Such great customer service and absolutely amazing cake! This review is long overdue as I ordered my wedding cake plus cupcakes for my wedding a few years ago. Can't say enough good things about this business. ?? Photo Credit to MollyMcPhoto
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wedding Cake
Marie Wenzel
On very short notice, Lexi made me the most beautiful cake for my 60th birthday! There were gasps when my guests opened the box. It tasted as good as it looks! A definite go to for a special occasion cake. Give her more notice though.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Debra Maldonado
The cake was beautiful and tasted wonderful. Sugar Mamas made my daughter’s graduation a little bit sweeter!
Bruinmoose A.
Lexi was wonderful! We ordered a cake and cupcakes, and there were none left. So delicious, and beautiful.
Megan Shelton
Can't get a hold of this bakery to do a cake for my wedding. She keeps pushing dates back of when she'll be back. Doesn't communicate well via email or through the knot app. Only responded once last month and has not followed up with me. Not reliable. I think I'm going to go with someone else. Disappointed, extended through the end of March to April 7th now mid April I feel like you are lying to everyone. And also nobody has posted pictures/reviews for months so I take that as a bad sign.
Sanjam Ahluwalia
Lexi's baked good are absolutely the best ever! Thank you for adding to the culinary delights of Flagstaff?
Megan Prim
Can't get a hold of this bakery to do a cake for my wedding. She keeps pushing dates back of when she'll be back. Doesn't communicate well via email or through the knot app. Only responded once last month and has not followed up with me. Not reliable. I think I'm going to go with someone else. Disappointed, extended through the end of March to April 7th now mid April I feel like you are lying to everyone. And also nobody has posted pictures/reviews for months so I take that as a bad sign.
Colleen Kelly
An amazing cake! It looked spectacular and was delicious! The lemon filling was the best!Thank you Lexi! You helped make our event and evening very special!
Acie VanCleave
They saved my bacon. I needed a last minute birthday cheesecake and somehow she pulled off a honey lavender massive cheesecake in under 24 hours despite having more than full capacity of orders. Not only that, this was hands down the best cheesecake I've ever had and my wife concurs. The only other cheesecake that was even close was at Sarge's Deli in Manhattan. Sugar Mamas is legit!
Sugar Mama's baked the cake for our wedding at Shoshone Point on 10/3, *very* last minute (our original caterer dropped out mid-June). They were very responsive and helpful with the super short deadline. On top of that, the cake was *amazing*. When we took our first bite, we both paused and then kept shoveling cake into our mouths it was sooo delicious! Another fun thing - my husband's favorite cake is German Chocolate, so they made us a cupcake to have in our room at the end of the night (also scrumptious!). We cannot thank Sugar Mama's enough, they were the best!
Liza S.
Sugar Mamas baked the cake for our wedding at Shoshone Point on 10/3, *very* last minute (our original caterer dropped out mid-June). They were very responsive and helpful with the super short deadline. On top of that, the cake was *amazing*. When we took our first bite, we both paused and then kept shoveling cake into our mouths it was sooo delicious! Another fun thing - my husband's favorite cake is German Chocolate, so they made us a cupcake to have in our room at the end of the night (also scrumptious!). We cannot thank Sugar Mamas enough, they were the best!
Gabriel F.
We live in Sedona and were very dissatisfied with cakes available in Sedona, so we ordered a birthday cake from Sugar Mamas in Flagstaff. We ordered a white cake with buttercream icing. Lexi was great to work with and came through with a tasty cake made from great ingredients. The cake was delicious, it felt like a real cake. So many bakery cakes these days taste like they were made from a mix and with cheap ingredients. Caution: When the cake is this good you feel like eating more so order a larger cake then you think you'll need....
Tammy Sabo Nelson
My daughter picked up an Apple Pie on Wednesday for my birthday. It was by far the BEST apple pie we have ever eaten! Thank you!
Tammy Sabo Nelson
My daughter picked up an Apple Pie on Wednesday for my birthday. It was by far the BEST apple pie we have ever eaten! Thank you!
The icing tasted off, the cake was very dry and
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: Wedding Cake
Such great customer service and absolutely amazing cake! This review is long overdue as I ordered my wedding cake plus cupcakes for my wedding a few years ago. Can't say enough good things about this business. ?? Photo Credit to MollyMcPhoto
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wedding Cake
On very short notice, Lexi made me the most beautiful cake for my 60th birthday! There were gasps when my guests opened the box. It tasted as good as it looks! A definite go to for a special occasion cake. Give her more notice though.
Food: 5
Service: 5
The cake was beautiful and tasted wonderful. Sugar Mamas made my daughter’s graduation a little bit sweeter!
Lexi was wonderful! We ordered a cake and cupcakes, and there were none left. So delicious, and beautiful.
Can't get a hold of this bakery to do a cake for my wedding. She keeps pushing dates back of when she'll be back. Doesn't communicate well via email or through the knot app. Only responded once last month and has not followed up with me. Not reliable. I think I'm going to go with someone else. Disappointed, extended through the end of March to April 7th now mid April I feel like you are lying to everyone. And also nobody has posted pictures/reviews for months so I take that as a bad sign.
Lexi's baked good are absolutely the best ever! Thank you for adding to the culinary delights of Flagstaff?
Can't get a hold of this bakery to do a cake for my wedding. She keeps pushing dates back of when she'll be back. Doesn't communicate well via email or through the knot app. Only responded once last month and has not followed up with me. Not reliable. I think I'm going to go with someone else. Disappointed, extended through the end of March to April 7th now mid April I feel like you are lying to everyone. And also nobody has posted pictures/reviews for months so I take that as a bad sign.
An amazing cake! It looked spectacular and was delicious! The lemon filling was the best!Thank you Lexi! You helped make our event and evening very special!
They saved my bacon. I needed a last minute birthday cheesecake and somehow she pulled off a honey lavender massive cheesecake in under 24 hours despite having more than full capacity of orders. Not only that, this was hands down the best cheesecake I've ever had and my wife concurs. The only other cheesecake that was even close was at Sarge's Deli in Manhattan. Sugar Mamas is legit!
Restaurantji Recommends
Sugar Mama's baked the cake for our wedding at Shoshone Point on 10/3, *very* last minute (our original caterer dropped out mid-June). They were very responsive and helpful with the super short deadline. On top of that, the cake was *amazing*. When we took our first bite, we both paused and then kept shoveling cake into our mouths it was sooo delicious! Another fun thing - my husband's favorite cake is German Chocolate, so they made us a cupcake to have in our room at the end of the night (also scrumptious!). We cannot thank Sugar Mama's enough, they were the best!
Sugar Mamas baked the cake for our wedding at Shoshone Point on 10/3, *very* last minute (our original caterer dropped out mid-June). They were very responsive and helpful with the super short deadline. On top of that, the cake was *amazing*. When we took our first bite, we both paused and then kept shoveling cake into our mouths it was sooo delicious! Another fun thing - my husband's favorite cake is German Chocolate, so they made us a cupcake to have in our room at the end of the night (also scrumptious!). We cannot thank Sugar Mamas enough, they were the best!
We live in Sedona and were very dissatisfied with cakes available in Sedona, so we ordered a birthday cake from Sugar Mamas in Flagstaff. We ordered a white cake with buttercream icing. Lexi was great to work with and came through with a tasty cake made from great ingredients. The cake was delicious, it felt like a real cake. So many bakery cakes these days taste like they were made from a mix and with cheap ingredients. Caution: When the cake is this good you feel like eating more so order a larger cake then you think you'll need....
My daughter picked up an Apple Pie on Wednesday for my birthday. It was by far the BEST apple pie we have ever eaten! Thank you!
My daughter picked up an Apple Pie on Wednesday for my birthday. It was by far the BEST apple pie we have ever eaten! Thank you!