I ordered a $37 ribeye. It was awful. The top was so burned (not seared), and I had to apply such force, the fork literally put a purple mark on my finger. The "sear" tasted like pure charcoal. The broccolini was raw. It had no seasoning on it. I did request mashed potatoes instead of fingerling potatoes. I assume the request was why they did nothing to correct the meal. I tried to eat it. I said no thank you to a box. I did tell my server it wasn't good. I asked to show her how difficult it was to cut. She simply replied with, "I believe you. I believe you," and took my plate. No offer of restitution of any kind. I paid and left. I will never be back.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 3
Tiffany A. Doud
We loved our dinner at Garfrericks! The drinks and the food were both excellent. We also could not have asked for better service. Would definitely recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mel Ostrander
Great food and staff. A bit pricey for me but the food was very good.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Pecan Encrusted Grouper
Annette M.
I can't recommend this restaurant enough. The food is amazing and fresh. The service is outstanding. Perfect for date night, celebrations, or just because. I've never eaten anything there that I didn't love!
Pramod K.
Excellent food with a neat and clean environment!! Will go there again whenever I am in Oxford/Anniston.
Laura Tutor
This is always our go-to for a fine meal and is probably the best place in the area for a menu that always has something wonderful and unexpected. This past week, four of us (two couples) went for a mid-week dinner.In addition to the regular winter menu, which includes fish/seafood, poultry, beef and vegetarian entrees, the specials included grilledvenison and braised rabbit. I got the venison, and a friend got the rabbit. Both were excellent and had us both so happy to come by and enjoy this variety. So good! As in, so good I’ll be back fairly soon before these dishes rotate off the menu.Food here is always excellent. Always a wonderful evening for a special occasion or just a good night out with friends. Wine selection is best in the area, and it includes access to their wine shop if you want something particular. You can also bring your own wine or champagne (which we’ve done) for a small corkage fee.Dress: Most folks are in office-casual clothing, but special occasion attire would be equally set in this atmosphere.This is not a place to take children.Vegetarian options: Pasta, whole grains, salads.Dietary restrictions: Vegetarian options. Staff very familiar within the menu and can answer questions.Wheelchair accessibility: No steps at all. All one level.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Redfish, Beet Salad
Olivia S.
Absolutely stunning restaurant and great food! I was impressed with their wine list as well. I got the chicken Marsala and loved it. The wine room looked really neat. I'd like to do a wine tasting next time I'm in town. Our waitress was wonderful! She was very attentive and knowledgeable about the menu. I forgot her name but she had Brunette hair and took care of us on 1/30/24 at 6pm in the Gallery room. I highly recommend eating in the Gallery room. It felt more private and quiet.
J. A. McGlaun
Will try this restaurant again. Very friendly staff and great food.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Barrett Coheley
Our first time there, I've heard mixed sentiments about this place. Thankfully, we tried it for ourselves , it will be a constant for us now!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Charlotte Hand
Great dinner with friends tonight. Food was good, cooked to perfection. I would have liked a bit more herbs on my pecan encrusted grouper. The hoppin' John and veggies were perfect.Creme brulee was light and delicious.Service could have been better. She handed out 3 menus for the 5 of us, then brought out 2 more. Same thing happened with the beverage list, brought 3 then 2 more later. She kept our beverages filled and asked if we needed anything at appropriate times - good.I wish that other starter dishes were offered. Crabcakes and oysters aren't appealing to some people. So m e people are lactose intolerant, eliminating the cheese board. Plenty of other starter options to consider, including soups.
1 year later! We survived another year of marriage and celebrated in the same spot. Service was fine. We started with the crab cake which was great though more crab than cake. Hubby got the ribeye entree and while he ordered it medium, received it closer to medium-rare, but it was tender, rich, and had lots of gravy. I ordered the salmon which was perfectly done and the roasted vegetables were DELICIOUS. We ended our meal with the chocolate custard split between the two of us. Another great anniversary feast!
Clarissa H.
Service is always great. The food is always wonderful and the atmosphere is relaxing. This a restaurant we keep coming back to.
Kay Moore
For our group of 9, everything was delicious! Matt was an amazing server, and the food, drinks, and desserts were phenomenal! If you haven't checked it out, you need to!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Creme Brulee
Kaitlin Bova
I was traveling on business in the area and found Garfrerick’s online after scrolling through tons of chain restaurants! This place was great- food was amazing and our server was friendly. I had the pork chop with green beans and sweet potato purée and the guys I was with had the scallops and the shrimp and grits. I have traveled a lot in the past 3 years and this will be at the top of best dinners out!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Keith A.
Amazing petite filet mignon! I highly recommend it. Great ambience, service, and food.
I ordered a $37 ribeye. It was awful. The top was so burned (not seared), and I had to apply such force, the fork literally put a purple mark on my finger. The "sear" tasted like pure charcoal. The broccolini was raw. It had no seasoning on it. I did request mashed potatoes instead of fingerling potatoes. I assume the request was why they did nothing to correct the meal. I tried to eat it. I said no thank you to a box. I did tell my server it wasn't good. I asked to show her how difficult it was to cut. She simply replied with, "I believe you. I believe you," and took my plate. No offer of restitution of any kind. I paid and left. I will never be back.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 3
We loved our dinner at Garfrericks! The drinks and the food were both excellent. We also could not have asked for better service. Would definitely recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great food and staff. A bit pricey for me but the food was very good.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Pecan Encrusted Grouper
I can't recommend this restaurant enough. The food is amazing and fresh. The service is outstanding. Perfect for date night, celebrations, or just because. I've never eaten anything there that I didn't love!
Excellent food with a neat and clean environment!! Will go there again whenever I am in Oxford/Anniston.
This is always our go-to for a fine meal and is probably the best place in the area for a menu that always has something wonderful and unexpected. This past week, four of us (two couples) went for a mid-week dinner.In addition to the regular winter menu, which includes fish/seafood, poultry, beef and vegetarian entrees, the specials included grilledvenison and braised rabbit. I got the venison, and a friend got the rabbit. Both were excellent and had us both so happy to come by and enjoy this variety. So good! As in, so good I’ll be back fairly soon before these dishes rotate off the menu.Food here is always excellent. Always a wonderful evening for a special occasion or just a good night out with friends. Wine selection is best in the area, and it includes access to their wine shop if you want something particular. You can also bring your own wine or champagne (which we’ve done) for a small corkage fee.Dress: Most folks are in office-casual clothing, but special occasion attire would be equally set in this atmosphere.This is not a place to take children.Vegetarian options: Pasta, whole grains, salads.Dietary restrictions: Vegetarian options. Staff very familiar within the menu and can answer questions.Wheelchair accessibility: No steps at all. All one level.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Redfish, Beet Salad
Absolutely stunning restaurant and great food! I was impressed with their wine list as well. I got the chicken Marsala and loved it. The wine room looked really neat. I'd like to do a wine tasting next time I'm in town. Our waitress was wonderful! She was very attentive and knowledgeable about the menu. I forgot her name but she had Brunette hair and took care of us on 1/30/24 at 6pm in the Gallery room. I highly recommend eating in the Gallery room. It felt more private and quiet.
Will try this restaurant again. Very friendly staff and great food.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Our first time there, I've heard mixed sentiments about this place. Thankfully, we tried it for ourselves , it will be a constant for us now!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great dinner with friends tonight. Food was good, cooked to perfection. I would have liked a bit more herbs on my pecan encrusted grouper. The hoppin' John and veggies were perfect.Creme brulee was light and delicious.Service could have been better. She handed out 3 menus for the 5 of us, then brought out 2 more. Same thing happened with the beverage list, brought 3 then 2 more later. She kept our beverages filled and asked if we needed anything at appropriate times - good.I wish that other starter dishes were offered. Crabcakes and oysters aren't appealing to some people. So m e people are lactose intolerant, eliminating the cheese board. Plenty of other starter options to consider, including soups.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Creme Brulee, Pecan Encrusted Grouper
Restaurantji Recommends
1 year later! We survived another year of marriage and celebrated in the same spot. Service was fine. We started with the crab cake which was great though more crab than cake. Hubby got the ribeye entree and while he ordered it medium, received it closer to medium-rare, but it was tender, rich, and had lots of gravy. I ordered the salmon which was perfectly done and the roasted vegetables were DELICIOUS. We ended our meal with the chocolate custard split between the two of us. Another great anniversary feast!
Service is always great. The food is always wonderful and the atmosphere is relaxing. This a restaurant we keep coming back to.
For our group of 9, everything was delicious! Matt was an amazing server, and the food, drinks, and desserts were phenomenal! If you haven't checked it out, you need to!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Creme Brulee
I was traveling on business in the area and found Garfrerick’s online after scrolling through tons of chain restaurants! This place was great- food was amazing and our server was friendly. I had the pork chop with green beans and sweet potato purée and the guys I was with had the scallops and the shrimp and grits. I have traveled a lot in the past 3 years and this will be at the top of best dinners out!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Amazing petite filet mignon! I highly recommend it. Great ambience, service, and food.