Awful....tough crust, no cheese.Ordered barbecue chicken but all I could taste was barbecue sauce which I tried scraping off.I'll never go here again.My friend also had bad experience.She ordered sausage, ham chicken.No cheese. Tough crust.Awful. Worst we've ever had.Parking: Adequate
Angelita Contreras-Oliva
We ordered today from here for a staff party and it was a hit! We had never ordered from here but thought we should give it a try. We are glad we did!! :)The Margherita Pizza was the best and the Mild wings were super good and meaty ! We also got bbq but I prefer some heat so the mild were our favorite. Thank you so much. We will be ordering more often ! Delivery was right on time as well !
Brittany
We found our new pizza place! The pizza here is really good, great flavors. I appreciate the high quality ingredients they use (Hayden flour mills and Bianco Dinapoli tomatoes). It’s a refreshing change from the many franchises in the area. We also appreciated that they had a dairy free mozzarella for our kids that are allergic.
Roxana V
Definitely expected more for the pricing.I had their hot honey wings and margarita pizza. The wings were yummy. Their blue cheese sauce is not flavorful tho def just go with the ranch. Margarita pizza had way too much tomato sauce for thin crust pizza and that made it unpleasant to eat They def skimped on the basil, only got 3-4 leaves on the whole pizza . Taste was overall pretty good but either prices should go down or quality should go up.
Brandon Pickett
The margarita pizza was very good. It a absolutely tasted fresh and had a great crust. The pizza is surprisingly light. The anti pasto salad was delicious. Fresh ingredients including freshly made Italian dressing with good Olive Oil. Will certainly be back.
Rod
Went to Reel Pizza in Surprise AZ for the 1st time and probably the last. Pizza was Hella expensive and bad. Ordered the White Pizza with a few extra toppings which was thin crust, dry with hard dough. Nice size Pizza, but lacking flavor and not sure why anyone would want a pizza without sauce anyway. Tried purchasing some marinara sauce the next day to help finish off the extra alices i had left over, but it was difficult to eat. The only good thing about my experience was the cook who handed out the food was friendly.
AD Groves
Pizza was amazing! Thin crust loaded with cheese and toppings. My only complaint would be the meatlovers was super greasy. Best pizza joint I have eaten at in months!
Sara P.
Located in a smaller plaza with a lot of parking. Very little seating inside, maybe 10-12 people. Came in about an hour before closing on a Friday night and the workers were friendly and we got our food hot and quick. Pizzas were good, crispy crust but pizza itself is a bit soggy. Pepperonis we're a bit salty. The wings were just ok. The highlights were the meatballs - tasty, meaty and the marinara it sat in was a perfect compliment. And the garlic cheese bread - garlicky, cheesy and ooey goey. It was perfect. Great cheese to bread ratio. Overall, would come back here again for the meatballs and garlic cheese bread.
Scott Uehlein
The pizza is off the hook, but seriously don't miss the meatball sub....it is freaking delicious!!!!
Mikey D.
This is simply the best pizza in Arizona. I don't know about their other dishes, but the pizza is great. That's coming from a person that grew up in the New York City area.
Love this pizza place in Surprise! Great slices and the salad is very tasty too! If you want a pie that tastes like back East, this is the place to go! We enjoyed the Meathead with added pineapple and Margherita. They are wonderful to do a half and half. The wings are very tasty too. We ordered the BBQ flavor and even taking them home, they were still very hot! The Cesear salad was fresh and happy they put the dressing on the side. We will be back for more!
Brett W.
Excellent pizza ((and salad) I didn't have high hopes since it's pizza in Surprise AZ, but I was pleasantly surprised. This place is far better than everything in the area!
J M
From New York and Chicago I know good pizza plus I'm also a chef. I've been ordering from Reel for years and have never been disappointed. Best pizza in town! They take that extra step to start with a fermented dough and use the finest ingredients. Their crust truly makes them special. Delicious!
Deb Nier
Was visiting in Surprise and tried your pizza ! Very good! Delicious crust and excellent toppings. Quick,ready on time hot! We be back again!
Rosie Z.
Always amazing every time! The crust is perfection and they do not skimp on the toppings. Everything is great I really can't recommend them enough.
Awful....tough crust, no cheese.Ordered barbecue chicken but all I could taste was barbecue sauce which I tried scraping off.I'll never go here again.My friend also had bad experience.She ordered sausage, ham chicken.No cheese. Tough crust.Awful. Worst we've ever had.Parking: Adequate
We ordered today from here for a staff party and it was a hit! We had never ordered from here but thought we should give it a try. We are glad we did!! :)The Margherita Pizza was the best and the Mild wings were super good and meaty ! We also got bbq but I prefer some heat so the mild were our favorite. Thank you so much. We will be ordering more often ! Delivery was right on time as well !
We found our new pizza place! The pizza here is really good, great flavors. I appreciate the high quality ingredients they use (Hayden flour mills and Bianco Dinapoli tomatoes). It’s a refreshing change from the many franchises in the area. We also appreciated that they had a dairy free mozzarella for our kids that are allergic.
Definitely expected more for the pricing.I had their hot honey wings and margarita pizza. The wings were yummy. Their blue cheese sauce is not flavorful tho def just go with the ranch. Margarita pizza had way too much tomato sauce for thin crust pizza and that made it unpleasant to eat They def skimped on the basil, only got 3-4 leaves on the whole pizza . Taste was overall pretty good but either prices should go down or quality should go up.
The margarita pizza was very good. It a absolutely tasted fresh and had a great crust. The pizza is surprisingly light. The anti pasto salad was delicious. Fresh ingredients including freshly made Italian dressing with good Olive Oil. Will certainly be back.
Went to Reel Pizza in Surprise AZ for the 1st time and probably the last. Pizza was Hella expensive and bad. Ordered the White Pizza with a few extra toppings which was thin crust, dry with hard dough. Nice size Pizza, but lacking flavor and not sure why anyone would want a pizza without sauce anyway. Tried purchasing some marinara sauce the next day to help finish off the extra alices i had left over, but it was difficult to eat. The only good thing about my experience was the cook who handed out the food was friendly.
Pizza was amazing! Thin crust loaded with cheese and toppings. My only complaint would be the meatlovers was super greasy. Best pizza joint I have eaten at in months!
Located in a smaller plaza with a lot of parking. Very little seating inside, maybe 10-12 people. Came in about an hour before closing on a Friday night and the workers were friendly and we got our food hot and quick. Pizzas were good, crispy crust but pizza itself is a bit soggy. Pepperonis we're a bit salty. The wings were just ok. The highlights were the meatballs - tasty, meaty and the marinara it sat in was a perfect compliment. And the garlic cheese bread - garlicky, cheesy and ooey goey. It was perfect. Great cheese to bread ratio. Overall, would come back here again for the meatballs and garlic cheese bread.
The pizza is off the hook, but seriously don't miss the meatball sub....it is freaking delicious!!!!
This is simply the best pizza in Arizona. I don't know about their other dishes, but the pizza is great. That's coming from a person that grew up in the New York City area.
Restaurantji Recommends
Love this pizza place in Surprise! Great slices and the salad is very tasty too! If you want a pie that tastes like back East, this is the place to go! We enjoyed the Meathead with added pineapple and Margherita. They are wonderful to do a half and half. The wings are very tasty too. We ordered the BBQ flavor and even taking them home, they were still very hot! The Cesear salad was fresh and happy they put the dressing on the side. We will be back for more!
Excellent pizza ((and salad) I didn't have high hopes since it's pizza in Surprise AZ, but I was pleasantly surprised. This place is far better than everything in the area!
From New York and Chicago I know good pizza plus I'm also a chef. I've been ordering from Reel for years and have never been disappointed. Best pizza in town! They take that extra step to start with a fermented dough and use the finest ingredients. Their crust truly makes them special. Delicious!
Was visiting in Surprise and tried your pizza ! Very good! Delicious crust and excellent toppings. Quick,ready on time hot! We be back again!
Always amazing every time! The crust is perfection and they do not skimp on the toppings. Everything is great I really can't recommend them enough.