Gus's New York Pizza

7425 W Peoria Ave #100, Peoria
(623) 878-3000

Recent Reviews

Tim Pickering

The pizza and wings are top notch. The prices are much lower than expected and the quality is worth much more than you pay for. The store is not designed for you to eat in, though there are a few seats there. I don't fault them for this because I'm sure that is part of what keeps the prices low. Also to be noted, I'm not sure if the pizza is better hot or cold and I mean that in the best way. If they see this review, please keep up the good work and know that it is appreciated and I have told multiple people to try your food!

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pizza, Jumbo Wings, Wings, Cheese Pizza

Timothy Lancaster

Good Pizza and good

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza

Braden Rader

Im not sure were they find the tweekers that work here but its getting out of hand, food is disgusting and takes forever i was told 15 more minutes 4 times thats an hour for one pizza and the employees look like they were picked up from a rehab.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Gabriel Guamam

Best pizza in town, beats domino's and pizza

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Miguel V.

I rarely write reviews but I have to for this one ! Do not eat here when Dons Pizza is across the street. I wanted to try Gus's because the one in Tempe is phenomenal, but this location is terrible. One of the worst restaurants I've ever been to when it comes to ambiance and customer service. The workers seem like druggies and have attitudes, the wings were dry and had no taste. The pizza was soggy but edible. Don't spend your money here.

Leahann Batley

First and last time from this place. The 3rd star is solely for the chick behind the counter doing her best by herself, who was friendly despite being out of a dozen plus ingredients (there's a list on the white board behind the counter).Both pizzas were missing ingredients and the outer crust was spicy which, in a wing place, smacks of cross contamination.Grease on the mushrooms tasted old. Sad because I love a local pizza place but there's just too many issues.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 2

Service: 5

Daniel E.

Great pizza great service, friendly fun filled environment. The cooks are awesome, the menu have a variety of options to choose from. S

Liza W.

Omg no. Just no! Go somewhere else. The food is absolutely terrible the wait time is ridiculous and the people have bad attitudes. All around it's a hard pass for me! Not what it used to be So sad

Debbie Myers

FOOD IF YOU CHOOSE TO CALL IT THAT..I CALL IT MOLDED GARBAGE!! GAL HANDLING THE COUNTER IS RUDE AND IM BEING POLITE..INSIDE WAS WELL....THERES NO WORDS...THIS PLACE SHOULD BE CLOSED DOWN. HATE TO BE THAT PERSON...WAS PIR 1ST AND LAST TIME. $26.12 PAID FOR NOT ONE BITE EDIBLE

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

V Dieter

Placed order online, was given 3 texts with time and updates. Went to pick up food within time frame given. Once there it took a few minutes for a worker to say anything to me while standing at counter. There is no bell or anything to get the workers in the backs attention. Once I finally talked to a worker she told me that the order was barley received and needs to be made! It took another 15 minutes for my order to be ready. So in total my order took an extra 30 minutes. Very disappointed and irritated in this encounter. If the time was going to be extended I can understand but I was told prior to driving there my order would be ready. Unfortunately will not be going back. Food was good but service and time wasted was not worth it.

Atmosphere: 1

Service: 1

Krystalyn Jackson

Customer service is horrible. They are very rude there. I ordered a fried cheesecake just now for pickup. When I got home and opened the container the smell was so horrendous my husband and I both gagged. I had to throw it away because it obviously was super old and no longer edible. Not happy at all.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Jerry Minard

Excellent service and excellent

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Fettuccine Alfredo, Large Pizza, 12 Wings, Sauce, Pepperoni Pizza, Slice, Medium Pizza, Wings, Cheese Pizza

Jeff H.

NEVER AGAIN I just ordered a phili sub and 24 wings and gave them a 20% Tip. When you see this place run away, the wings were way over cooked, they were so bad that they were not edible. Some of the wing's bones had a green color to them The sub had some kind of sauce marinade that tasted like burnt cheap steak sauce. This is the second time in a row I had a bad experience there, and the best advice I can give the owner is to fire everybody, burn the place down, and start over.

Todd Edwards

Ordered the Medium pizza and 6 wing special. Melissa is apparently the new manager and she killed it. She awesome!! Great service and good food. Labor costs have made it very hard to run a restaurant these days so until the volume is higher I think they be slower on service and orders but they are focusing on consistency and quality.

Chris

Purchased a pizza, taste was decent but when a couple slices turned over accidentally I saw what looked like a burn mark on the crust, but something about it didn't look right, I took a closer look and it was fuzzy mold starting to grow on the crust. From the prior reviews something ain't right about this place. Surprised it hasn't been shut down.

Food: 1

Load More