Pizza is good! I don't like some of the tastes of the toppings! I don't know what companies you guys use for your meats and veggies, they just have very weird tastes!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Colton Weaver
Ordered 4 pizzas they brought out 3 and seem to have an attitude because they couldn't read the ticket correctly. Hire people who need a job not people who show up for a free check. Come on now
Jose Lopez
Called in for a Sausage pizza. Not only did they have it ready just as I had arrived, but the pizza was absolutely delicious! Price was very reasonable and the location is very convenient for me. Will definitely be back here!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sausage Pizza
Dawson Reynolds
I've been a customer for years. Last few months the Elm Srings location has completely went down hill. On several occasions I've stopped for a sausage pizza to be told it's a 10 to 15 min wait. I ask if they have pepperoni and told the same thing. It seems they never have any pizza ready. I've never had this problem in the past. Last night is what made me decide I'll not be visiting any Eureka Pizza location maybe ever?? Since they never seem to have pizza ready I called in a order. I pick my order up I ordered a couple of pizzas and cheese bread. First off I guess if you call in a order the pizza costs more because it was definitely more expensive than getting the exact same thing though the window. Also I noticed no dipping sauce with the cheese bread I asked if it came with dipping sauce and was told no. Which is ridiculous even gas station bread sticks has a dipping sauce.
Wendy Coopers
Provolone cheese does not take kindly to high heat. If you’re gonna offer a pizza with provolone cheese, you must take that into account and pre-cook your crust a bit before you actually put the ingredients on it. We were eating burnt, pizza soup. The problem, cheese was burnt, but the crust was very doughy and not cooked. If your going to offer a Specialty pizza learn the ingredients and how it reacts to high heat. The first go around they sent us home with 100 percent burnt crust (black) and burnt cheese (dark brown, almost black). We drove back and showed them, they offered to make it again. This time I did not want to argue so we just took the second pizzas home. It was absolutely the worst pizza I have eaten from there. Sad. As soon as I seen the second pizza I knew what the issue was. Too high of heat for provolone cheese. So if you order the St Louie pizza ask them to precook the crust for about 1 min if you do not want a soggie mess, or burnt pizza, for asking for it to be well done so the crust is cook through. Our curst was still dough. So sad. You can do better. Just slightly precook the crust or don’t sell pizzas with provolone cheese.
Epoch Fry
I was expecting this pizza to be on par with Little Caesar’s but it was practically inedible. Idk if it was just an off day, but it legit made me feel sick. I couldn’t even swallow a bite.
Austin Phillips
Eureka Pizza is a great place to get good pizza for cheap. I believe they only do drive up and order ahead (no delivery)? Love their small little pizzas. Yes, it’s not the best pizza I’ve ever had so I knocked off a star, but the pizza is good at an affordable price. Customer service is really great at this location. Drive thru is a little small and would probably be hard to navigate with a larger vehicle though. Located on the corner of Elm Springs Rd and 40th St. (near I49).
Kristy Mills
For the same price I could get dominos and it would taste
Laura Price
Love their stuff crust cheese
dan west
Mr.Rolf , I've been eating your pizza every since you started making them (that's been a "LOT OF PIZZA")I've always loved your pizza and will continue to be a Eureka Pizza customer until you quit serving pizza ,,,KEEP UP THE GREAT WORK ? ? ?
Atmosphere was my car lol. The food is always hot and fresh and staff is professional.
Jaque Winns
In the area for work wanted cheap pizza that's not lil ceasers, got what I payed for, this is a mix between mazzios and simple Simon's, aka, good enough for the price but not a place I'd run to when back in town. All in all pretty decent pizza crust was ok toppings were fantastic except the cheese tastes a little rubbery
Care Bear
It was ok but the price is great for the amount of food you get.
Ethan Ross Elledge
Sure, Eureka is your traditional, authentic Italian pizza but I love it. When I was young I would always order Eureka because it was the cheapest. Now, Eureka is still one of the cheapest and has upped their ingredients so much. It’s honestly a fantastic pizza if you want something quick and affordable. The customer service has always been great in my opinion, and the pizzas are always good. The sausage stuffed crust is my personal favorite.
Jon Phillips
Eureka has one of the best stuffed crust pizzas around! I'd have to say, they've edged out Pizza Hut for the top spot in that category. This location has always done a great job. Good customer service. Pies have always been made correctly. That's what I'm talking about...nice job, Eureka!
Pizza is good! I don't like some of the tastes of the toppings! I don't know what companies you guys use for your meats and veggies, they just have very weird tastes!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Ordered 4 pizzas they brought out 3 and seem to have an attitude because they couldn't read the ticket correctly. Hire people who need a job not people who show up for a free check. Come on now
Called in for a Sausage pizza. Not only did they have it ready just as I had arrived, but the pizza was absolutely delicious! Price was very reasonable and the location is very convenient for me. Will definitely be back here!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sausage Pizza
I've been a customer for years. Last few months the Elm Srings location has completely went down hill. On several occasions I've stopped for a sausage pizza to be told it's a 10 to 15 min wait. I ask if they have pepperoni and told the same thing. It seems they never have any pizza ready. I've never had this problem in the past. Last night is what made me decide I'll not be visiting any Eureka Pizza location maybe ever?? Since they never seem to have pizza ready I called in a order. I pick my order up I ordered a couple of pizzas and cheese bread. First off I guess if you call in a order the pizza costs more because it was definitely more expensive than getting the exact same thing though the window. Also I noticed no dipping sauce with the cheese bread I asked if it came with dipping sauce and was told no. Which is ridiculous even gas station bread sticks has a dipping sauce.
Provolone cheese does not take kindly to high heat. If you’re gonna offer a pizza with provolone cheese, you must take that into account and pre-cook your crust a bit before you actually put the ingredients on it. We were eating burnt, pizza soup. The problem, cheese was burnt, but the crust was very doughy and not cooked. If your going to offer a Specialty pizza learn the ingredients and how it reacts to high heat. The first go around they sent us home with 100 percent burnt crust (black) and burnt cheese (dark brown, almost black). We drove back and showed them, they offered to make it again. This time I did not want to argue so we just took the second pizzas home. It was absolutely the worst pizza I have eaten from there. Sad. As soon as I seen the second pizza I knew what the issue was. Too high of heat for provolone cheese. So if you order the St Louie pizza ask them to precook the crust for about 1 min if you do not want a soggie mess, or burnt pizza, for asking for it to be well done so the crust is cook through. Our curst was still dough. So sad. You can do better. Just slightly precook the crust or don’t sell pizzas with provolone cheese.
I was expecting this pizza to be on par with Little Caesar’s but it was practically inedible. Idk if it was just an off day, but it legit made me feel sick. I couldn’t even swallow a bite.
Eureka Pizza is a great place to get good pizza for cheap. I believe they only do drive up and order ahead (no delivery)? Love their small little pizzas. Yes, it’s not the best pizza I’ve ever had so I knocked off a star, but the pizza is good at an affordable price. Customer service is really great at this location. Drive thru is a little small and would probably be hard to navigate with a larger vehicle though. Located on the corner of Elm Springs Rd and 40th St. (near I49).
For the same price I could get dominos and it would taste
Love their stuff crust cheese
Mr.Rolf , I've been eating your pizza every since you started making them (that's been a "LOT OF PIZZA")I've always loved your pizza and will continue to be a Eureka Pizza customer until you quit serving pizza ,,,KEEP UP THE GREAT WORK ? ? ?
Restaurantji Recommends
Atmosphere was my car lol. The food is always hot and fresh and staff is professional.
In the area for work wanted cheap pizza that's not lil ceasers, got what I payed for, this is a mix between mazzios and simple Simon's, aka, good enough for the price but not a place I'd run to when back in town. All in all pretty decent pizza crust was ok toppings were fantastic except the cheese tastes a little rubbery
It was ok but the price is great for the amount of food you get.
Sure, Eureka is your traditional, authentic Italian pizza but I love it. When I was young I would always order Eureka because it was the cheapest. Now, Eureka is still one of the cheapest and has upped their ingredients so much. It’s honestly a fantastic pizza if you want something quick and affordable. The customer service has always been great in my opinion, and the pizzas are always good. The sausage stuffed crust is my personal favorite.
Eureka has one of the best stuffed crust pizzas around! I'd have to say, they've edged out Pizza Hut for the top spot in that category. This location has always done a great job. Good customer service. Pies have always been made correctly. That's what I'm talking about...nice job, Eureka!