good choices!
The ice cream and Italian ice here is wonderful. It was very clean and kid friendly. We will be back to try something new.Kid-friendliness: Game and art area for kids.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Italian Ice
Must come all ages. So good.Dietary restrictions: The Italian ice (no ice cream layers) is dairy free and very good. Layer up!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Medium Gelati, Green Apple and Black Cherry Italian Ice, Orange Mango Tango, Strawberry Shortcake, Birthday Cake, Oreo, Candy Bar, Small Italian Ice, PB&J, Oreo Cookie Cookie Butter, S'More, Oreo Mud Pie, Italian Ice, Mud Pie, Cake, Strawberry, Frosted Animal Cracker, Sugar Cookie, Caramel Apple, Quart Italian Ice
A place that seems like it was a secret. Marketing is needed in this small...not to small town. So many cool businesses but you sometimes don't know of them. This one came about my daughter brought home a coupon from school. OMG. A must go to...pleasant clean atmosphere. The stuff they sell...not too sweet..just sheer perfection. And the name made me think all they sold was Italian ice...but..there is alot more. Please check them out TODAY. N leave a review...
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Visiting from out of state and loved it so much we went twice! Kid friendly, lots of flavors to choose from and customize, and the staff is friendly. Bathrooms are clean! I really appreciate when establishments have clean bathrooms. Definitely recommend.Also. Bring one to Alaska. Plz and thx!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We love this place. We live in Florence and I first discovered this treasure of an ice cream shop. I wish we had one in our home town. If you are around this area plz stop by and do your self a favor. Can't beat Jeremiah the bullfrog!
Just had the franken frog it had froggy frog and chocolate icecream with Oreos crumble it was Soo good!! My bf loves the froggy frog flavor
Jeremiah's has a wide variety of classic Italian Ice flavors as well as seasonal fun flavors. My favorite is to have a Gelato by combining the Ice with the ice cream. The staff is always courteous. They are happy to give free samples. The only reason for not giving 5 stars is that I feel $9 for 2 small Gelatos is a bit much.
Oh my goodness! The best ice cream I have ever tasted
It was AMAZING!!! I loved the Sugar Cookie one! And once I ordered I got my treat quick!
Delicious selection of Italian Ice and Gelato. Cotton Candy, salted Caramel, and Orange are all good choices!
Restaurantji Recommends
This place is a must try! Sugar cookie and Oreo mud pie are our favorites! Service was quick!
Good selection of flavors and options! Delicious ?
Unusual flavors and delicious. Very efficient service. Parking lot good. Handicap friendly.
This place is a must go. I loved it. I had the strawberry shortcake I will return flavor was awesome. Staff was welcoming.
So glad we have this in Madison. Make sure to stop by! We'll be back. My dreamsicle recipe is orange and mango with vanilla soft-serve :)