Great food and service. The lunch special is my favorite. 2 pieces of pizza and a drink. Reasonable prices
Pamela Rogowski
Great pizza- best in T
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Detroit Style Pepperoni Pizza
Paul Taper
First time customer. Got the 20 inch pepperoni and the 12 inch Mama Mia. In the photo you can get an idea of the difference between a 12 inch and a 20 inch pizza by the boxes. Sorry I was too busy eating to post pictures of the actual picture.The 20 inch pizza was all you could hope for in a New York style crust. It folded well and had a good chew. IYKYK!! Even better it passed the late night or breakfast cold pizza test by not getting soggy and the crust still retaining its integrity. Also reheated well(375 for 8 min got everything warm without over crisping the crust). The 12 was fine but wasn't as tasty as I was expecting with the garlic confit. But that could just be me.Yes the price seems expensive but just from the 20 inch we got 5 meals, Dinner and lunch for 2 plus breakfast for 1, out of it. Making the cost about 8 dollars a meal. Which is less than you pay for a hamburger combo at your favorite fast food restaurant.I didn't put anything for the atmosphere because I was there at 330 in the afternoon, on a Thursday, and I was the only one there. But the staff were nice and tried to explain to me the size of the 20 inch pizza. I wouldn't say they failed as much as I would say I failed to truly understand.Best Pizza I have eaten in Tuscaloosa. Next time I am going to try the Sicilian style crust! Only recommendation I would have is that they display the pie pans so customers would get a true understanding of the size of the pizzas.?Parking: Seem to be a good number of spaces. Just be careful of the grade to the road on the entrance and exit.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: 20 in New York Style Cheese Pizza
Lulu Chen
I had read and heard great things about this place so I came in with pretty high expectations. Fell short of expectations for me, just so disappointed after tasting. The flavors were not there and the ratio of topping to crust felt off. Very greasy results, and not in a good way. The most disappointing thing was the dough was underbaked. From the outside and edge, it looks fine, but 1/3 of the way in, the dough is still clear and not baked through properly. Sigh.Saving grace was the Tiramisu, no complaints about that. Tiramisu was wonderful.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 4
Steven Murphy
I hate to leave a 3 but I feel it's necessary.First, it was very loud and quite warm.Second, they advertise as pizza and "pasta" but there is a single pasta dish and its an appetizer....Third, the actual pizza was very good. The rest is what knocks it down so far.Value also isn't good.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 5
Service: 4
Candy Washington W.
I ordered a 20-inch cheese pizza with extra cheese. The pizza was good but greasy. This NY-style pizza had approximately eight slices. I was hungry and ate a slice when I got in the car.
Steph Kehrer
Being from NY this is by far the most similar to a real NY pizza I have found. We dined in and it was a pleasant experience. Wait staff was great! There is a bar inside also with a variety of
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Thomas Keys
Pretty solid pizza. I prefer a thicker crust and a different style sauce. Overall it was good quality
Michael van den Eijnden
Delicious pizza, with a really good crust. I'd say the best in Tuscaloosa.Wheelchair accessibility: There is one handicap spot, with a wheelchair ramp, but the paving is a bit uneven.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sicilian Pizza, Tiramisu for Two
Charles Fowler
Best pizza in townParking: Park at the front door
Recommended dishes: Mama Mia Pizza, Pistachio Cheesecake
Let me preface this by saying that: I. I (the guy) do not enjoy pizza. I really don't care for pizza unless it has apples, cinnamon, and sugar on it. AND II. I've been to Sicily and Rome and I know fresh pizza! So here's how we ended up here: After me and my wonderful grudgingly watched a terrible "comedy" movie about pizza on Tubi (we know ), we had a craving for pizza! We searched around and found this place that had pretty high ratings already so we went. The place was packed and had a fresh pizzeria odor in it (already a plus). The hostess asked if we'd like to dine at the bar since there was only us two and we agreed. As soon as we sat down, our waiter (sorry I forgot his name but I'll edit it when I find the receipt) was attentive, considerate, and overall ON IT! Our waiter asked if we'd like to start off with any drinks as they had a $2 off special going on. uh, sí señor. I (Jaguar) had a lemon drop martini while my wonderful had a mule. Yes, they were delicious but what made them great was this one simple thing most restaurants fail to do consistently: they put an adequate amount of alcohol in it! More alcohol = more happy patron = more of our mulah going into patronizer's pockets, so thanks for the great drinks! We started with an appetizer of the fried ravioli and it's the greatest fried ravioli we've ever had in our short lives. The marinara sauce was FRESH. We then ordered our pizzas and they came out picture perfect and with perfect flavor and fresh crust. Anyway I'm about to eat the leftovers (I stole her's) and go to bed happy. We will be back!
RobMofATiM
The service was awesome, but the pizza was average. It really didn’t live up to the hype of Trip Advisor or others who had told me about this place. I’d go back to try again, but there are other pizza options that I’ll try first.
Jace R
We had pizza at TuscNY and it’s the best pizza we have ever tried. I have had pizza in New York and even Italy. I even went to the back and the cook looks Italian. Highly recommend! I will be driving 4 hours to come back!!!!
Jason H.
The BEST Pizza in Tuscaloosa... Hands Down. Regular crust is awesome and the Sicilian crust is a must try! Always great service from Lauren as well.
Il-Gyu Cho
Cool pizza joint to grab one of the best pizzas in town. Lot of different options including different types of pizza. Definitely liked the New York style pizza, but others are good as well. Make sure to grab desserts afterwards as well. Definitely will be back to have more.
Great food and service. The lunch special is my favorite. 2 pieces of pizza and a drink. Reasonable prices
Great pizza- best in T
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Detroit Style Pepperoni Pizza
First time customer. Got the 20 inch pepperoni and the 12 inch Mama Mia. In the photo you can get an idea of the difference between a 12 inch and a 20 inch pizza by the boxes. Sorry I was too busy eating to post pictures of the actual picture.The 20 inch pizza was all you could hope for in a New York style crust. It folded well and had a good chew. IYKYK!! Even better it passed the late night or breakfast cold pizza test by not getting soggy and the crust still retaining its integrity. Also reheated well(375 for 8 min got everything warm without over crisping the crust). The 12 was fine but wasn't as tasty as I was expecting with the garlic confit. But that could just be me.Yes the price seems expensive but just from the 20 inch we got 5 meals, Dinner and lunch for 2 plus breakfast for 1, out of it. Making the cost about 8 dollars a meal. Which is less than you pay for a hamburger combo at your favorite fast food restaurant.I didn't put anything for the atmosphere because I was there at 330 in the afternoon, on a Thursday, and I was the only one there. But the staff were nice and tried to explain to me the size of the 20 inch pizza. I wouldn't say they failed as much as I would say I failed to truly understand.Best Pizza I have eaten in Tuscaloosa. Next time I am going to try the Sicilian style crust! Only recommendation I would have is that they display the pie pans so customers would get a true understanding of the size of the pizzas.?Parking: Seem to be a good number of spaces. Just be careful of the grade to the road on the entrance and exit.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: 20 in New York Style Cheese Pizza
I had read and heard great things about this place so I came in with pretty high expectations. Fell short of expectations for me, just so disappointed after tasting. The flavors were not there and the ratio of topping to crust felt off. Very greasy results, and not in a good way. The most disappointing thing was the dough was underbaked. From the outside and edge, it looks fine, but 1/3 of the way in, the dough is still clear and not baked through properly. Sigh.Saving grace was the Tiramisu, no complaints about that. Tiramisu was wonderful.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 4
I hate to leave a 3 but I feel it's necessary.First, it was very loud and quite warm.Second, they advertise as pizza and "pasta" but there is a single pasta dish and its an appetizer....Third, the actual pizza was very good. The rest is what knocks it down so far.Value also isn't good.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 5
Service: 4
I ordered a 20-inch cheese pizza with extra cheese. The pizza was good but greasy. This NY-style pizza had approximately eight slices. I was hungry and ate a slice when I got in the car.
Being from NY this is by far the most similar to a real NY pizza I have found. We dined in and it was a pleasant experience. Wait staff was great! There is a bar inside also with a variety of
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Pretty solid pizza. I prefer a thicker crust and a different style sauce. Overall it was good quality
Delicious pizza, with a really good crust. I'd say the best in Tuscaloosa.Wheelchair accessibility: There is one handicap spot, with a wheelchair ramp, but the paving is a bit uneven.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sicilian Pizza, Tiramisu for Two
Best pizza in townParking: Park at the front door
Recommended dishes: Mama Mia Pizza, Pistachio Cheesecake
Restaurantji Recommends
Let me preface this by saying that: I. I (the guy) do not enjoy pizza. I really don't care for pizza unless it has apples, cinnamon, and sugar on it. AND II. I've been to Sicily and Rome and I know fresh pizza! So here's how we ended up here: After me and my wonderful grudgingly watched a terrible "comedy" movie about pizza on Tubi (we know ), we had a craving for pizza! We searched around and found this place that had pretty high ratings already so we went. The place was packed and had a fresh pizzeria odor in it (already a plus). The hostess asked if we'd like to dine at the bar since there was only us two and we agreed. As soon as we sat down, our waiter (sorry I forgot his name but I'll edit it when I find the receipt) was attentive, considerate, and overall ON IT! Our waiter asked if we'd like to start off with any drinks as they had a $2 off special going on. uh, sí señor. I (Jaguar) had a lemon drop martini while my wonderful had a mule. Yes, they were delicious but what made them great was this one simple thing most restaurants fail to do consistently: they put an adequate amount of alcohol in it! More alcohol = more happy patron = more of our mulah going into patronizer's pockets, so thanks for the great drinks! We started with an appetizer of the fried ravioli and it's the greatest fried ravioli we've ever had in our short lives. The marinara sauce was FRESH. We then ordered our pizzas and they came out picture perfect and with perfect flavor and fresh crust. Anyway I'm about to eat the leftovers (I stole her's) and go to bed happy. We will be back!
The service was awesome, but the pizza was average. It really didn’t live up to the hype of Trip Advisor or others who had told me about this place. I’d go back to try again, but there are other pizza options that I’ll try first.
We had pizza at TuscNY and it’s the best pizza we have ever tried. I have had pizza in New York and even Italy. I even went to the back and the cook looks Italian. Highly recommend! I will be driving 4 hours to come back!!!!
The BEST Pizza in Tuscaloosa... Hands Down. Regular crust is awesome and the Sicilian crust is a must try! Always great service from Lauren as well.
Cool pizza joint to grab one of the best pizzas in town. Lot of different options including different types of pizza. Definitely liked the New York style pizza, but others are good as well. Make sure to grab desserts afterwards as well. Definitely will be back to have more.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5