6 oz steak tough,but tasty. Luke warm bake potatoe. Wife chicken, hoe hum. Extremely slow service, even with minimal customers. Over hour and 20 minutes! Will try Texas roadhouse next time in town.
Nancy Root
This Colton’s location is poor. Food was very OK. The place was dirty. Hopefully I have attached a photo of a ceiling fan near our table. Service poor. I ordered a second glass of wine when my food arrived…..my meal was finished when it arrived. The restaurant was totally NOT busy. That being said, the Mountain Home, Arkansas location is very good.
Mike M.
Colton's in Fayettville is a nice choice for a good steak. I recently went through major weight loss and can only eat small amounts of lean meat and veggies. I ordered the Kids portion of steak tips. The meat was very tender and seasoned well. The veggies were fresh and steamed just enough. I highly recommend them for a good satisfying meal for everything from chicken to steak or salmon. Have a Yelptastic day!!
Amanda Chaffin
Got a to go salad first off didn't even fill Togo box plus they didn't have all toppings for salad and salad was 14 dollars. Not enough dressing and charged me for extra.. Then while I'm waiting. Mind you they are not busy and I called this order in 30 min ago. There are roaches by to go area and bathrooms.. waste of time and money. Definitely going down hill quickly.. when asked for manager was told she isn't here doesn't work on Mondays.. so no managers on mondays??
Ramona Olson
HORRIBLE ServiceWas about to walk out just waiting on someone yo show up at the front yo seat us. Should have took the warning. After getting seated, rolls, drinks, appetizer arrives.. still waiting on silverware. Asked and waitress pops off "yeah that might be useful" then she goes to another table visiting, joking and picking stuff up off the floor with her bare hands. By the time we got up to walk out she came back, still no silverware, I asked about it again and she informed me the silverware wasn't her problem. SERIOUSLY??? Now we know why the parking lot was empty!
Shirley Ann
Our food was cold and we had to wait 45 minutes for our food. My food was brought out almost 10 minutes after after the rest of the table. very subpar. We will not go back
Alexander Solomon
It was my first time at this restaurant, the service was great and friendly, even though they were short staffed and did have a notice on the door. So that was really good knowing beforehand. The food was really good.
Peyton G.
Server and manager were super nice and it was most definitely not her fault, but we ordered the sirloin tips and they came out gray. They offered to recook them and they looked the exact same. The manager came over and stayed that it was due to them soaking in a marinade for days and it's just what they looked like, but still did not feel comfortable eating them and ended up getting something else. They were super nice about it though.
Charlene Starr
Our waitress (Kasey Jo I think) was phenomenal. We went after the U of A game so they were busy but she was super attentive and got us everything we needed. The food was good and the beer was cold!!!
Gail Chitwood
Don't eat here, could be hazardous to your health, got half way through my salad and found a piece of raw chicken. Pray I don't get salmonella ? I will not be back!
Service was good. The food to me was not great The nachos was overcooked, the steak had a lot of fat in it and didn't have any taste. The rolls with butter and honey was great!
Stacie P.
The bread was good but the beef apparently had turned brown during extended storage or maybe spoiled, had a terrible off-odor and was sent back but I ended up with the same batch of beef... Absolutely terrible!
charlenes2014
We stopped here after a UofA game and after having stopped at several other restaurants that were on hour long waits. They were able to seat 8 of us immediately. Our waitress KJ was AMAZING!!! She took great care of us. Everyone at our table enjoyed the food and rolls. The beer was super cold too!!!
rachel tabash
Not to be rude:((( I really am NOT this person! We read the reviews and still decided to come here. Please do not waste the money! They were out of salads and baked potatoes!!! This was fine.. we ordered something else… the steaks came out cooked wrong and just so fatty!! The server was very sweet but please don’t waste the money! This was such a bad experience…
Shannon Marise
For it being delivered to me it was so hot and fresh I couldn't believe it! One of the best steaks I've had in a long time. And they were quite prompt also. Definitely will be ordering again, if not returning in person.
6 oz steak tough,but tasty. Luke warm bake potatoe. Wife chicken, hoe hum. Extremely slow service, even with minimal customers. Over hour and 20 minutes! Will try Texas roadhouse next time in town.
This Colton’s location is poor. Food was very OK. The place was dirty. Hopefully I have attached a photo of a ceiling fan near our table. Service poor. I ordered a second glass of wine when my food arrived…..my meal was finished when it arrived. The restaurant was totally NOT busy. That being said, the Mountain Home, Arkansas location is very good.
Colton's in Fayettville is a nice choice for a good steak. I recently went through major weight loss and can only eat small amounts of lean meat and veggies. I ordered the Kids portion of steak tips. The meat was very tender and seasoned well. The veggies were fresh and steamed just enough. I highly recommend them for a good satisfying meal for everything from chicken to steak or salmon. Have a Yelptastic day!!
Got a to go salad first off didn't even fill Togo box plus they didn't have all toppings for salad and salad was 14 dollars. Not enough dressing and charged me for extra.. Then while I'm waiting. Mind you they are not busy and I called this order in 30 min ago. There are roaches by to go area and bathrooms.. waste of time and money. Definitely going down hill quickly.. when asked for manager was told she isn't here doesn't work on Mondays.. so no managers on mondays??
HORRIBLE ServiceWas about to walk out just waiting on someone yo show up at the front yo seat us. Should have took the warning. After getting seated, rolls, drinks, appetizer arrives.. still waiting on silverware. Asked and waitress pops off "yeah that might be useful" then she goes to another table visiting, joking and picking stuff up off the floor with her bare hands. By the time we got up to walk out she came back, still no silverware, I asked about it again and she informed me the silverware wasn't her problem. SERIOUSLY??? Now we know why the parking lot was empty!
Our food was cold and we had to wait 45 minutes for our food. My food was brought out almost 10 minutes after after the rest of the table. very subpar. We will not go back
It was my first time at this restaurant, the service was great and friendly, even though they were short staffed and did have a notice on the door. So that was really good knowing beforehand. The food was really good.
Server and manager were super nice and it was most definitely not her fault, but we ordered the sirloin tips and they came out gray. They offered to recook them and they looked the exact same. The manager came over and stayed that it was due to them soaking in a marinade for days and it's just what they looked like, but still did not feel comfortable eating them and ended up getting something else. They were super nice about it though.
Our waitress (Kasey Jo I think) was phenomenal. We went after the U of A game so they were busy but she was super attentive and got us everything we needed. The food was good and the beer was cold!!!
Don't eat here, could be hazardous to your health, got half way through my salad and found a piece of raw chicken. Pray I don't get salmonella ? I will not be back!
Restaurantji Recommends
Service was good. The food to me was not great The nachos was overcooked, the steak had a lot of fat in it and didn't have any taste. The rolls with butter and honey was great!
The bread was good but the beef apparently had turned brown during extended storage or maybe spoiled, had a terrible off-odor and was sent back but I ended up with the same batch of beef... Absolutely terrible!
We stopped here after a UofA game and after having stopped at several other restaurants that were on hour long waits. They were able to seat 8 of us immediately. Our waitress KJ was AMAZING!!! She took great care of us. Everyone at our table enjoyed the food and rolls. The beer was super cold too!!!
Not to be rude:((( I really am NOT this person! We read the reviews and still decided to come here. Please do not waste the money! They were out of salads and baked potatoes!!! This was fine.. we ordered something else… the steaks came out cooked wrong and just so fatty!! The server was very sweet but please don’t waste the money! This was such a bad experience…
For it being delivered to me it was so hot and fresh I couldn't believe it! One of the best steaks I've had in a long time. And they were quite prompt also. Definitely will be ordering again, if not returning in person.