10 Best Pizza Restaurants near Elkins

“We just had our first experience with Simple Simons and have found a new favorite place. The food is fresh and everything tastes so good! The employees are so kind and always working so the place is extremely clean. Definitely give them a try!“

“Make the following passage more concise : The Maui Wowie pizza from Mellow Mushroom delivers a delightful burst of flavors that transport your taste buds to a tropical paradise. With its harmonious blend of tangy pineapple, savory ham, and zesty barbecue sauce, each bite is a symphony of sweet and savory goodness. The crust is perfectly baked to achieve that ideal balance between chewy and crispy, providing a satisfying foundation for the flavorful toppings.However, despite the culinary delight, the service at the bar left much to be desired. The lackluster attention from the bartender compelled me to bypass them entirely and approach the girls at the register to place my order to go. This disconnect between the quality of the food and the service detracted slightly from the overall experience.Nevertheless, the psychedelic atmosphere of Mellow Mushroom remains a standout feature, adding an extra dimension to the dining experience. The vibrant colors, whimsical décor, and laid-back ambiance contribute to the restaurant's unique charm, making it a favorite haunt for those seeking a dose of eccentricity with their meal.While the Maui Wowie pizza undoubtedly satisfies the palate with its delicious combination of flavors, improvements in service could elevate the overall dining experience at Mellow Mushroom. Yet, its quirky atmosphere ensures a memorable visit nonetheless.P. S. Corporate... Bring back the jerk chicken hoagie. It was the best thing on the menu for years. Not the remake that came along later, but the original.“

“Loved this place! Was right across from our little hotel so made for a convenient walk to lunch. Awesome draft and cocktail selection. Good food. The staff were all great as well as the manager. Really nice outdoor patio too for when the weather warms up ? Would definitely recommend to anyone in the “

“I have had both good and bad experiences at any place of games and kid gatherings. However the staff was amazing, help was in plentiful and they made it worth it. Grateful and for that will return with my kid. ?Parking: Really, there is amazing parking due to the size!Kid-friendliness: Games and prizes and the staff make it worth it.Wheelchair accessibility: Easy“

“This is a classic pizza joint. I’m a lifelong Fayetteville resident, but am new to living on the east side. Note that this restaurant is under different ownership than Tiny Tim’s on the square, which is a place I had given up on years ago.The environment feels very welcoming on the inside and I was pleased that there was no blasting music or television (there are televisions but they were set either on silent or low volume). Service was friendly and prompt, and the beer was served in a chilled mug!The prices are excellent. We ordered a large (which was ACTUALLY large!) pizza for 20 dollars; this is a great deal considering that the “better ready” Eureka Pizzas these days cost $10. The pizza was delicious.I will definitely be returning regularly!“

“This place has been my go-to pizza place since I was about ten years old. I might be a bit biased because my parents were managers, and this was my first job! It's a walk down memory lane every time I get to order here with my babies,vwjo is now nine and two. The food has always been fantastic because the dough is handmade, and the make table is always prepped with fresh veggies. The cheese sticks are the best because of the real cheese and garlic! Also, the pickles are the best in town, I know, a bit odd, but when you order a sandwich, you must always order extra! So salty and yes, yummy vinegar. It's a great family owned business. Comparing it to big chained pizza places is impossible. They will always fall short. Prices are absolutely spot on, especially for a quick pick up or just to spoil yourself.“

“The pizza is so good, we got 2 minis (Hog Wild and Hot Chick) and cheesy breadsticks, which came out at $20. Super affordable! It was right on time and the man working there was very friendly. The building (despite being in a gas station which scared me at first) was actually super cute and clean. We'll be back for sure!“

“This review is for the Eastside location. I came in from Alexandria VA to visit family. The service and the food was great. I had the pizza dip, and OMG, wonderful. Everyone else says it's the best pizza they had in a long time. I'm hoping next time I'm visiting family, we can come back.“

“Good price for pizza. It's not as good as Pizza Hut but is better than Domino's and some other pizza places. This is a buffet style pizza joint, so there are many options to choose from. If you can't find what you want on the buffet, simply put in a request and you'll have what you want in just a few short minutes. I would say that they need to add a few more deep pan options and add more cheese, cause and other toppings to them!“

“I have ordered twice now to have food delivered and both times the order was messed up. First they forgot the sandwich sauce and the 2nd time they forgot the main item the pizza. The first time I let it go and this time I called to try and get the pizza delivered. I spoke with GM Joseph and all he did was blame it on he delivery service. I PAID YOU for my order not the delivery service and you are responsible for making sure everything is in my order. You try to act like you're doing me a favor by making a fresh pizza. Sir there is no pizza you are just now making it. At the very least you should've reimbursed me for the pizza. If I pay you for my food YOU are RESPONSIBLE to make sure I get my food and that all of the order is picked up. After reading all of the comments I should've known that you have a problem with customer service. I pray people read this and stop coming to your restaurant until it is under better management. TAKE RESPONSIBLTY AND STOP BLAMING A DELIVERY SERVICE.“