My cake was perfect. Beautifully done and delicious 10 star experience. Simply put. The
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Birthday Cake
Mckenzie Barbera
I found this bakery online and the online order form made it super simple to order the cake I wanted and pay. I had no issues picking up the cake a few days later, the whole process was so easy and stress free. The woman I spoke with was extremely friendly and kind. Now the cake, this was stunning. It was moist and fluffy and not overly sweet, honestly the perfect cake. I will be purchasing other cakes from here for upcoming special occasions ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kam
Lisa did an absolutely phenomenal job on our wedding cake last weekend. She made the cake tasting beforehand such a fun experience for us and she was really helpful and easy to get a hold of when we decided to change our design a couple weeks before the event. The cake was delivered right on time and tasted as great as it looked! We had lots of compliments from our friends and family. Thank you so much for making this part of our planning so easy!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wedding Cake, Birthday Cake
James Pauley
I searched numerous bakeries for the perfect cake for my wife’s birthday, and Lisa did not disappoint ! My wife is very particular about cake, most are to sweet or too dry. I found Lisa’s online and stopped by the bakery and the staff was amazing and extremely helpful. I purchased a box with a variety of cakes, and to say my wife loved them is an understatement! Lisa’s Rum Cake are absolutely fantastic!Dietary restrictions: The best vegan cakes
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Strawberry Vanilla Cake
Tyler Kettler
The atomic cake is so good, gotten it on back to back in the family birthdays.
Amazing service when arrived to pick up cake. Got some sample cakes and OMG the peach amaretto! Limoncello was so tasty. Cakes were very moist. Loved the icing! Highly recommend.Update. Tried the valentine red velvet cake. 10 stars! That was so freaking good. Loved the authentic cocoa taste in it!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Limoncello Cake
Bob B.
Amazing service when arrived to pick up cake. I Got some sample cakes and OMG the peach amaretto! Limoncello was so tasty. Bday Cake was very moist. Very impressed with the decoration and Loved the icing! Highly recommend.
Haley G.
I wanna start this by saying, these cakes are delicious. I have ordered from here SEVERAL times. I ordered a cake for my sons's birthday. I originally wanted a cake that resembled a soccer field.. Although I am no cake decorator, I thought it was a fairly simple request, as a soccer field as just a couple boxes and a circle in the middle, and I just wanted it green. I was told it would be "too expensive" and I should "buy and edible template from Albertsons to put on top." I was VERY off put by this. I was told it would be "too expensive" but they never told me a price. And I thought the idea of an edible template was extremely tacky. I opted for Happy Birthday in the middle, but hoped the frosting would still be green. I was planning on buying plastic soccer players and goals to be put on afterward. Notes were took on my cake, but I felt extremely rushed and wanted to make sure details were correct, so I emailed the business the next day. (Email attached) I was called a few hours later by Lisa herself who said "yes I remember you, remember I said to buy the edible template for the top" I explained that I did not like that idea, and I just wanted it to be green with the happy birthday in the middle and I would add my little things at the end. Attached is the cake I picked up. I was extremely disappointed, and when I called I was told that in order for it to be green I would have had to pay extra. I clarified "it would have cost extra to add a couple drops of food coloring to the frosting?" "Yes" I wish it would have been make crystal clear over the phone that I was getting a white cake. I wanted a soccer field. I thought I made that clear on the phone and the email. The cake was served 2 days later, and it was delicious. But I am not sure the next time I'll be back. I would recommend getting the cakes without any special requests. It seems to be too much trouble for them. But these cakes are delicious.
Carol Olsen
This is an amazing cake shop And I have been following it for years. Absolutely the best❤️
I absolutely love Lisa and her wonderful girls. They did our wedding cake and it was AMAZING! all the ladies their are great and so welcoming. So many wonderful flavors, plus if you can imagine it, if they don't have it already as an unlisted flavor, I'd be shocked. Such an amazing group and delicious bakers. I will always go there for my cakes and don't forget to check out the cake cuts, the flavors change weekly and you can always find something new to try
Let me start the cake was DELICIOUS .. BUT I asked for a canolli cake (specified that I wanted vanilla cake with canolli cream in the middle instead of icing) was told they do this often and we were good to go. They even were able to take the order last minute which I appreciate greatly! ONLY thing is there was pastry cream in the cake that I was not informed of so half the cake was wasted due to half of the family not liking the pastry cream on top or the canoli cream (luckily the birthday boy enjoyed it which was a relief he’s a VERY picky eater so it was a close call) just wish there was better communication on what would be inside the cake if it’s not a standard thing. We’ll still be back ? (& I liked the curly ribbons on the cake too since we asked for no food coloring it was so cute!)
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Birthday Cake
Alexandra Greenwood
My friend pre-ordered a cake for her youngest son's birthday well in advance. She asked for a specific design, relatively simple and was told they could do it. Instead, she received a plain white cake with black writing. No apology and no refund. I will never come here.Thank you for your response, however, my friend just wanted green frosting. If you are unable to change frosting from white to green 1 to 2 weeks before a holiday, you shouldn't have accepted the order.
Service: 1
Rachael Ridley
Amazing people, amazing cakes! You’ll not be disappointed getting your cake here. Even stopping by for a treat. This family owned business is full of the most amazing people. Support a local shop!
Nancy M.
I ordered the banana strawberry rum and the peaches and cream for a weekend of family birthday celebrations! They were so good that I ordered the atomic cake for my own bday the following week.
Austin A
I've been coming to Lisa's Rum Cake for years. Their cakes and service are absolutely the best.
My cake was perfect. Beautifully done and delicious 10 star experience. Simply put. The
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Birthday Cake
I found this bakery online and the online order form made it super simple to order the cake I wanted and pay. I had no issues picking up the cake a few days later, the whole process was so easy and stress free. The woman I spoke with was extremely friendly and kind. Now the cake, this was stunning. It was moist and fluffy and not overly sweet, honestly the perfect cake. I will be purchasing other cakes from here for upcoming special occasions ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lisa did an absolutely phenomenal job on our wedding cake last weekend. She made the cake tasting beforehand such a fun experience for us and she was really helpful and easy to get a hold of when we decided to change our design a couple weeks before the event. The cake was delivered right on time and tasted as great as it looked! We had lots of compliments from our friends and family. Thank you so much for making this part of our planning so easy!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wedding Cake, Birthday Cake
I searched numerous bakeries for the perfect cake for my wife’s birthday, and Lisa did not disappoint ! My wife is very particular about cake, most are to sweet or too dry. I found Lisa’s online and stopped by the bakery and the staff was amazing and extremely helpful. I purchased a box with a variety of cakes, and to say my wife loved them is an understatement! Lisa’s Rum Cake are absolutely fantastic!Dietary restrictions: The best vegan cakes
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Strawberry Vanilla Cake
The atomic cake is so good, gotten it on back to back in the family birthdays.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Strawberry Vanilla Cake, Birthday Cake
Amazing service when arrived to pick up cake. Got some sample cakes and OMG the peach amaretto! Limoncello was so tasty. Cakes were very moist. Loved the icing! Highly recommend.Update. Tried the valentine red velvet cake. 10 stars! That was so freaking good. Loved the authentic cocoa taste in it!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Limoncello Cake
Amazing service when arrived to pick up cake. I Got some sample cakes and OMG the peach amaretto! Limoncello was so tasty. Bday Cake was very moist. Very impressed with the decoration and Loved the icing! Highly recommend.
I wanna start this by saying, these cakes are delicious. I have ordered from here SEVERAL times. I ordered a cake for my sons's birthday. I originally wanted a cake that resembled a soccer field.. Although I am no cake decorator, I thought it was a fairly simple request, as a soccer field as just a couple boxes and a circle in the middle, and I just wanted it green. I was told it would be "too expensive" and I should "buy and edible template from Albertsons to put on top." I was VERY off put by this. I was told it would be "too expensive" but they never told me a price. And I thought the idea of an edible template was extremely tacky. I opted for Happy Birthday in the middle, but hoped the frosting would still be green. I was planning on buying plastic soccer players and goals to be put on afterward. Notes were took on my cake, but I felt extremely rushed and wanted to make sure details were correct, so I emailed the business the next day. (Email attached) I was called a few hours later by Lisa herself who said "yes I remember you, remember I said to buy the edible template for the top" I explained that I did not like that idea, and I just wanted it to be green with the happy birthday in the middle and I would add my little things at the end. Attached is the cake I picked up. I was extremely disappointed, and when I called I was told that in order for it to be green I would have had to pay extra. I clarified "it would have cost extra to add a couple drops of food coloring to the frosting?" "Yes" I wish it would have been make crystal clear over the phone that I was getting a white cake. I wanted a soccer field. I thought I made that clear on the phone and the email. The cake was served 2 days later, and it was delicious. But I am not sure the next time I'll be back. I would recommend getting the cakes without any special requests. It seems to be too much trouble for them. But these cakes are delicious.
This is an amazing cake shop And I have been following it for years. Absolutely the best❤️
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Strawberry Vanilla Cake, Limoncello Cake, Wedding Cake, Birthday Cake, Unicorn Cake
I absolutely love Lisa and her wonderful girls. They did our wedding cake and it was AMAZING! all the ladies their are great and so welcoming. So many wonderful flavors, plus if you can imagine it, if they don't have it already as an unlisted flavor, I'd be shocked. Such an amazing group and delicious bakers. I will always go there for my cakes and don't forget to check out the cake cuts, the flavors change weekly and you can always find something new to try
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wedding Cake
Restaurantji Recommends
Let me start the cake was DELICIOUS .. BUT I asked for a canolli cake (specified that I wanted vanilla cake with canolli cream in the middle instead of icing) was told they do this often and we were good to go. They even were able to take the order last minute which I appreciate greatly! ONLY thing is there was pastry cream in the cake that I was not informed of so half the cake was wasted due to half of the family not liking the pastry cream on top or the canoli cream (luckily the birthday boy enjoyed it which was a relief he’s a VERY picky eater so it was a close call) just wish there was better communication on what would be inside the cake if it’s not a standard thing. We’ll still be back ? (& I liked the curly ribbons on the cake too since we asked for no food coloring it was so cute!)
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Birthday Cake
My friend pre-ordered a cake for her youngest son's birthday well in advance. She asked for a specific design, relatively simple and was told they could do it. Instead, she received a plain white cake with black writing. No apology and no refund. I will never come here.Thank you for your response, however, my friend just wanted green frosting. If you are unable to change frosting from white to green 1 to 2 weeks before a holiday, you shouldn't have accepted the order.
Service: 1
Amazing people, amazing cakes! You’ll not be disappointed getting your cake here. Even stopping by for a treat. This family owned business is full of the most amazing people. Support a local shop!
I ordered the banana strawberry rum and the peaches and cream for a weekend of family birthday celebrations! They were so good that I ordered the atomic cake for my own bday the following week.
I've been coming to Lisa's Rum Cake for years. Their cakes and service are absolutely the best.