Post Office Pies

270 Rele St, Mountain Brook
(205) 848-2092

Recent Reviews

Buck Jordan

This review is specifically about the mountain brook location. I ordered a margarita pizza and was given the wrong pizza after waiting 27 minutes. I didn't have time to wait around for them to fix the error so I just has to deal with that. On top of that, the pizza i waited for wasn't even hot when it was given to me and the crust was rubbery. I usually love Post Office Pies but I always go to the one downtown. Lesson learned I guess? The staff were also stand-offish so that, on top of the sub par pizza that wasn't even what I ordered, all I can say is avoid this location and save your money.

Big GAS

I really liked the location and digs, but the food just wasn’t good. Paid $35+ for a speciality pizza and it was nothing to (pun-intended) take home about; I’ll give it a 2nd try and hopefully, it’ll be worth the time/money.

Bill Trainor

Stopped in for a quick bit and ordered the Italian. Was very tempted to finish it all but managed to find the willpower to save half for later.

Maddie S.

Pretty disappointing honestly. Ordered the caesar salad, took about 20 minutes for it to come out and when it did it was not good. Almost no dressing and over all just not good. Next came out our garlic cheese bread which was basically just a pizza. undercooked and overtopped with cheese, served with extremely watery marinara sauce. Then our pizza came out pretty much the same as the "garlic bread" way undercooked and all the toppings just slid right off when you picked it up. On top of the disappointing food everything took extremely long to come out even though it was a Monday afternoon and there were only 2 other tables seated. Not the greatest experience.

Ernest Hall

Great food, great service

Erwin Clements

Very nice restaurant in a very nice area. The staff was very friendly also.The barbeque pizza is fantastic.

large marge

We visited this location for the first time and the pizza was NOT the same as their other location. In fact it was terrible. The lady who seated us was not friendly, the guy who took the order was nice and the place was clean.We excepted better from this location, but instead we were disappointed. I'm sad to say that we will not be back.

Michelle A.

The salad was quite delicious, but the pizza left a lot to be desired. The pizza crust was very thin, the cheese was very thick, and when you picked it up or tried to bite it...all of the toppings & cheese came off. Although this is a pizza place, it's better to order a salad & a drink rather than the pizza.

Jay Frazier

Great pizza!! Highly recommend!!

Joey H.

Terrible service. Bartender sucks, we sat at the bar for at least 5 min before we were acknowledged. Came in to watch Braves game and eat. When asked to change the channel to Braves game, bartender said, "no, I'm not changing a channel. I have too much going on..." Intended to stay and eat, have a couple beers... Had my one beer and rolled out. I understand being busy. I was in the service industry myself for several years. But you figure it out... ask for help if you need it. Was the bartender the only person who knows how to change a channel? Won't be back.

Mary Margaret Gray

The best white pizza! Get one!

Bill Voigt

Post Office Pies is the gold standard in Birmingham. Their Saws BBQ edition is off the chart. All flavors are 4 or 5 stars with our family. Restaurant vibe is good too, tho we do mainly takeout bc are close.

Jan Jackson Foresee

Great gourmet pizza and fun choices at reasonable prices. Great, friendly staff

Nicole C.

Post Office Pies wasn't exactly a part of the original Sunday plans, but I'm glad it ended up to be! We stumbled across this cute eatery in the Mountain Brook area after visiting the Birmingham Botanical Gardens. It's only like 0.3 miles away and right next to Char Bar. P.O.P. Is also within walking distance of the Grand Bohemian Hotel if you ever stay there. This whole little Mountain Brook retail area where Post Office Pies is, is just a few steps away. We ate on the patio where they have a number of umbrellas available for shade, higher seating as well as traditional lounge areas and lower tables too. It wasn't too busy when we went (around 4pm) but even inside is pretty spacious if you still have any concerns with crowds and congestion. You can easily dine indoors at a table, at the bar or out on the patio. It was a gorgeous day out, and we opted for the patio. The service was great - server was masked and attentive but not overbearing. While they don't seem to require masks for entry, all staff members are wearing masks. The two of us in my party split a 12" White Pizza which was delicious, just slightly oily as expected with those cheeses. It comes with multiple white cheeses like mozzarella, Parmesan, ricotta & topped with a few basil leaves. The crust was good and must've been baked in a brick or woodfire oven. The 12" was plenty for us to share, and we even left with two slices to go. Oh and the menus are adorable....created to look like little postcards or envelopes, right in line with the restaurant brand. You may notice the regular post office is across the street but likely closed during weekend hours. For once you can find a post office open on a Sunday afternoon, and with this one serving fresh pizza pies it definitely has my stamp of approval!

James Pilman

Fast and curtious service . Food was excellent. Enjoyed the out door dinning.Will be back for sure.

Load More