Omar's Pizza

33 E Duarte Rd, Arcadia
(626) 446-2900

Recent Reviews

Santiago Alejandro

Great undercarriage, 0 flop, great sauce, good cheese, and a great crisp. 8.6

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Slice of Pizza Choice of Cheese or Pepperoni, Pizza, Garlic Knots

Giuseppina Cafaro

My favorite to go for the calzone with ricotta and mozzarella ?

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Lucy K

Parking: Additional parking in the backKid-friendliness: There's a claw machine and the owner will put any cartoon/ movie you ask her for.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Marinara Sauce, Wings, Pizza, Boneless Wings with a Side of Ranch

Kelly C.

Called to ask about prices, first time ordering from here and wants to know if it was different than Grub Hub prices which I prefer not to use. I don't know who I spoke to, a male, but he don't have answers. I went ahead and started to place an order to find out how it compared to GH.... It was the same price but then my husband decided in the background that he wanted to go with a closer pizza place...so I apologized and said we would be going elsewhere and CLICK he hung up the phone mid-apology. I mean, it was a 30 seconds or less order and it wouldn't hurt to acknowledge that I apologized and go on our merry way; just not the best approach in customer service imo

Jan B.

Still Amazing. Also a Go-To for the Fam. My 2 boys can eat the whole jumbo pepperoni by themselves.

Libby Lee

Quiet place for pizza. The pizza was yummy but I was especially excited to see cannoli on their menu. It was good and I could tell it was not pre-made because the shell was still crispy when I bit into it.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Victoria M.

Grabbed a quick pizza to take to St Lowes brewery cuz the taco truck canceled. Googled pizzas in the area. First choice was Alitali, but we wanted a pastrami pizza. Called Omars they had pastrami, we ordered and we were on our way..The place was empty. We waited 5 minutes and it was ready. Took our pizza to go. Pizza was just ok. Crust was thin. Needed more cheese, had marinara which made it sweet. Im just use to mustard drizzle. Wasn't a fan, but would want to have it my way. Might give it another try if i order a thicker crust. The garlic knots weren't too buttery. The stafff were nice tho.

Brienna M.

Was craving some New York pizza with ricotta and found this spot. Unassuming location doesn't do the food justice. The pizza was great! Very reasonably priced. I've got the menu handy on my fridge for the next craving. We preordered using the online service which was quick and easy. Food ready when we got there. Could see going and sitting in just to get a quiet moment away from more crowded spots. They have a great lunch special for under $10.

Dream State Films

True New York slices served

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Robert W. Gilliam

So I decided to take a chance on this location due to the fact it was one of the few places open on Christmas. I should’ve taken heed to the previous substandard reviews. I ordered an Xtra large 5 cheese pepperoni pizza, 10 honey bbq wings, and an order of potato wedges. The potato wedges seemed to be tasteless and refried in old oil. The wings had to be doctored with other seasonings. The cheese pizza was below average and not worth the nearly $40!!!I’m gonna chalk this experience up to it being on Christmas Day. There was no enjoyment for this food while watching Christmas Day football and basketball. I gave this location a one star because it was actually open on Christmas Day. Buyers and Italian food lovers beware!!!

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Victor H.

Great service and pizza and Barbeque wings were a hit! Recommend this place and be. Ack for sure.

Silvia V.

Food is good it's a nice little hidden gem. They sale pizza by the slice and their Alfredo also good.

Mike Liu

I liked the variety of toppings they had as well as the crust. They can do half half but you have to call. Garlic knots looked like a ton of flavor but was on the bland side however the dough was good. The boneless wings with bbq didn’t taste like bbq at all. Overall just okay.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 4

Mike L.

I've heard good tings about Omars and finally tried it. I called as I wanted to place a half half pizza and didn't see that option available online. 5 piece boneless wings (bbq): the boneless wings were all different sizes so there weren't really 5 of them. I didn't like the bbq sauce as it didn't taste like bbq sauce and was hard to say what flavor it was. garlic knots: they come looking very seasoned however I thought the garlic was on the bland side. the knots however were a nice consistency. 18" half bronx half garlic chicken: overall pizza was okay. I thought the crust was good and slices were large. Overall just okay.

Ruben Zuniga

The fave!? used to be! Don't use slice! They "Omar's" take no responsibility for mistakes. Stupid attitude..

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Load More