NYC Pizza

5400 McFarland Blvd E, Tuscaloosa
(205) 722-1047

Recent Reviews

Catherine B.

Best Pizza in Tuscaloosa!! We got our food very fast and all of our pizzas were great!! Loved the cheese pizza, it was a hit with our whole group! Kind of a hole in the wall but very good pizza!

Susan L.

Very good!!!!!!!!Best I've ever eaten. Is now my favorite and I will order often. Fast delivery.

Chase B.

Everything we've ever ordered (as a five member family), has been fantastic. I've ordered a number of calzones and a few different pizzas. My children love the cheese pizza and my wife loves the Hawaiian pizza and calzones. We have eaten here often from ordering out to DD, and they've never made a mistake on our order and they've always gotten the order ready in a reasonable amount of time. I've nothing but good things to say about this pizzeria.

Kimberly F.

Love the crust on the pizza,but the wings are a no.they looked and tasted old.fresh food is the key to good business for this restaurant.it has the potential to be good based of the pizza

Courtney M.

This place was way overpriced and just not good. The pizza was like cardboard. The large pizza was not very large. The wings just ok. Over $90 for a large cheese pizza, 24 wings, a small gluten free pizza and a green salad.

Will C.

I've ordered pizza twice from here before. Both times the pizza was undercooked and inedible. Will not be ordering again.

Adam McDowell

I recently started working in the area so I stay in a hotel and pizza is a convenient solution for dinner. I have read some of these reviews and people just don't make any sense. This place is a treasure and it's constantly delicious!!

Tim F.

Delicious pizza and calzones and probably the best garlic knots you can buy always a go to for the busy week nights I will never eat pizza from anywhere else again

Special K L.

Great pizza and fast delivery service. Hubby thought 12" wasn't enough but it was. Didn't care for the garlic butter spice but pizza and service was better than expected.

Amber Edens

Extremely disappointing wings. Super dry, no flavor, very little sauce. Pizza was great.

Jamie B.

The other reviewers weren't kidding when they said this was good pizza. I ordered a small chicken Alfredo pizza for myself and a pepperoni and sausage for my son. My son immediately stated it was good pizza. After one bite of mine, I agreed. Decent delivery time for a Saturday night, especially since hotels are booked from people trying to get away from Hurricane Ida.

Heidi M.

We ordered a built your own pizza from Broadway Pizza to be delivered to our hotel when we stopped here mid way through a long road trip. The front desk clerk suggested this place when we asked for a GOOD pizza recommendation. It did not disappoint! The pizza was delivered much quicker than expected, was hot and delicious. The delivery driver was very friendly too. We got the medium size pizza and had enough leftovers to munch on through the night and then some. Wish we had one of these in our hometown!

Kimberly W.

Best pizza in Tuscaloosa! i highly recommend! My favorite pizza by far! only place i order from! always delivered hot! & veggies delicious!

Helmut E.

While travelling back to New Orleans, we were looking for some quick pizza and then get back on the road. They are located in the same building as a gas station / convenience store so we didn't know what to expect. Since they had good reviews, we decided to try it. We were pleasantly surprised. Pizza came quickly and was hot and delicious.

Star H.

This food. Holy s**** The Buffalo Knots are the best thing I have ever put in my mouth. Absolute foodgasm. The dough is.. wow. The ranch, oof. I have eaten here twice in one week and I will continue to eat here forever.

Load More