Would’ve been a 5 star review if the man working hadn’t added an almost $8 tip after I paid unbeknownst to me… Good food, but sketchy practices.
Jessica Moore
Follow our foodie adventures on @wildformoore???? ??? ????? ???? ? ? My favorite love triangle!!? My husband and I wanted just one singular slice of pizza one day, (that was thin crust!) and the pizza gods answered.? We just happen to be strollin’ by the at @bentonvilledive and discovered @slicepizzanwa. This delicious pizza can be served literally by the slice! With it being in the heart of downtown Bentonville this location is a perfect place to kick your feet back, grab a cold one, and enjoy the good ol’ outdoors. We both got pepperoni sausage because that was because that is our main staple when it comes to pizza and OH MY GOSH! Amazin’? I also found out upon walking up that they have gluten-free bread as well., You can also get whole pizzas if you’re up for it.? Also fun fact: Owned and operated by Dave and Jenny Marr, the couple behind the HGTV show "Fixer to Fabulous”.? What’s your favorite pizza? Tell us in the comments below. ✨?: @wildformoore#Pizza #TheSliceNWA #NWA #Gluten-free #Bread #BentonvilleAR #Sauce #italianfood #BentonvilleArkansas #Pepperoni #Sausage #Cheese #Sauce #Crust #Za #Foodie #HGTV #FixerToFabulous #Arkansas #ARAmbassador #FindingNWA #wildformoore
Eleonora Pagano
EhhhThis place was really awesome when they first opened albeit a very rude owner/order taker.The pizza was fresh and frankly delicious.Now it’s potentially worse than frozen CPK…I’ll take chain pizza any day of the week.Need to keep up the consistency!!!
Danielle Keller
Favorite Pizza in NWA! I love the Bianca and Hawaiian the best! The crust is so delicious and the slices are huge! I also LOVE their calzones!
Jonathan Eidson
Great pizza and very good atmosphere. One of the best slices that I’ve had.
Scott
I found this place online with great reviews which is what brought me here. Since their online ordering system is turned off with no phone number to reach them, I had driven here and asked for an estimate on about how long it would be for 2 pies to be ready. The man behind the counter responded with a nasty attitude saying what are you in a hurry or something? I asked nicely and didn't deserve this attitude. He could have been having a bad day so I let it go. He did tell me later to expect it to be about 30 minutes and that he would call me when it's ready. Guess what, I waited an hour with no phone call before I went back to the truck to check on the progress and the pies had been done for nearly 30 minutes, just sitting there. I guess I angered the man working here with my offensive time estimate question that he 'forgot' to call his customer to tell them their food is ready. This was the worst experience I had ever witnessed with ordering pizza. I can't believe I'm saying this but I would have rather gone to a big chain like pizza hut instead of supporting this local business. I hope they improve.
Katie Lind
Flavor and quality was good, but at $6/slice or $32/pie the prices are outrageous. We ordered 2 slices and two cans of soda and it came to $16.
Jonah Wilcox
Might be the best pizza in all of NWA. Only a handful of other places even compare. Please check these guys out they deserve all the business they can get!
Kyle Doney
Not crispy, not hot, just ok. Clerk was rude. Wouldn’t get another slice there. Good vibe at the spot brings me in at 3.
H C.
Mist have gone on a bad day. 2 of our slices were undercooked. Was like gas station pizza but for $6 a slice.
This place is hard to figure out. Today there were four people in line and the guy yells out the window in a frustrated voice that it is Sunday and is going to be at least 30 minutes. 30 minutes to heat up some pre-cooked pizza...
Alan Nash
Im visiting from Ft Lauderdale and I visit NY frequently. This is the closest NY pizza I have had in a long time. Definitely worth it.
Stephanie York Murphy
Best pizza around! Highly recommend!
Susan T.
As a native born and raised New Yorker, the NYC cheese slice here is the closest I've found in all of Arkansas that tastes as amazing as a Brooklyn cheese slice. The cheese is so gooey and stretchy. Crust is crunchy.
Avinash B.
When we moved here from the NY/NJ area 10 years ago, I never thought I'd have NY style pizza locally. Now Slice shows up and . Such good NY style pizzeria pizza! I hope this business is around for years to come.
Would’ve been a 5 star review if the man working hadn’t added an almost $8 tip after I paid unbeknownst to me… Good food, but sketchy practices.
Follow our foodie adventures on @wildformoore???? ??? ????? ???? ? ? My favorite love triangle!!? My husband and I wanted just one singular slice of pizza one day, (that was thin crust!) and the pizza gods answered.? We just happen to be strollin’ by the at @bentonvilledive and discovered @slicepizzanwa. This delicious pizza can be served literally by the slice! With it being in the heart of downtown Bentonville this location is a perfect place to kick your feet back, grab a cold one, and enjoy the good ol’ outdoors. We both got pepperoni sausage because that was because that is our main staple when it comes to pizza and OH MY GOSH! Amazin’? I also found out upon walking up that they have gluten-free bread as well., You can also get whole pizzas if you’re up for it.? Also fun fact: Owned and operated by Dave and Jenny Marr, the couple behind the HGTV show "Fixer to Fabulous”.? What’s your favorite pizza? Tell us in the comments below. ✨?: @wildformoore#Pizza #TheSliceNWA #NWA #Gluten-free #Bread #BentonvilleAR #Sauce #italianfood #BentonvilleArkansas #Pepperoni #Sausage #Cheese #Sauce #Crust #Za #Foodie #HGTV #FixerToFabulous #Arkansas #ARAmbassador #FindingNWA #wildformoore
EhhhThis place was really awesome when they first opened albeit a very rude owner/order taker.The pizza was fresh and frankly delicious.Now it’s potentially worse than frozen CPK…I’ll take chain pizza any day of the week.Need to keep up the consistency!!!
Favorite Pizza in NWA! I love the Bianca and Hawaiian the best! The crust is so delicious and the slices are huge! I also LOVE their calzones!
Great pizza and very good atmosphere. One of the best slices that I’ve had.
I found this place online with great reviews which is what brought me here. Since their online ordering system is turned off with no phone number to reach them, I had driven here and asked for an estimate on about how long it would be for 2 pies to be ready. The man behind the counter responded with a nasty attitude saying what are you in a hurry or something? I asked nicely and didn't deserve this attitude. He could have been having a bad day so I let it go. He did tell me later to expect it to be about 30 minutes and that he would call me when it's ready. Guess what, I waited an hour with no phone call before I went back to the truck to check on the progress and the pies had been done for nearly 30 minutes, just sitting there. I guess I angered the man working here with my offensive time estimate question that he 'forgot' to call his customer to tell them their food is ready. This was the worst experience I had ever witnessed with ordering pizza. I can't believe I'm saying this but I would have rather gone to a big chain like pizza hut instead of supporting this local business. I hope they improve.
Flavor and quality was good, but at $6/slice or $32/pie the prices are outrageous. We ordered 2 slices and two cans of soda and it came to $16.
Might be the best pizza in all of NWA. Only a handful of other places even compare. Please check these guys out they deserve all the business they can get!
Not crispy, not hot, just ok. Clerk was rude. Wouldn’t get another slice there. Good vibe at the spot brings me in at 3.
Mist have gone on a bad day. 2 of our slices were undercooked. Was like gas station pizza but for $6 a slice.
Restaurantji Recommends
This place is hard to figure out. Today there were four people in line and the guy yells out the window in a frustrated voice that it is Sunday and is going to be at least 30 minutes. 30 minutes to heat up some pre-cooked pizza...
Im visiting from Ft Lauderdale and I visit NY frequently. This is the closest NY pizza I have had in a long time. Definitely worth it.
Best pizza around! Highly recommend!
As a native born and raised New Yorker, the NYC cheese slice here is the closest I've found in all of Arkansas that tastes as amazing as a Brooklyn cheese slice. The cheese is so gooey and stretchy. Crust is crunchy.
When we moved here from the NY/NJ area 10 years ago, I never thought I'd have NY style pizza locally. Now Slice shows up and . Such good NY style pizzeria pizza! I hope this business is around for years to come.