Emma is the coolest bartender! Her drinks are amazing and she is great at customer service. I will be coming back to experience the amazing drink chemistry behind her mixology!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jen Dragon
My friend and I ordered pizza from Tony’s and were sorely disappointed. My cauliflower crust pizza came on regular crust, which could’ve been awful for someone who requires gluten free food. The pizza bread appetizer was absolutely not as described, what came was a small pizza crust with cheese. The description indicated there would be sauce and pepperoni, and that ranch would be served on the side. There was no ranch and no pepperoni. The final straw was my friend’s pizza. The “fresh mozzarella” was substituted with ricotta cheese, and the “fresh basil” was actually dried and just sprinkled around the pizza. Awful. Absolutely not worth the money, Fayetteville has better pizza at Casey’s or Sam’s Club for a fraction of the price.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 2
Johnny Williams
Best pizza I’ve had since visiting Little Italy in NYC several years ago!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jessica Thomas
I used to be such a huge fan of this place but it is Saturday 12/23/23 at 1:20 they refused to open the door for my friends and I. They state on the website it is open until 2:00 pm . We left the party scene early because we loved the pizza so much. Will not be coming back .
Chris Jones
Pizza was OK. Sever was very sweet. Place is small and drunk guy's cussing each other kind of ruined it for me.Parking: We had to park in a parking garage about a block away because of a football game in town
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 5
Xiuming 0.
I took my pizza to go so i cant say for sure if the service is good or bad but i can say that my pepperoni pizza was the most flavorless pizza I've ever had. Truly a disappointment because it looks so visually stunning!
Shwangy 41
Really friendly down to earth staff. Pizza is one of if not the best in town. Slightly better price than the average for pizza of this caliber. Thanks guys!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheesy Pizza Bread
Adam Hurry
Great service even at the end of night, good big slice of pizza for a great price!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Natasha Young
The atmosphere was great. There's outside seating as an option. There are TVs for sport-watchers. The bar had a great selection of beer and liquor. I wouldn't go back for the pizza though. Since this was during an event, we only had the choice of whatever was in the hotbox (pepperoni or cheese). The pizza was so salty that I didn't even eat half my slice. Go for the atmosphere, not the pizza.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 4
devin topf
tony's has great food and usually great service.although this evening the guy working came outside and cussed me out for no reason. dude needs to be
Tried it out and was pleased. Not oily, crispy crust, great flavor. It comes very close to what I’ve had in NJ and NY. The only difference is the crust has more of a saltine cracker flavor to it, which I prefer. In my opinion it’s a NY style pizza, but better, because of the saltine cracker taste of the crust. The only other pizza place around here with that similar flavor is Tim’s, but they don’t do NY style.
Joshua Seow
Being from NY, this pizza was nowhere near a NY slice. The crust was dry and bland. There was a lack of sauce, and the cheese was very low quality.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 1
Austin Stuhr
Owner greeted us at the bar and had a good chat with us! Pizza really good as well!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jon LaBelle
This place is amazing! A little hidden gem I never caught on to. I got the Fat Tony Alfredo Pizza at 18" and it's so good. Not only that, it's the biggest pizza I've ever walked home with. The feta on if makes it worthwhile. I didn't go in for a slice yet with beer prices and quality it would be worth it. College or not, this place has you covered.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Zachary Fredricksen
Watch out if you get delivery. The employee assured the delivery driver that everything was present when there was an entire item missing, the Big Pig Calzone. They are not checking the order when they say they say they have everything made. You need to have better checks when filling orders. It really stains your business.
Emma is the coolest bartender! Her drinks are amazing and she is great at customer service. I will be coming back to experience the amazing drink chemistry behind her mixology!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
My friend and I ordered pizza from Tony’s and were sorely disappointed. My cauliflower crust pizza came on regular crust, which could’ve been awful for someone who requires gluten free food. The pizza bread appetizer was absolutely not as described, what came was a small pizza crust with cheese. The description indicated there would be sauce and pepperoni, and that ranch would be served on the side. There was no ranch and no pepperoni. The final straw was my friend’s pizza. The “fresh mozzarella” was substituted with ricotta cheese, and the “fresh basil” was actually dried and just sprinkled around the pizza. Awful. Absolutely not worth the money, Fayetteville has better pizza at Casey’s or Sam’s Club for a fraction of the price.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 2
Best pizza I’ve had since visiting Little Italy in NYC several years ago!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I used to be such a huge fan of this place but it is Saturday 12/23/23 at 1:20 they refused to open the door for my friends and I. They state on the website it is open until 2:00 pm . We left the party scene early because we loved the pizza so much. Will not be coming back .
Pizza was OK. Sever was very sweet. Place is small and drunk guy's cussing each other kind of ruined it for me.Parking: We had to park in a parking garage about a block away because of a football game in town
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 5
I took my pizza to go so i cant say for sure if the service is good or bad but i can say that my pepperoni pizza was the most flavorless pizza I've ever had. Truly a disappointment because it looks so visually stunning!
Really friendly down to earth staff. Pizza is one of if not the best in town. Slightly better price than the average for pizza of this caliber. Thanks guys!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheesy Pizza Bread
Great service even at the end of night, good big slice of pizza for a great price!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The atmosphere was great. There's outside seating as an option. There are TVs for sport-watchers. The bar had a great selection of beer and liquor. I wouldn't go back for the pizza though. Since this was during an event, we only had the choice of whatever was in the hotbox (pepperoni or cheese). The pizza was so salty that I didn't even eat half my slice. Go for the atmosphere, not the pizza.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 4
tony's has great food and usually great service.although this evening the guy working came outside and cussed me out for no reason. dude needs to be
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 2
Restaurantji Recommends
Tried it out and was pleased. Not oily, crispy crust, great flavor. It comes very close to what I’ve had in NJ and NY. The only difference is the crust has more of a saltine cracker flavor to it, which I prefer. In my opinion it’s a NY style pizza, but better, because of the saltine cracker taste of the crust. The only other pizza place around here with that similar flavor is Tim’s, but they don’t do NY style.
Being from NY, this pizza was nowhere near a NY slice. The crust was dry and bland. There was a lack of sauce, and the cheese was very low quality.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 1
Owner greeted us at the bar and had a good chat with us! Pizza really good as well!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This place is amazing! A little hidden gem I never caught on to. I got the Fat Tony Alfredo Pizza at 18" and it's so good. Not only that, it's the biggest pizza I've ever walked home with. The feta on if makes it worthwhile. I didn't go in for a slice yet with beer prices and quality it would be worth it. College or not, this place has you covered.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Watch out if you get delivery. The employee assured the delivery driver that everything was present when there was an entire item missing, the Big Pig Calzone. They are not checking the order when they say they say they have everything made. You need to have better checks when filling orders. It really stains your business.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 1